BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: UK
Front Page 
Northern Ireland 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Monday, 16 July, 2001, 15:05 GMT 16:05 UK
Anatomy of a backlash 1
Hype's love affair with the internet, and the backlash which followed, are remarkable chapters of our recent history.

In a little over two years, the worlds of media, PR, and corporate finance staged a breathtaking about-turn in their positions.

The mood changed from mild curiosity about online technology, to all-consuming fascination, to disenchantment and eventually outright hostility. Yet all the time, internet usage figures have steadily climbed.

Every day this week we pick a key moment in the shifting sands of opinion.

No. 1: Behold the revolution

October 1999

Martha Lane Fox, then a virtual unknown, is invited on to the BBC's Question Time.

As she took her seat on the panel next to Robin Cook, the then foreign secretary, Martha Lane Fox was no household name.

She was just 26, and the company she and a friend had set up,, was just one of the hundreds of ambitious, self-confident start-ups.

Yet that TV appearance heralded a hype frenzy. Her picture appeared in countless newspapers. She was dubbed the nation's best-known businesswoman. And her fortune became a topic of national conversation.

Lastminute sounded funky and the sort of thing the internet should be about

Richard Garvin, Question Time
She was literally half the age of the next youngest member of the Question Time panel. Now, looking back on the event, she admits the producers were "taking a brave gamble" on her.

But she used her youth and freedom from party politics to appear modern, fresh, and optimistic.

Her answers were popular - renationalising the railways, for instance - but she avoided sounding cocksure ("Things change so fast that something I believe today could be completely wrong by next week").

Number of UK newspaper stories about Martha Lane Fox by month
Richard Garvin, the Question Time producer who invited her to appear, remembers that they had wanted an internet character on the panel, and Lastminute had fitted because it sounded "funky and the sort of thing the internet should be about".

After the programme, he recalls, the feeling had been "thank God we got her then".

"She was the right face at the right time. Any later and we would have looked like we were jumping on a bandwagon."

But it was that performance which launched her as a business celebrity, he believes.

Star qualities

That she was attractive, an Oxford graduate, and posh (the Marquess of Anglesey is a great-uncle) help explain why she made so many appearances on the otherwise grey-suited financial pages.

And she used her media exposure not to preach to the converted net users, but to a slightly wary offline majority.

I am no geek, she would say. I know "peanuts" about technology. I am just like you, she would explain to people, and I'm excited about this net thing. Join in and don't worry about your credit card, it'll all be all right.

Lastminute: "funky and the sort of thing the internet should be about"
In the run-up to's share flotation in March 2000, there were also a fair number of columnists trying to burst her bubble. One wrote that "loathing Martha Lane Fox has become a national sport". "Most of us are already finding it pretty hard to cope with the Martha thing," wrote another.

The day the bubble actually burst in the UK was, it has been argued, the day of the Lastminute flotation itself.

And when flashy fashion shop went bust in May, amid tales of champagne and Concorde lifestyles, the message was firmly out. Not only was it too late to have your own billion dollar idea for a, it was also probably too late to make any money from buying into someone else's idea.

Out of the spotlight

But for Martha Lane Fox - who had said repeatedly she wasn't in it for the money - it was time for a batten down the hatches. She had said she wanted a chance to prove her mettle, and the downturn was it.

More than a year later, her company is still going - more than can be said for many of its contemporaries. But on the only measure of success which will really matter in the long term - can it make any money - the jury is still out.

There is a real inverse proportion to how people are using the web, and how the press are hyping it

Martha Lane Fox

Looking back on the hype whirlwind, Lane Fox realises its link with the real world of business was somewhat tangential.

"The hype surrounding the flotation just got wildly disconnected with actual consumer interest or need or use of this technology."

Frankly, she said, at the time of the share flotation, was tiny.

"Now, a year later, we're a much bigger business, much less risky. And yet you wouldn't know that if you either read the press or saw the share price.

"There is a real inverse proportion to how people are viewing the web and actually using it, and how the press are hyping it."

While this was going on, the UK internet audience rose strongly.

In January 1999 there had been 3.2m households online; by December there were 5.1m.

Your comments:

Add your comments or memories by clicking here - PLUS your comments in full

Fickle, fickle, fickle. I was a nerd. I studied Computer Studies before it was trendy (14 years ago). We were shunned by the cool (and scientifically challenged) English Lit./Sociology/Media Studies crowd. The members of that clique then went on to become journalists, hyped the internet and then jumped with glee as the bubble they had created "burst". Who knows/cares what their flavour of the month is going to be next? The internet will carry on unabated with or without the support of the press. Long live the nerds.
James, Scotland

The only problem with the internet was that the people with the money expected to much, to soon for to little. How many other industries (not companies) can you name that became profitable in only months?
Rob, London

I imagine the same sort of thing happened with other tech or comms revolutions... Then the next big thing come along, history is forgotten and the whole silly cycle starts up again.
Steve, London, UK

The whole "" hype was started by ill-informed journalists looking for a sensational and sexy way to write about what must have been a boring subject for them previously. As the mania and madness continued, even those who were more cautious (ie. most of the established IT industry) was forced to take part in the hype.
David, Ireland

Tomorrow: Suspicion begins to set in with the "old school net-heads".

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console

1. October 1999

2. Spring 2000

3. Summer 2000

4. December 2000

5. Spring 2001

Links to more UK stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more UK stories