BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh
BBCi CATEGORIES   TV   RADIO   COMMUNICATE   WHERE I LIVE   INDEX    SEARCH 

BBC NEWS
 You are in:  UK
Front Page 
World 
UK 
England 
Northern Ireland 
Scotland 
Wales 
UK Politics 
Business 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 


Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

SERVICES 
Wednesday, 27 February, 2002, 15:16 GMT
Does prayer work?
The Archbishop of Canterbury, the Pope, and Metropolitan Athanasios praying together in Jan 2000
A holy trinity
test hello test
By Giles Wilson
BBC News Online
line
The world's religions got together a month ago to pray for peace. Has the planet seen any impact - and is there any evidence that praying works anyway?

There was certainly no shortage of good intentions, or of symbolism.

Just a month ago, the Pope led 200 religious leaders from round the world in prayers for peace.

The venue for this landmark occasion was Assisi - the place which, fittingly, gave the world St Francis and his prayer "Make me a channel of your peace".

Children praying for the victims of the 1989 Hillsborough football tragedy
Hands together, eyes closed.
And yet a month on, peace seems as elusive as ever. Dozens of Israelis and Palestinians have died. Worshippers at a Rawalpindi mosque have been gunned down. Fears of further conflict rose after President Bush spoke of an "axis of evil". Zimbabwe grows further from the world community.

The impact of the day of prayer is on the agenda in the House of Lords on Wednesday as crossbench peer Lord Hylton asks the government what conclusions it draws from the event.

It could scarcely conclude that prayers had been answered in any miraculous way. And it goes without saying that non-believers would not be surprised by that.

But for believers, whether there is any point in praying can be a complicated issue, crucially taking in two distinct aspects:

  • Can praying change "external" things, for example the weather?
  • Can it have an "internal" effect on the person who is doing the praying?

    Believers can answer the latter point for themselves, but the former point is more open to debate.

    Crude methods

    Some of the first experiments to try to answer it came in the 1800s, when the worlds of science and religion began to eye each other uncomfortably.

    Palestinian women praying in Jerusalem
    Palestinian women praying in Jerusalem
    The tests used crude methods, concluding for instance that prayer was proved by the long lifespans of royals - people who were much prayed for. These methods have been superseded by more rigorous trials.

    But, remarkably, many modern tests have reached similar conclusions. Professor Leslie Francis of the University of Bangor has studied 31 experiments (conducted to the "highest professional standards") into the effectiveness of prayer.

    The trials would typically take a group of hundreds of patients recovering from heart surgery, randomly divided into two groups, one of which is prayed for. None of the patients would know they were or weren't being prayed for.


    It depends on God being an intervening God

    David Laws
    "The findings are quite staggering," he says. "Studies show that patients in hospital who are being prayed for (even when they do not know they are being prayed for) are more likely to recover."

    But according to Dr David Laws of the University of Manchester the kind of prayer which asks God to do something is only relevant if you have a particular understanding of God.

    "It depends on God being an intervening God who breaks into our world and mops up our mess whenever we make one."

    Jews praying at the Wailing Wall in Jerusalem
    Jews praying at the Wailing Wall in Jerusalem
    That is a kind of God that Professor Francis says he would be uncomfortable with, since it raises questions that if God can intervene, why does he not do so to avoid more human suffering?

    But former cancer patient Mary Ligertwood, from Milton Keynes, believes prayer did play a part in her recovery.

    When she was found to have cancer in her breast, kidney and lymph gland at the age of 50, she was given a year to live. And yet within six months, she walked away free of the disease.


    People would ask me: 'Why are you so happy?'

    Mary Ligertwood
    Now 13 years on, she puts her recovery down to a combination of the power of surgery - she had five operations - and the prayers of her friends. But she does not consider herself to have experienced a "miracle cure".

    She does though consider it a miracle that the whole experience of diagnosis, surgery and recovery was for her such an enjoyable - and spiritual - one.

    "Again and again, people visiting me in hospital would say: 'Why are you so happy?' For me it really was a very wonderful time... There was no element of fear there at all."

    Peace prayers

    The inner effect on praying people has a bearing on prayers for world peace such as those said at Assisi, says Dr Laws.

    "For me it's not a matter of persuading God to do something, but of people praying for peace looking to become peaceful people. It starts with the internal effect and that, hopefully, will have an impact on the outside world."


    I'm not surprised research shows an impact on people who are praying. But the studies also show an impact on people who are prayed for

    Leslie Francis
    Lord Hylton says the fact of the religious leaders praying together was a significant statement in itself, and one which has made its own contribution to a more peaceful world.

    In particular, he says, a declaration the leaders made that their religions should not be used as pretexts for violence or wars could have a huge impact. He believes that even now, the religious leaders in the Middle East have become more inclined towards engaging with each other.

    Professor Francis suggests that should another day of prayer for peace be organised, subsequent levels of fighting should be monitored, as should people's perceptions of peace.

    Many religious people may feel however that having tangible proof is not really what prayer is about, and that - believe it or not - they rather enjoy simply believing.


    What are your views? Send them to us using the form below.

    Some of your comments:

    Looking for a response a month on, after only one day of prayer? If we want God to supernaturally act in our world, we need to show Him we're serious and pray regularly, hard and long!
    David Slater, Scotland

    I don't believe in God but I believe in the power of prayer and often ask my Mum, a catholic, to light a candle or "say one" for people I care about who are ill or having a tough time. I don't think you have to believe in a particular higher power to benefit from praying - which is simply a form of meditation or channelling your thoughts and energies.
    Sarah Wilson

    Prayer is not only a complete waste time, it's also degrading.
    Derek Watson

    I wish these people would get real. The sooner people understand that we are on our own, and that when things go badly praying to some mythical concept of a 'creator' isn't going to do anything. Think for yourselves and act for yourselves. Is this the dark ages?
    SK, UK

    What we can never know is how much worse things might have been had we not been praying.
    Maryla Carter, England

    The problem is we mistake praying as some form of 'wish list' to someone up above. The reality is that prayer is more about developing our relationship with God. We don't always see prayer answered but that does not mean prayer does not work.
    Mark Wigginton, Leeds, UK

    There is no more powerful thing in this world than the power of prayer. I used to be an atheist, but I became a Muslim over 7 years ago. Until you see and understand how prayer and conversation with God can benefit you, and until you notice that a prayer has been answered, you'll never understand its power.
    James, UK

    Asking "have prayers for peace a month ago worked?" is not a sensible question to ask, as who can tell the timescale God works on? What is certain if you talk to those who know God is that prayers are always answered, but not always in the way we might want or expect. Answers are not always "Yes", but also "No" and "Not yet - wait".
    Jenni Sparkes, Britain

    Who cares if it works or not? If it makes people feel better by praying then good luck to them. The only downside is if people think that's all they need to do to achieve anything. World peace or anything for that matter can only be achieved by working out what's involved in achieving it, calling that a plan and then implementing the plan. Prayer would only be an optional extra.
    Alex Keenleyside, England

  • Send us your comments:
    Name:

    Your E-mail Address:


    Country:

    Comments:

    Disclaimer: The BBC will put up as many of your comments as possible but we cannot guarantee that all e-mails will be published. The BBC reserves the right to edit comments that are published.
    See also:

    24 Jan 02 | Europe
    Pope leads world prayer day
    Links to more UK stories are at the foot of the page.


    E-mail this story to a friend

    Links to more UK stories