Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: Talking Point
Front Page 
World 
UK 
UK Politics 
Business 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
Forum 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 

Thursday, 28 September, 2000, 12:30 GMT 13:30 UK
Are we heading for a car-free future?

Drivers across Europe were asked to leave their car at home Friday and walk, cycle or use public transport to move around.

It was the second car-free day organised by the European Union. They say sixty five million people across Europe will take part.

Motorist organisations have dismissed the campaign as a public relations gimmick, but environmental groups say it helps to raise awareness of the problems with our increasing reliance on the car.

Is this a glimpse of a car free future? Or is this day of action a waste of time? What will you be doing about transport today?

This debate is now closed. Read a selection of your comments below.


Your reaction


Leave us car owners alone and plan for renewable supplies

B. Martin, UK
Fuel cell engines are on their way. In 20 years environmentally friendly energy sources will provide cheap energy. So I say, leave us car owners alone and plan for renewable supplies
B. Martin, UK

Car-free day is undoubtedly a PR gimmick but it serves to raise our awareness of the issue at stake - environmental protection. While we should somehow lessen our dependence on cars, it's far better we make every endeavour to develop real, more environmentally friendly vehicles.
Kit Chai, Hong Kong

I think we can make great progress in reducing car use, especially in urban centres. Another Canadian claimed that public transport is not practicable in our country, due to the vast territory and cold temperatures. Rubbish! Most people driving cars are commuting within urban areas - it is not the few people in rural or wilderness areas who are causing air pollution and urban sprawl.
Maria Gatti, Québec, Canada

It would be difficult to rid the highways of the USA of their vehicles. We have a strong love affair with our cars and the bigger and more expensive and more gasoline they use the better it seems. I think it's time, perhaps past time, to get tough on the issue. There is no good reason for so many vehicles to be used every day on our highways.
George Britton, USA

I was fine using public transport until I came to live in London a month ago (from West Yorkshire). Now I understand why people use their cars in central London and withstand hours of queues.
H. Hussain, UK

I hope that the pro-car correspondents on these pages can feel proud of themselves when due to their selfishness, their children and grandchildren are living in a polluted wasteland. Being of the younger generation myself, I and others my age will have to live with the consequences i.e. global warming, flooding, droughts, air pollution etc, caused largely by today's motorists. Sadly it seems some people will wait until they are ankle-deep in water before they consider giving up their beloved motor cars.
Gareth Leah, UK


If you live in an area with excellent public transport, it's possible to be car free

Kate, England
If you live in an area with excellent public transport, or within a couple of miles of shops and work, it's possible to be car free. For anyone else, it is not at the moment, and without much more money being invested into public transport nothing much is going to change.
Kate, England

So if we all decide to leave our cars and pile onto public transport where is the money for hospitals and schools going to come from?
Ian Thomas, England

What angers me is the number of unnecessary journeys some people make in cars; 300 yards to the shops; half-a-mile to pick the kids up from school. If only people would think before they drive, congestion and pollution would be reduced, as would the amount they have to spend on fuel! We are lucky to live in an area with adequate public transport, and made a conscious decision to sell our car so I can speak from both sides. Two years later, we are healthier, fitter and considerably better off.
Paul, UK

I look forward to car free days, the freedom, the joy of being in your car whilst those suckers that fall this sort of government gimmick, are smelling someone else's armpit in a cramped and crowded train or bus.
William Lack, England

I live in heavily populated Northern New Jersey, and am have been car-less for ten years. I love it. I never realised what an irrational waste of money an auto is until I got rid of mine, and started walking and using public transportation.
Louis B. Massano, USA


Reading the comments of some of the pro car people here... you all sound so childish, its like someone's taking your favourite toy away

T. Gill, UK
Something has to be done to get us out of our cars... isn't that obvious. Things can't keep going the way they are. Reading the comments of some of the pro car people here... you all sound so childish, its like someone's taking your favourite toy away. (In a childish voice "My car! My car! Give me my car back.... Warrrr! Warrrr! Sob sob....) I hope you all live happy lives in your endless tail backs.
T. Gill, UK

Sorry folks I disagree with many of the anti-car sentiments expressed. For the majority of the world's population, the private car represents a huge step forward in their personal freedom. No longer bound by territory as dictated by the time it takes to ride or walk or by the governments of the nations of the world.
The one caution must be that right is exercised with care and we should be alert to and avoid unnecessary damage to the World's ecosystem.
Jimmy Johnson, UK

If petrol is so bad for kids why do parents insist on placing their children in schools other than the one closest to home and then driving them there? Alternative means of individual transport to the car - has anybody noticed the increasing numbers of powered two-wheelers about? True they burn petrol but motorcycles rarely cause gridlock and as a means of transporting one or two people it beats the car every time.
Jennie, England

I live in rural Hampshire, only 8 miles from my office. There is only one but an hour for a couple of hours in the morning and they are not running at the time that I finish work. I would ride my bike, but the A325 is the most dangerous road in the county!
Until this government put more into public transport, then when the infrastructure is in place, insist that people use park and ride schemes and trams etc, gridlock will continue.
Mark Beresford, UK


Due to the inconvenient routes my travel now has to take, I have to use the car more frequently

Hazel, UK
Until 1981 we were pedestrians who relied on public transport. What converted us to predominantly car users was a combination of expense and the fact that the reliability of the transport services was decreasing. As an ex-urban dweller, I would prefer to continue to use public transport, but unfortunately, due to the inconvenient routes my travel now has to take, I have to use the car more frequently.
Hazel, UK

In the days before cars, we had a huge infrastructure of horse breeders, saddlers, wagon makers, wheelwrights, smithies, coaching inns, to support horse-based transportation. We managed to discard all of that without grinding to a halt. We can change the entire car-based infrastructure if we want to.
Michael, UK

Give me cheap, frequent and reliable public transport and I will consider reducing my so-called dependence on the motorbike and car. The vast majority of society lives further away from our place of employment, our relatives and friends than previous generations. It will take a lot more than the occasional "car-free" day to reverse this process. I find it incredible that parents complain about the levels of pollution due to car usage. The decrease in traffic levels (on commuter routes at least) when the schools are on holiday seem to indicate that they are part of the problem!
Mike, Bristol, England

Will someone explain how public transport is expensive? I have just bought a car to get to work. Annual cost: £300 loan interest, £800 depreciation, £155 tax, £450 Insurance, £100 MOT/servicing, petrol £520. Total £2325. I'd love to go by bus, but I can't get there until 10:30 and would have to leave at 3 p.m. Mr Blair, please nationalise the buses and trains and give us back a decent level of public transport.
Nigel Wakefield, UK

No one is suggesting that we create a car-free society. City officials realise that many people have no other option than the automobile. But there are many people who DO have other options, and the whole purpose of the car free day was to introduce them to these options. The goal of the car free day is NOT to eliminate cars completely, but to reduce the amount of cars driven in our cities to sustainable levels.
Alexander Papanikolaou, Greece


Not many people are physically capable (or stupid) enough to pedal 30 miles home in the rain after a hard day's work

Paul Hicks, UK
No matter how the anti-car lobby tries, they can't uninvent the car. And it's no use claiming that cars are just "mobile egos" as one correspondent did. For starters 90% of the population find a car indispensable as a means of getting to and from work.
Let's not pretend we could all get by with a bike if we tried, because not many people are physically capable (or stupid) enough to pedal 30 miles home in the rain after a hard day's work. And you can forget buses as well. I live 45 miles from the nearest bus depot, and if I relied on the service we get here, I'd have starved to death years ago.
Paul Hicks, UK

We managed well enough for 5 million years without the car so I guess we might just manage it.
Neil, England

All these people predicting the end of convenient transport are just not being realistic. The car is so useful and convenient and invention that it will never stop being used. People seem to think without oil the car will be no more - that is just underestimating the power of human inventiveness. The car will be around just running on something else - Hydrogen is my fave with three times the power per Kg of Petrol.
C. Mclaren, UK


Motorism has become a kind of religion

Lars Werner, New Zealand
It seems to some people motorism has become a kind of religion and they like to burn everyone who dares to criticise their metal gods. Meanwhile, the costs of public transport have increased much more than petrol prices in the past decades. But nobody is blocking train stations.
Isn't it high time the governments in Europe and the EU promoted and subsidised the use of public transport. At least in metropolitan areas.
It's perfectly okay to use your car if you live in remote country areas. But I am fed up with those ignorants who reduce the life quality of our cities by blocking the streets each peak hour, pumping carbon monoxide into residential areas, jeopardising cyclists and pedestrians and using their car even for a drive to the local shop.
Lars Werner, Germany, currently New Zealand

It is a waste of time trying to envision how we might give up something that clearly most people desire to have: individual powered transportation.
True visionaries will try to find a way to deliver what is desired in a manner that solves the current problems with cars. In fact one should see an improvement in personal transportation - not a reduction in quality.
George Milton, USA


What about all the government revenues that are generated by the direct or indirect use of the motor car?

Tim, France
OK so we all agree that cars pollute, create gridlock and are to blame for many road deaths. So imagine what the world would be like if we all dumped our cars tomorrow and decided to walk, cycle or get the train/bus.
Well for a start all the car manufacturers would go out of business causing mass unemployment. (At least they won't need their car anymore to get to work.) Then all the associated manufacturing and retail businesses would go under as a result of our car free society. Who would need a car mechanic or car spares?(e.g. every branch of your trusty Halfords would shut down.) Who would need car sponges, car polish, car radios, roof racks, trailers, caravans or spare bulbs? (I work for a lighting manufacturer).
What about all the car insurance policies we pay for that would get cancelled. Doubtless many of these companies also manage your life insurance and pension plans. What about all the government revenues that are generated by the direct or indirect use of the motor car? Plus of course all the income tax and NI contributions that would disappear as a result of the millions of unemployed people. The list is obviously endless. I think the car is here to stay, don't you...?
Tim, France

I think our hope for getting the message over that we have to find alternative ways to move goods and people lies in the hands of the young and the intelligent. Visiting Paris over the weekend, what impressed me was the number of bright young professionals out there on foot, cycles and roller blades winding in and out among the frequently gridlocked traffic.
Simon Baddeley, UK


It's about time pro-car campaigners realised the depth of damage that the car-culture is doing to this country's social fabric and environment, and stopped burying their faces in the sumptuous leather of their mobile egos

Dave Strong, UK
Cars are the biggest singular cause of needless death, pollution and selfishness in this country. Whilst the ridiculous UK car culture continues apace, and the government carry on woefully under funding public transport, then we're in for much tribulation in the next twenty years.
It's about time pro-car campaigners realised the depth of damage that the car-culture is doing to this country's social fabric and environment, and stopped burying their faces in the sumptuous leather of their mobile egos (because let's face it - that's all cars are to most people), and got on foot/bike/bus/train to work instead.
Who knows, we may actually lose some weight through the exercise we'll get, and the chances are that if the government see more of us actually using public transport, then they might just be inclined to spend some of the untold billions we pay in fuel tax each year on it! We live in hope!
Dave Strong, UK

Realistically, we must find alternative ways of providing transport since oil supplies are not going to last half of our lifetimes. However, I think this will merely result in cars powered by different energy sources. Less pollution, but no less congestion. If only the railways were like Holland - Amsterdam to Utrecht, every 15 minutes till 1am, then once an hour between 1 and 5am. Even on Sundays, and its cheap.
Martin, UK

If the oil reserves get that low you can chuck away the business suit and ride your bike to the farm.
Roger Sayer, USA

Over the past few weeks, I've been close to giving up. But I'll keep banging my head against the wall, in the hope that one day, our government will see sense, and agree, (by saying it in public!) that petrol is bad for the environment, and for me and my children. And if driving your car is so, so important to you, you have my permission to move abroad. No, honest, go on¿
Vic, England

Car free future? And what will people use if they're not conveniently living near a rail link, bus line, or within walking distance, (re: everyone living outside the downtown area of major cities) go back to riding horses?
Stephen Kenney, USA


People in Athens always complain about air pollution and traffic; but on September 22, they chose to complain about the ban on cars

Anna Maria Venetou, Greece
Despite the recent achievements and ongoing efforts by our state to create better and improved public transport systems in our largest cities, several arrogant and closed minded people refused to leave their car and chose to complain about the car free day. People in Athens always complain about air pollution and traffic; but on September 22, they chose to complain about the ban on cars. That proves how hypocritical and backward-looking people can be around here.
Anna Maria Venetou, Greece

The problem is not too many cars - it is too many people.
Wendy, England

The closer to being unique a journey is the less practical public transport becomes. This means that away from the movement of the commuter hoards every rush hour public transport rapidly becomes uneconomic. There is a place for all forms of transport "including" the private car. For medium to long journeys where time is an issue there is no better transport than the car. We certainly need to seek cleaner alternative power sources for all motor transport, but to say 'everyone out of your car, henceforth you will use public transport' is an attack on personal freedom.
Richard, UK

Car Free! Never, it would be like saying building houses is bad for the environment so lets all live in caves and mud huts. I do cycle to work most days but between my wife and I we still own two cars and a motorbike. Freedom of choice the Government can bump their gums all day about it but when was the last time you saw any of them tip up in Downing Street on a Bike or in a small economical car!
Tim, Wales

There is absolutely no reason why any of this should be a waste of time but the lack of publicity and governmental emphasis on events such as this 'car free day' doesn't hold much promise for a car free future. The government needs to take a tougher hand and if it can't take advantage of a simple day without non-essential driving - especially when it holds so much promise after the recent fuel crisis - then it certainly hasn't got the iron will to make any radical changes such as those that are needed. When the long-term (or even short-term) future of the world is at stake it is simply not rational to give in to public opinion.
Benj'min Mossop, UK


They will do anything which is not actually illegal in the pursuance of this profit

Phil, UK
What the motoring organisations think or say matters nothing since they are selfish short-sighted greedy businesses only interested in short-term profit for themselves. They will do anything which is not actually illegal in the pursuance of this profit regardless of the negative effect on others. And they claim to be responsible organisations! Instead of car-free day all new cars should be fitted with the exhaust pointing into the cars so that the drivers can keep all their precious fuel and its by-products to themselves.
Phil, UK

One day, when the oil runs out and America has bought up the last reserves, we will all have to get on without our cars. Unfortunately we will also have to live without many of our other comforts such as plastic goods made from oil (i.e. your computer) and nobody will be able to use bicycles because oil is used in the building process. Buses won't run without petrol. Trains will be the only effective form of transport. You can kiss goodbye to travelling by plane. It will be back on the boats, weeks of travel when it used to be just hours. And guess what, this could happen in our lifetime.
Anne, London, UK

What does not mix is motor vehicles and town/city centres. This can only be addressed by better public transport, which requires more public investment. The green lobby cannot make a logical case for alternatives to road for the movement of goods and longer distance private journeys, other than between city centres, because viable alternatives simply do not exist. Their assumption seems to be that a railway or bus runs directly between every home, office, factory and shop. I am sorry to say that it doesn't and never will.
Brian Worboys, U K


The current car-obsessed society we live in does not give us choice

Elly, U.K
What we would all like, is choice. However, the current car-obsessed society we live in does not give us that choice. Cheap, efficient public transport would encourage car drivers into buses -but people also have to take a broader view and stop being so selfish - travelling through London every day is a nightmare, sitting in traffic jams for hours while single drivers block the roads for hours. When we REALLY need to use cars we should be free to do so, but I wish people would think a bit more about whether they REALLY need to use their cars every time they do.
Elly, U.K

What a stupid idea!! All you Euros would be doing is giving these people who drive gas hogs (SUVs and V8 Pickups)a respite. While ya'll suffer they will keep on burning fuel like there is no tomorrow!! My auto gets 26 miles in the city and 36 miles on the highway per gallon. The SUVs and Pickups average 12 and 22 miles per gallon. Time to make them pay up!!
Eddie, USA

Like it or not, the world's oil supply IS finite and a day will come when there is no more oil and the car-culture will grind to a halt. I support the idea of "car-free" days because it is much cheaper and safer to use public transport. More Americans have been killed in car accidents in the last fifty years than were killed in Korea and Vietnam. The U.S. has spent more than $1.5 trillion on oil in the last fifty years.
Jeff, USA


Waiting for a bus in -30 C is not a very good feeling

Collin, Canada
Car free future, maybe in Europe, but then Europeans have no concept of the vast distances we need to travel, extent of temperature variations and complete lack of any public transportation here. Waiting for a bus in -30 C is not a very good feeling. I can see an alternative fuel being developed and I do hope it is soon.
Collin, Canada

Has anybody heard about "hybrid" vehicles. These use regular gasoline engines and batteries, which are charged as the car slows down. When stationary the engine is switched off, and electricity used to accelerate, when the gas engine comes on again. Here in LA a few friends of mine have them, and manage anywhere between 60 and 100 mpg! Honda, and Toyota make them here in the US, so I wonder when when they will be sold in the UK? Incidentally they cost about 12,000 pounds new, just in case they decide to sell them and rip you guys off. Just so you can ask for a fair price!
Napo, LA, USA

"Andy, England" has the germ of a very good idea. But government should take the lead. Give free passes to all government workers to ride mass transit to and from work. Maybe the private sector would then follow government's lead.
Tim Donovan, usa


In what respect are cars 'unsustainable'?

David John, England
The word that keeps cropping up here is 'unsustainable'. Why? In what respect are cars 'unsustainable'? Or is that a self-fulfilling prophecy i.e. by taxing drivers out of existence in order to pander to the eco-lefties? Cars are good. Mobility is good. The alleged harm to the environment is a pretext for an ideological left/green jihad against independence, freedom and prosperity. Fortunately, it is destined to lose
David John, England

It is very laudable if you live in London to use a bus or the tube, but what about elsewhere in the country? My parents live in rural Leicestershire. They are 8 miles from the nearest town. A bus comes once a week on a Wednesday. We have to be practical and ensure that those who live in rural areas are protected from policies designed to prevent car use, until a decent alternative system has been thoroughly implemented.
Gavin Pearson, USA

I believe that petrol powered automobiles will be phased out in favour of green alternatives (electric, hydrogen, etc). However, the car itself will not go away in this century. People have to right to freely travel anywhere they wish, and not on someone else's schedule. Until the transporter from Star Trek appears, the car isn't going anywhere.
David Easley, USA


Perhaps a more achievable goal would be car-free city-centres

Kristian, Canada
A car free future is pretty far fetched. Perhaps a more achievable goal would be car-free city-centres. This would vastly reduce emissions in already polluted urban areas, and make them more accessible to everyone.
Kristian, Canada

Yes, there will be are car-less future! That'll be the day when we all commute, do are shopping and pick the kids up from school in our little Spaceships. As for the question of whether individual transportation will be eradicated the answer is no!
Ben Snowdon, England

The personal automobile will be with us forever ... it may not run on fossil fuels, per se, but it's here to stay. This is just another EU gimmick, doubtless dreamed up by some euro-geek, lost in the nightmare of "sameness": We all take buses/trains to and from our 35 hour a week job, and take August off to all vacation together in some hell-hole by the sea "somewhere" in the Med. Gee, don't you just hate these people?!?!?!
Mark M. Newdick, USA/UK


Cars provide an environmentally sound and sustainable solution to our long term transport needs

Essada, UK
What environmental problems caused by cars? It is now obvious that, with developing propulsion sources, cars provide an environmentally sound and sustainable solution to our long term transport needs. Indeed outside city centres they use far less resources per passenger mile than public transport. Unfortunately many of you correspondents still seem more interested in using last centuries envy politics to justify a feeling of morale superiority over car owners.
Essada, UK

This could never happen in the USA. Our country is to big for public transportation to solve all problems. I'm at college and I'm a 6 hour drive from home. This is short compared to most people from my high school. We have a country that is a few thousand miles from point to point and hundreds of cities spread out all over the place, some in very rural areas. We will always need something like a car here.
David, USA

Cars are a mass of waste. 90% of car usage is travelling around one's hometown, essentially going nowhere. The other 10% percent could be transferred to more efficient forms of transportation. However, as long as humans remain selfish and prefer comfort over conservation, "gas-guzzlers" will remain.
Drew, USA

The Sun newspaper this week stated that people had a right to drive cars. Having just returned from Barcelona seeing the car-free day being promoted, I find much of the right-wing newspapers attitudes towards such events as arrogant. Anyone who claims looking for ways of achieving a sustainable future are 'politically correct nonsense' are simple unable to look at an issue critically and intelligently and are happy to stick with their inherited prejudices and assumptions - perfect fodder for certain newspapers.
Tom, UK

Historical facts:
1. Cheap public transport works.
2. Infrastructure attracts expensive government bureaucracy.
3. Anything which takes longer than one term of government to do rarely succeed.
4. It takes far less intelligence to talk of stopping something (e.g. car use) than to actually build its replacement.
I'll keep on driving...
Clive Mitchell, UK


The bullying tactics of the fuel protesters which will could finally break the Thacherite Car culture in this country

Mike, UK
Motoring organisations are dismissive of car free campaigns because as more people chose to leave their cars at home the motoring organisations will see their influence curtailed.
All that is now required is a long period of intermittent fuel supplies to make many commuters change from their cars and motorbikes onto bicycles and public transport. In the past couple of weeks there have been far more bicycles on the road, including children on their way to school. Ironically though Car Free Day has brought the environment back onto the agenda, it is the bullying tactics of the fuel protesters which will could finally break the Thacherite Car culture in this country.
Mike, UK

Only the naive can believe there will be a car free future. The fuel crisis is artificial, caused by greedy OPEC members and governments who what to tax people to force them to live differently. Once the idea of freedom once again reigns supreme the car will return.
Richard T. Ketchum, USA

I think a better idea would be a "public transport free day" when for one day the providers of public transport run their services for free. This would be a good indicator as to the amount of people who would choose to use public transport if the costs were reduced.
Andy, England


I would prefer to see my children grow up asthma free and with the consideration for other human beings that is so blatantly lacking in the motorist's lobby..

Steve Knowlson, UKe
Comments from individuals such as "David, UK" never cease to amaze me. They bring a whole new dimension to the concept of selfishness. The FACT that the internal combustion engine causes unsustainable damage to the environment, the air that we breathe and the FACT that thousands of people are killed and maimed on the roads every year seem to pass the likes of him by. I would never classify myself as a "right on" Green type, I simply see this as an issue of sustainability and common-sense. I would prefer to see my children grow up asthma free and with the consideration for other human beings that is so blatantly lacking in the motorist's lobby..
Steve Knowlson, UK

You will only have a car-free society if we roll back society to live, work and behave as we did over 150 years ago. And let's face it that won't happen voluntarily but only when oil runs out and we are forced to.
Rob, UK

Probably not car-free, but distinctly car-reduced. Today's patterns of car use will be looked back on in the same disgusted way that we now look back at 17th century open sewers. One day we will realise the utter madness that is that the death toll, pollution, noise, social division and economic stranglehold that results from depending on our cars for virtually every journey we make and designing our whole built environment for cars rather than people.
Neil Gall, Scotland

I have a car-free life. I walk to work and back each day, a round trip of about three miles. Out of concern for the environmental impact of the internal combustion engine? No, it's because I can't afford to run a car! I hate dirty, crowded, unreliable public transport. Given the choice (and the money), I'd travel by car any day.
Henry Case, UK


Any move to get people out of their cars is a complete waste of time and energy

Andrew J. Chisholm, UK
The simple answer is NO.
Last weekend I organised a long-standing walking trip to Dorset. Needless to say, people were worried about getting there due to the fuel crisis.
I researched and informed everyone going that there was a good rail service to near our destination. And then arranged a lift for anyone who decided to go by train.
I was ridiculed and, in one case, sent an abusive e-mail in response to this suggestion. People decided not to go at all if it were not in their cars.
In the light of this, I am now convinced that any move to get people out of their cars is a complete waste of time and energy.
Andrew J. Chisholm, UK

It doesn't take a genius to predict complete apathy on the part of the British public to this enterprise. They will be reliant on the car until oil runs out or until this country's appalling public transport system is overhauled. If Tony Blair will not reduce fuel tax, he should use the extra revenue to provide motorists with an efficient and low cost alternative.
Richard, UK

Why must people look for absolute solutions? Perhaps a more realistic aspiration would be to provide an effective, efficient transport system and let the people choose between traffic jams and public transport: then we would have the best of both worlds. Equally if ways were found to move freight by rail in a cost effective, timely and efficient manner this would attract many of those heavy loads from the long haul routes up and down our motorways.
John Brownlee, England

Today I drove to work as usual; I had no alternative. I wish the small number of woolly-brained car-haters had less publicity given to them until they can answer the question, "How do you replace the 94% of journeys taken by road with a cuddly green alternative?" I wish they would put up or shut up.
David K, England


I hadn't heard a thing about this

Ian Dugdale, UK
I hadn't heard a thing about this. Until there is a change in lifestyles i.e. working at or nearer to home, and better UK public transport, private cars will always be preferred when taking into account, cost, time, convenience, and personal safety.
Ian Dugdale, UK

I live on a cul-de-sac of twenty houses in a small village in rural East Yorkshire. There are a total of 49 cars in the drives of these houses every night, making an average of 2.45 cars per household. We have an excellent public transport provision with at least one bus per hour all day every day of the week to both Hull (20 miles) in one direction and York (7 miles) in the other. These buses serve the majority of small villages and market towns in the area, so why on earth do people need so many cars?
It is not an overly-affluent area and I would wager that car numbers per household in the village have doubled in the last 10 years. I assume car ownership has more to do with status than with real need, the need to show the neighbours what you can afford to put on your driveway. One word sums it up - unsustainable.
Dave Hay, UK


We just don't seem to have the right infrastructure yet

David Finch, UK
I recently lived in Munich for a few months, and the public transport was brilliant. Everything runs frequently, on time and the time-tabling and tickets are integrated across all forms of public transport.
On returning to the UK, I looked into the feasibility of leaving my car at home and found that the timing and connections were impractical and the cost is just too much. In the UK we just don't seem to have the right infrastructure yet.
David Finch, UK

A pathetic gesture. Until the geographic separation of home, work and suppliers of provisions is reversed, we will continue to rely on personal transport, of which the car is by far the most convenient.
Chris Klein, UK

Errrm ... what European Car-Free day? Yes, I fully support these sort of campaigns in principle, but it would help if people actually knew this day existed. I didn't until now, and I'm sure I can't be the only one.
CNS, Durham, England

We really need to plough serious amounts of cash into public transport. Trams, monorails, urban underground railways. However, where will this cash come from? We need to think long and hard about our transport. A reduction in traffic would be great, but I think unachievable.
Alex White, UK


A car-free Europe? I hope not, otherwise how will I ever get anywhere?

Pete Morgan-Lucas, UK
A car-free Europe? I hope not, otherwise how will I ever get anywhere? Public transport as it stands is not an alternative - ever tried catching a rural bus after midnight, or getting a train to mid-Wales?
Mobility is a basic human right - we should be promoting it - in all forms - car, bus, plane, train, rather than trying to reduce it. I'm driving 150 miles today.
Pete Morgan-Lucas, UK

The transport day is going to be a splinter in the eye of all macho motorists who drive the cars mostly because it makes them feel important and in control. The cars ruin our streets with noise, pollution and physical danger, they isolate people rather than connect. Cars are needed of course, but this is way too much.
Christian, UK

Today I'm using the car as normal. I believe that public transport would grind to a standstill if everyone left their cars at home. As an example : the train from Southampton to Portsmouth consists of 3 carriages, but the motorway is packed every morning and evening. If everyone was to use public transport instead of their cars, a lot of people wouldn't be able to get to work.
Steve Wehrle, UK

Why doesn't the EU organise a "Plonker-Free Day", when, just for a brief period, politically correct nonsense like this will be banned?
David, UK

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
BBC RADIO NEWS
BBC ONE TV NEWS
WORLD NEWS SUMMARY
PROGRAMMES GUIDE
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


Links to other Talking Point stories