BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in:  UK
Front Page 
Northern Ireland 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Friday, 12 April, 2002, 08:55 GMT 09:55 UK
Black and Asian workers 'underpaid'
Asian workers
Black and Asian women earn a weekly average of 187
Black and Asian workers are paid far less than their white counterparts, and the government must act to address the problem, the TUC has claimed.

Average weekly UK earnings
White: Men - 332, Women - 180
All black: Men - 235, Women - 187
Caribbean: Men - 217, Women - 210
African: Men - 216, Women - 199
Indian: Men - 327, Women - 194
Pakistani/Bangladeshi: Men - 182, Women - 146

A TUC report says on average, black and Asian men are paid 97 a week less than their white colleagues.

Pakistani and Bangladeshi men earn 150 per week less than white men, while the difference is 115 for Caribbean men and 116 for Africans.

It also shows black and Asian women earn 7 per week more than white women - but the TUC says this is because they are more likely to work full-time.

The director of the Low Pay Unit, Richard Towers, told BBC News that within the same job, people tend to be paid the same.

The problem is that many ethnic minorities live in deprived areas and have to take jobs in low-paid industries such as textiles.

Factors such as educational qualifications, language and dependence on public transport also have an effect.

Changes in law

But the TUC says direct discrimination plays a part in the pay discrepancies in some workplaces.

It wants race relations laws to be extended from the public to the private sector.

It is calling for trade unions and the Commission for Racial Equality to be given the right to take collective cases on behalf of individuals or groups of members.

The TUC says the government should also encourage employers to regularly monitor pay data to ensure equality.

The CRE itself was more cautious on the need for a change in the law.

Beverley Bernard, deputy chair CRE
Bernard: Examples of discrimination should be submitted to CRE
Deputy chair Beverley Bernard told BBC Radio 4's Today programme the figures were "startling" but "mixed", and she would like to find out more before addressing the question of legislation.

In the meantime, she said, disgruntled workers had two options to tackle pay discrimination.

"Workers could join together under the same organisation to challenge this under the employment tribunal.

"Two, if there is sufficient evidence that discrimination is consistently going on in any organisation, the CRE is obliged to look at formal investigations."


The study, Black and Underpaid, is launched to coincide with the TUC's Black Workers' Conference, which opens in Southport on Friday.

These workers already suffer twice the levels of unemployment... and racial harassment

TUC general secretary John Monks

TUC General Secretary John Monks said: "New laws in the public sector... must now be extended to end the unfairness in pay for black and Asian workers.

"These workers already suffer twice the levels of unemployment, lack of promotion opportunities and racial harassment.

"Unions are seeking to work in partnership with employers and the government to end this disadvantage."

Commission for Racial Equality's Beverley Bernard
"The size of the gap is quite startling"
See also:

16 Mar 02 | Education
Black pupils 'under-achieving'
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more UK stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more UK stories