BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: UK
Front Page 
Northern Ireland 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

The BBC's David Shukman in London
"This case leaves the islanders happy but the Ministers in a very awkward position."
 real 56k

Donald Anderson MP
"The Foreign Office overrode the claims of the islanders"
 real 28k

Professor Phillip Sands, International Law expert
"The judgement recognises the principle of self-determination"
 real 28k

Friday, 3 November, 2000, 16:26 GMT
Evicted islanders allowed home
Chagos islanders
Islanders lived a largely self-sufficient lifestyle
The UK Government acted unlawfully in sending thousands of Indian Ocean islanders into exile to make way for a US military base, the High Court has ruled.

The decision paves the way for the Chagos islanders to return to their home for the first time since the 1960s.

Islanders spokesman Oliver Bancoult, whose family have been exiled from there since 1968, called the ruling an "unforgettable moment".

"People who were unlawfully uprooted will be able to return freely and live in their homeland."

Chagos Islands
Paradise Lost: The main island is now an American airbase
Lord Justice Laws said there had been "an abject legal failure" and immediately overturned a 1971 order that bans the islanders from going back to the island.

Between 3,000 to 4,000 islanders and their families are living in exile on Mauritius.

Lawyers for the islanders had argued that the authorities "rode roughshod" over their human rights and their rights as citizens of the UK, leaving them with a burning sense of injustice.

Their application for a judicial review was opposed by the Foreign and Commonwealth Office.

The decision is an embarrassment for the government, who may now have to ask the Americans to leave their military base on Diego Garcia, the principal island in the Chagos archipelago.

Islander Louis Bancoult
Islander Louis Bancoult celebrates the victory
The Foreign and Commonwealth Office was later granted permission to appeal and given a seven-day "stay" before the courts' order takes effect.

The government is now considering its position.

Sir Sydney Kentridge QC, appearing for the islanders, had told the court at a hearing in July that the British authorities took steps to hide the truth from Parliament and the United Nations as the people of the Chagos archipelago were sent packing.

The islanders were "simply dumped on the dockside" 1,200 miles away on Mauritius and other faraway destinations between 1967 and 1973 and left to a life of distress and poverty which many were still experiencing, he said.

No compromise

Mr Bancoult said the islanders would not accept any compromise that might see them occupy the other islands in the archipelago, while the US continues to operate from Diego Garcia.

We have a fundamental right to return

Oliver Bancoult
"In our demands we have asked for all our islands including Diego Garcia. We have a fundamental right to return even if there is an agreement between America and the UK.

"Why should people from Singapore and the Philippines and elsewhere be allowed to go to work on Diego Garcia and we are not allowed return home to our motherland?"

Liberal Democrat foreign affairs spokesman Menzies Campbell said it was too late for the islanders to return home and urged the government to compensate them instead.

"This judgment is a matter of embarrassment to both the present government and its predecessors," he said.

But he added: "Return to the island would be fraught with great difficulties since the infrastructure has long since disappeared. The best solution now is for the government to offer generous compensation."

As part of the deal to acquire the site, the UK Government reportedly received an 11m discount off its US-made Polaris nuclear weapons system.

It also reportedly paid Mauritius 3m to take the islanders off its hands.

The islands, more than 1,000 miles from the nearest mainland, had been occupied by the local inhabitants - known as the Ilois - for 200 years or more.

Descendants of African slaves and Indian plantation workers, they lived a simple, largely self-sufficient lifestyle as fishermen, farmers and working in the coconut plantations.

The Chagos group came under British sovereignty when Mauritius, together with its dependencies, were ceded by France at the end of the Napoleonic war.

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
See also:

03 Nov 00 | UK Politics
The Chagos Islands: A sordid tale
16 Jul 00 | UK
Memories of paradise lost
24 Aug 00 | South Asia
Hope for Indian Ocean islanders
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more UK stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more UK stories