BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in:  UK
Front Page 
Northern Ireland 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Wednesday, 24 October, 2001, 19:12 GMT 20:12 UK
Rail firms may face crash charges
Scene of the 5 October 1999 Paddington rail crash
One of the trains passed a red signal
No one will face criminal prosecution as a result of the Paddington rail crash, but Railtrack and Thames trains could still face prosecution by the Health and Safety executive.

The Crown Prosecution Service said on Wednesday there was insufficient evidence for charges of manslaughter against the two companies or any individuals involved.

Paddington crash
The crash claimed 31 lives
But the BBC has learned that the companies could still be prosecuted - under the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 - over the crash which killed 31 people died.

Although prosecutions under health and safety law are regarded as lesser charges than manslaughter or gross negligence, the penalty available to the courts is the same - an unlimited fine.

Following the 1997 Southall rail crash, in which seven people died, Great Western was fined 1.5m after being prosecuted under the Act.

'No retribution'

More than 400 were injured in the crash near Paddington, west London, on 5 October 1999.

The Crown Prosecution Service has advised the British Transport Police that further investigations would not be justified.

Memorial to the crash victims
Victims' families are still pressing for safer railways
Martin Mimms, a spokesman for the Paddington Survivors Group, said : "I think survivors were prepared for no charges to be made. They are not interested in retribution."

The group's founder Pam Warren, who was badly burned in the crash, said: "What we want is a safer rail system and greater corporate responsibility."

But solicitor Louise Christian, who represents most of the bereaved, said: "My clients are devastated by this decision and we will attempt to challenge the decision in the High Court on a point of law."

The collision happened when a Thames commuter train leaving Paddington crashed almost head-on with a Great Western express from Cheltenham, after passing through a red signal.

The CPS investigation had focused on the training of Thames train driver Michael Hodder.

Training 'deficiencies'

It had also probed the actions of signal box staff, and the track and signal layout in the area.

The CPS said there were a number of "deficiencies" in the training which Mr Hodder received.

But it said it would be impossible to prove that he passed the signal because of negligent training.

Nor could it be proved that a director or senior manager of a company was personally responsible for the actual events that led to deaths.

The CPS said it could not prove gross negligence by the signalman on duty at Slough, even though he was slow to signal danger to the Great Western train, and no attempt was made to divert the Thames train.

"In essence the fault of the signalman may be expressed as just seven seconds' unexplained inactivity. We do not think that we could prove that this inactivity amounted to gross negligence."


A spokesman for the train drivers' union, Aslef, said: "Lord Cullen, in his second report into this tragedy, found that both Railtrack and Thames Trains bore a share of the blame.

"This corporate responsibility by the privatised industry should not be forgotten in the light of today's announcement."

Railtrack said it was continuing "learning the lessons" of the inquiry.

And Thames Trains said: "Safety has always been our number one priority...our main focus now is actually working through all the recommendations from the Cullen report and implementing them as quickly as possible."

The British Transport Police is expected to formally announce a decision on whether to drop its investigation in a few days, but the CPS advice effectively ends the matter.

Louise Christian, Solicitor for the victims says
a challenge to the decision is under consideration
See also:

24 Oct 01 | Business
Tough challenge for new SRA boss
24 Oct 01 | Business
Byers appoints new rail chief
15 Oct 01 | England
Paddington survivor honoured
05 Oct 01 | England
Simple ceremony for rail victims
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more UK stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more UK stories