BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: UK
Front Page 
Northern Ireland 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Monday, 4 December, 2000, 16:09 GMT
Catholics set up 'placenta bank'
Cardinal Thomas Winning
Cardinal Winning: "There is an alternative to embryos"
A research facility is being set up to try to find alternatives to the use of human embryos in medical research.

The Catholic University of Rome will establish a "placenta bank" on 1 January which it hopes will provide a more ethically acceptable source of stem cells.

These are the "master" cells that develop into the various cell types that make up the body.

Scientists believe that if they can learn how to control this development they will be able to regenerate damaged tissues and organs.

Embryo research may help Parkinson's sufferers
They believe research into stem cells could lead to treatments for diseases such as Parkinson's, Alzheimer's and insulin-dependent diabetes.

But many researchers say the cells must be sourced from embryos if the full potential of the technology is to be realised.

They also believe cloning methods should be used to make the embryos so that the transplant tissues they create are not rejected by patients' immune systems.

Researchers at the Catholic University of Rome hope they will be able to regenerate human organs and tissue without the use of embryos.

They hope that stem cells taken from adults, or a baby's umbilical cord, will provide the same results as those taken from embryos.

Cardinal Thomas Winning, leader of Scotland's Roman Catholics and chairman of the bio-ethics committee of the Bishops' Conferences of the UK and Ireland, welcomed the announcement of the new university facility.

At this stage the best science suggests the alternatives [to embryo stem cells] may not be as flexible, and might treat less conditions.

Dr Donald Bruce
Church of Scotland

He has been a strong critic of proposed changes to the 1990 Human Embryology and Fertilisation Act which would allow the use of embryos up to 14 days old in limited cloning experiments.

Cardinal Winning has written to all MPs asking them to consider whether cloning could be right when it involved the use of embryos.

Writing in a newspaper on Monday, Cardinal Winning said: "In recent months it has become increasingly clear that there is an ethical alternative to cloning using embryos.

"This involves the harvesting of cells either from an adult or from a new-born baby's umbilical cord.

"Such cells can then be "trained" to grow in the same way as embryo-clone cells and may offer the same hope of treatment without any of the ethical problems associated with cloning."

Dr Donald Bruce, of the Church of Scotland's Society, Religion and Technology Project, said he welcomed research into alternatives to using embryos.

'Exaggerated claims'

"I'm very sympathetic to what the Catholic Church is trying to do. But I am anxious no one makes exaggerated claims.

"At this stage the best science suggests the alternatives [to embryo stem cells] may not be as flexible, and might treat less conditions."

Dr Bruce said he would "reluctantly" support the approval of limited embryo research.

"The route to getting stem cells by other means, without embryos, may mean doing some limited research on embryos."

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
See also:

07 Nov 00 | Sci/Tech
Call for cloning research
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more UK stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more UK stories