Page last updated at 09:38 GMT, Wednesday, 14 April 2010 10:38 UK

Giving power to the people

Light bulbs, Getty
The benefits of the net can be hard to sell, as with electricity

Regular columnist Bill Thompson thinks it's time to engage with the digitally disenchanted.

With the Digital Economy Act now law, a digital election taking place around us, and more media coverage of Apple's latest shiny electronic toy than anyone could read in a lifetime the sense that the world belongs to the wired can sometimes seem overwhelming.

One aspect of this digital triumphalism is a disturbing tendency on the part of the technologically privileged, a group of which I am clearly a member, to express incomprehension as to why anyone might choose not to be online, not to have home broadband, not to set up a Facebook profile or reveal their whereabouts through Rummble and not to tweet incessantly about their desire for the latest laptop, tablet or smartphone.

Long view

The reason may be that, as with any elite group, membership has its privileges but exacts a price. For the Inner Party in George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four it was the ability to acknowledge that the proles mattered, while we seem to have lost the ability to "decentre" and see the world from the viewpoint of another.

The term was coined by developmental psychologist Jean Piaget to describe something that most of us manage to achieve in early childhood but evidently lose as soon as we get a smartphone with an unlimited data plan, at which point we start seeing those who choose not to go online as "digital refuseniks" .

I'm not talking here about those who cannot get online either because they lack the resources or they live in areas of limited connectivity. Many groups and organisations are working hard to get them connected, and they do a great job in difficult circumstances.

Bill Thompson
I do firmly believe that the internet is one of the best tools on offer to create a better world, and that we need to work harder to get this point across
Bill Thompson
People like Helen Milner, the dedicated and effective managing director of the UK online centres , recently-appointed UK Digital Champion Martha Lane Fox, Gail Bradbrook at Citizens Online and Gill Adams at Digital Unite, which specialises in helping people over 50 use IT and organises Silver Surfer Day each year, are motivated, competent and effective, and we should all do what we can to support them.

But there are others who could evidently afford a computer and an internet connection yet choose not to take advantage of the opportunity to sign up and surf the web, and we should not neglect them.

If, as I do, you believe in the benefits to society and to the individual that come from being able to use online services and tools with confidence then making people aware of these benefits and changing their mind about what the internet has to offer is as much a part of the wider campaign for social justice as ensuring that everyone who is entitled to state benefits receives them in full.

And unless we can persuade them that it is worth going online we will all suffer, simply because real social change will only come about when everyone has access and everyone can use online services and tools.

Sales pitch

Part of the problem is that "selling" the internet to people who don't perceive their lives as lacking requires them to imagine themselves doing things which seem either trivial, boring or simply unnecessary, but this is an issue that has faced many technologies throughout the ages.

Phone and laptop, BBC
It can seem that the whole world is getting more and more wired.
There is a wonderful parody of a monk having to be taught how to use a "book" from the Norwegian TV show "Øystein og jeg" in 2001 that is now all over YouTube.

BoingBoing, the group blog that bills itself as a "directory of wonderful things", recently featured a pamphlet published in 1916 by the Milwaukee Electric Railway and Light Company that tried to explain why it was worth having an electric supply to your house.

Home electricity was a hard thing to sell because people used to gas lighting and the domestic equipment of the time simply could not imagine what electricity might be used for. As a result the focus is on the transformative power of the electric light, because it is easy to describe and easy to illustrate.

Of course the power cable that allows you to have light also lets you do many other things, and a hundred years later we can easily imagine electric versions of most devices, from toothbrushes to air conditioning, but those trying to sell electricity at the time faced a significant challenge.

A lot of the effort being made to promote the internet today relies on a similar strategy, focusing on the educational value of the net or the ability to have video chats with your grandchildren. It's understandable, but clearly ineffective for a small but significant proportion of the population.

Unlike 1916 when even the people selling electricity had no clear idea of how it might be used in the future we can tell much about the shape of the information society.

And we need to start talking about it in ways that emphasise the ability of the network-connected computers to improve our lives, help us build a sustainable economy that will not make the biosphere inhospitable and provide education, healthcare and a sense of community for all.

I am not blindly optimistic about technology, and I do not think that these benefits will come about simply because we all get online, but I do firmly believe that the internet is one of the best tools on offer to create a better world, and that we need to work harder to get this point across to those who see Facebook being bullied into adding a "panic" button to its website and believe that this is all the network can give us.

Bill Thompson is an independent journalist and regular commentator on the BBC World Service programme Digital Planet. He is currently working with the BBC on its archive project.

Print Sponsor

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Sign in

BBC navigation

Copyright © 2019 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific