BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in: UK
Front Page 
Northern Ireland 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Friday, 10 August, 2001, 16:42 GMT 17:42 UK
Nuclear blunder delays sub refit
Dry dock
HMS Torbay is been in for refit since 1998
Naval dockyard operators have admitted an embarrassing blunder during the rebuilding of a submarine's nuclear reactor.

A fault in the heart of HMS Torbay's reactor has been discovered only at the end of the three-year refit.

The entire reactor must be dismantled and rebuilt, causing a three-month hold-up at Devonport Dockyard in Plymouth.

The submarine had already been given a rededication ceremoney ready for a return to service, when the blunder emerged.

The fault should have been detected during rigorous tests that take place at every stage of a refit, which involves fitting a new core in the nuclear reactor and any other work that is needed.

Safety concern

The delay in completion will create a backlog of work on other vessels at Devonport Dockyard.

DML, the private company that runs the Royal Navy dockyard, said: "The fault is being investigated and will be fully amended before work proceeds.

"Safety is paramount in all our operations."

HMS Torbay
HMS Torbay had already been rededicated for service
The problem is understood to involve a faulty control rod drive in the reactor.

Once the rods and metal fuel plates have been inserted, the reactor is sealed and the rest of the submarine's power system built around it.

The flaw was discovered only when the reactor was ready for final sea tests.

Independent nuclear expert John Large said: "It's egg on the face for the navy that such a problem has been discovered after the boat has been finished.


"Someone does a test and says one of the control rods isn't working, and they have to take it all to pieces again.

"It's not only HMS Torbay that is taken out of action - it also takes up that dry dock and shunts the entire refit programme back."

Devonport Dockyard
Devonport Dockyard is run by a private company
HMS Torbay was one of four Trafalgar class hunter-killer sumbarines found to have faults in their reactor cooling systems.

The same fault controversially stranded HMS Tireless in Gibraltar last year.

Mr Large said: "When HMS Tireless came up it affected not only all the other boats with the same problem, but every boat waiting for a refit.

"They all got knocked back."

He said the oversight was extraordinary.

Rigorous checks

"With nuclear power, every single action is completely supervised and scrutinised.

"If you changed a nut and bolt, there would be several checks.

"If a defective piece of kit has got through, particularly in the reactor, it's very embarrassing."

The refit began in 1998 and the rededication ceremony took place in June.

The Royal Navy admitted that the refit had been delayed, but insisted that HMS Torbay would return to active service this year.

See also:

03 Aug 01 | Scotland
Dockyard announces job cuts
07 May 01 | Europe
Nuclear sub leaves Gibraltar
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more UK stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more UK stories