BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific
BBCi NEWS   SPORT   WEATHER   WORLD SERVICE   A-Z INDEX     

BBC News World Edition
 You are in: Talking Point  
News Front Page
Africa
Americas
Asia-Pacific
Europe
Middle East
South Asia
UK
Business
Entertainment
Science/Nature
Technology
Health
-------------
Talking Point
Forum
-------------
Country Profiles
In Depth
-------------
Programmes
-------------
BBC Sport
BBC Weather
SERVICES
-------------
EDITIONS
Tuesday, 17 December, 2002, 12:20 GMT
Venezuela protests: Your experiences
Talking Point: Venezuela
Anti-government protests have brought Venezuela's oil industry to a virtual halt.

Captains of ships carrying oil cargoes have dropped anchor and refused to continue to ports, while Venezuela's largest refinery was said to be "virtually paralysed" by the walk-out.

The protestors want President Hugo Chavez to submit to a referendum on his rule.

Mr Chavez has ordered the military to secure refineries and tankers in an attempt to maintain the flow of oil, which brings in most of the country's revenues.

Deputy Oil Minister Bernardo Alvarez warned that the stoppage could generate "irreparable damage" to the stability of Venezuela, the world's fifth-largest oil exporter.

Have you been affected by the Venezuelan strikes? Send us your comments.


This Talking Point has now closed. Read a selection of your comments below

Poor Venezuelans are becoming poorer

Brian Toth, Baltimore, USA
Chavez should not be concerned about giving in to the opposition, he should be concerned about doing the right thing for his country. Although he is a populist, he is not at all helping out the masses; poor Venezuelans are becoming poorer and there are more and more of them. He should realise that he has failed in his attempt of the "Bolivarian revolution", and save some face by resigning and calling for new elections.
Brian Toth, Baltimore, USA

The real problem is not Chavez, but the deep class and racial polarisation Venezuela suffers.
Jorge Moreno, Philadelphia, USA

I was in Caracas until I and others were obliged to leave on Tuesday 10th December because basic amenities were no longer available. My hotel was close to the Altamira square. What I saw and heard convinced me that the protests were artificial. The Venezuelans I met in the normal way were open, warm-hearted, good-looking people shocked at the ill-state of their country. Those protesters I heard and saw looked like hired thugs.
David Lawn, Euskirchen, Germany

Chavez is not the cause of the problem, he is a symptom of it

Mark, USA
I have been to Caracas only twice but seeing this island of wealth in a sea of poverty, it was obviously an explosive mixture. All one has to do is visit the 80,000 seat racetrack that puts Churchill Downs to shame and then look at the countless shacks on the mountainsides outside Caracas where millions of peasants live in abject squalor and hopeless poverty to know that something is very wrong. Chavez is not the cause of the problem, he is a symptom of it.
Mark, USA

It is sad countries in the world are doing nothing to avoid the killing in Venezuela. We are paying the price (deaths), you will pay some too (oil prices).
Boris Barrios, Pto la Cruz, Venezuela

Please help Venezuela human rights. Our freedom is in danger. Support is all we ask for new elections before is to late.
Horacio Velutini, Caracas, Venezuela

Venezuelan protests are not only from the oil industry, but from all Venezuelans. I do not understand how the international news show a distorted image of our problem, where the government appears as a victim fighting against a group of rich people, when in reality 80% of the population want him out. My town was completely empty today proving that opinion pulls are correct.
Josse Gonzalez, Maracaibo, Venezuela

Here, from a small state capital things have a different perspective than in Caracas

Daniel Duffaud, San Felipe, Venezuela
Here, from a small state capital things have a different perspective than in Caracas. People are months behind Caracas as far as "protest" techniques. Yet, we are catching up. The time of 8 p.m. has become and unbearable time when the now daily "cacerolazo" starts (pan drumming is the standard protest form). We are also a little bit afraid that as not a main area we will run out of stuff fast, hoping that because actually we are a small area we might not exhaust our supplies of petrol and food as fast as bigger areas. Fortunately so far we have not had the amount of viciousness between fractions observed in some areas of the country. How long we'll be blessed is anybody's guess.
Daniel Duffaud, San Felipe, Venezuela

There is a pattern of readers from outside of Venezuela writing in favour of Chavez. Unfortunately they have been exposed to the Venezuelan Government propaganda, paid with the taxes extracted from the Venezuelan middle class that Mr. Chavez has vowed to obliterate with his "circulos bolivarianos", a bunch of common criminals. So to set the record straight with those readers (like the one from Malaysia), no, Mr. Chavez is not a peace-loving democrat, Mr. Chavez is a left over communist that wants to destroy his country as it is and turn it into a second Cuba, with the help of his friend Fidel Castro. So my foreign friends, don't believe everything you hear from the Chavez government. Instead, try and help the Venezuelan people by sending Chavez questions about why he refuses to have the deaths of April 11 and December 7 2002 investigated.
Gualterio Bamberg, Caracas, Venezuela

This massive never-seen-before strike isn't just a game. We're more than 85% of disappointed Venezuelans who were tricked by this government and won't let it go on with its communist obsolete and unworkable ideals; last Friday three more people died in an awful and disgraceful massacre whilst protesting in a peaceful protest against the dictator Chavez. How many more deaths shall we carry on our shoulders to get rid of this man with his thirst for power? No turning back. We will regain our democracy.
Jonathan Kebe, Caracas, Venezuela

Only about 30% of the population still wants Chavez to stay, people who say that the opposition is made of the upper class has to do some research and calculations. The number of Venezuelans living under the poverty line is about 80%.
Carlos, Caracas, Venezuela.

The strike is creating a dull sensation among the inhabitants of Venezuela. Anything could happen, because there is no regard for the people. President Chavez doesn't care whether the country collapses, otherwise he would have submitted and let the democracy carry on in our country. However, we must calm down and ponder about all this, otherwise the outcome will be plain unpredictable.
Rafael E. Marín, Caracas, Venezuela

I understand that the poor people need help, but Chavez is not helping anybody except himself. You cannot help people by taking away from others, who have worked very had to give food and a home to their families, to give it to some people who is standing in the way waiting for the government to give them help. Democracy is easy to say but hard to put into practice. I'm very sad to read that we are crying for help and there are still people who don't believe that people who support Chavez are bad people who want to live as the rich without working for it. The good people who supported Chavez are now against him because they realise he isn't going to do anything for the poor.
Maria Beatriz, Caracas, Venezuela

What a sad moment for Venezuela! By our vote and by our ignorance we gave Chavez a mandate. But it is still our mandate as he is there to serve us. We now have the obligation to see that this communist tyrant leaves. Remember the start of our national anthem: "Gloria al Bravo Pueblo que el Yugo Lanzó", our brave people will again liberate the country. Liberty today, democracy tomorrow!
Carlos, Texas, USA

I cannot believe what is happening in my country. I'm a 25 year old professional with a dream to live in a country with peace, and Chavez doesn't let us. What he says and what he does stimulates and supports violence... I'm crying for help! I don't know what else can we do when our human rights have been violated by Chavez's goverment, and we don't have any credible institutions to ask for justice. Things are getting very bad in Venezuela!
Mergil, Caracas

I'm going to fight for the freedom of my country

Noemi Obenza, Caracas, Venezuela
Chavez is the worst president that the Venezuelans have had. He is destroying our country. I agree with the strike, it's the only way we have to show the rest of the world that the opposition is pacifistic. We want referendum and can be free of this tyrant. I don't want Venezuela to become like Cuba. I'm going to fight for the freedom of my country.
Noemi Obenza, Caracas, Venezuela

It is amazing to see how some Europeans can easily talk about Chavez being elected democratically. Yes, he was elected with a majority, most of them now repentant; but he is not a democratic president. And don't tell me about the rich people fearing losing their wealth. I am just an oil employee, and this government is far from fighting corruption and poverty.
Leonardo Velasco, Puerto La Cruz, Venezuela

What can Spain do for Venezuela? Or do they not deserve our help? Many Spaniards emigrated from Spain to Venezuela in the twentieth century. The silence of the Spanish government about what is happening in Venezuela is very sad.
Juan Cordero, Canary Islands, Spain

Don't stand by and watch this beautiful country ruined

Carlos José Torres, Barquismeto, Venezuela
We do not deserve, as Venezuelans, the nightmare we live in every day. Please, help us to get rid of this president. My country is getting broken into small pieces. This is one of the best and most beautiful countries in the world. Don't stand by and watch it ruined.
Carlos José Torres, Barquismeto, Venezuela

I wish I could say that I am surprised at what is happening in Venezuela right now. Sadly, I am not. Chavez is where he is, not because he deserves it but because people had nothing else to lose. Chavez's only qualification is to have led a failed coup back in the early 90s. I have no doubts he will be out of power soon. The question with an answer scarier than I want to admit is: who will be the next one in power?
Fernando Vega, Providence, USA

It's difficult to understand the Venezuelan problem from outside. It's true that Chavez was elected democratically by the majority of the people but, since he started to rule the country, we have had the worst political and economic crisis ever. If we let Chavez to fulfil his mandate there isn't going to remain a bit of democracy in Venezuela. He attacks all the media and the persons that don't support him. I love my country and I can not watch how Chavez is destroying Venezuela and promoting hate between brothers.
CTurco, Caracas, Venezuela

For the first time in my life I am marching against something.

René Pravia, Caracas
For the first time in my life I am marching against something. We are ruled by a group of communists we fought as guerrillas in the 60's against the democratic Venezuelan governments. They want to impose a communist system, aided by Castro and against our will. If the international community want to help us, good, if not, anyway we will overthrow this regime.
René Pravia, Caracas, Venezuela

I also wanted to say, this talking point has inadvertently excluded those Venezuelans who can not afford to browse the internet, and cannot afford to learn English. That is why it seems that Everyone in Venezuela wants Chavez out. This is definitely not the case! The only ones writing here are the rich kids enjoying their "strike" from school.
Adrian Aguirre, Juarez, Mexico

I'm very sorry my country is giving this impression to foreign nations. The government holds control of most of the information that escapes our borders, depicting itself as a fair government victimised by the rich and powerful. However, I can assure you that this national strike is a perfectly constitutional way of protesting to find a way out of this outrageous situation. If it is true that Chavez was once democratically elected, it is also true that he lost most of his supporters. I live in a very poor area, and most of the people I know are barely making ends meet. I myself have to moonlight to be able to pay the rent. Most of my colleagues, whose monthly salary was about $2000, now are being paid in food! Please, help us. We need to overcome all this before the situation is worse and more Human Rights are violated.
Isamar Carrillo, Caracas, Venezuela

Chavez was democratically elected, but he is not a democratic president.

Marcos, Caracas, Venezuela
True: Chavez was democratically elected, but he is not a democratic president. He constantly steps on the constitution by intervening otherwise independent powers, violating constitutional rights and ignoring the supreme court's verdicts. This is why a large percentage of the population has been willing to put their lives on hold for 5 days now, so he stops his authoritarian ways. We, Venezuelans, have the right to live under the rule of law, and within the limits it imposes defend any ideas we stand for.
Marcos, Caracas, Venezuela

I have read statements from people who live outside Venezuela and they all say one thing: Chavez was democratically elected , so why not leave him in peace? And it is true, he was fairly elected and in fact he won the elections by a vast majority. BUT, what happens when all that was promised during his campaign is never carried out? What happens when for the first two years of Chavez's mandate all of his efforts are put into getting as much power as he can? During his time as president the Venezuelan economy has plummeted, crime levels are at an all time high and the Venezuelan people have been divided into two separate bands; something never before seen in this country. We do not want to see our country turned into the next Cuba. We will do anything that is in our legal power to stop it, and we hope that we will receive support from the international community when and if this crisis is resolved.
Roberto, Caracas, Venezuela

We can't deny that all of us have been affected by this strike. It's the only option we have to make the government realize that we want Venezuela to be peaceful, democratic, and safe, but we are willing to pass through any circumstance as long as it bring us back the Venezuela we deserve. Democracy is priceless and economic consequences are not an obstacle to make us step aside.
María, Venezuela

We require help from other nations

Luis, Venezuela
Venezuela its a great country but with Chavez as a president the situation has gone pretty tough in many aspects such as political, social, economical, etc... I think we require help from other nations
Luis, Venezuela

Chavez is the only true president since he was elected to power. all of the people who oppose his regime are rebels and as such should be treated. They should have thought of everything before electing Chavez. Chavez is the answer and the key to Venezuela's future.
Federico Olivares, Venezuela

Chavez is a champion of the poor and the Indigenous Peoples. His constitution is one of the most progressive in the world. Its sad that the poor are yet again held at ransom by the elite through these strikes. I hope God hears the cry of the poor
Andy Pulung, Malaysia

We are losing our human rights

María Ortiz, Venezuela
We deserve a better life. Please don't forget we are here. We are losing our human rights, our freedom, our beautiful country. Venezuela's children will thank the world if you all help us.
María Ortiz, Venezuela

This is the most corrupt government Venezuela has had in one hundred years. Let us hope we get rid of it
Fernando Trigos, Venezuela

Chavez was elected fairly and democratically by the people, and is still supported by them. The reason he is in a strong position is this very fact. Unions are controlled by big business, and were probably pressed to go on strike. Why can't this man be allowed to fulfil his mandate? His administration has been attacked from day one by the forces of the corrupt right and powerful.
Nicholas Rice, UK

Chavez is a terrible president and should go but the fundamental problem in Venezuela is the lack of political opposition. Every time there is a presidential election the loser packs in his political aspiration and leaves no opposition to the president.
Douglas Gibson, Venezuela

I am of Venezuelan Nationality and I would just like to say it really is a shame that all these problems are happening in the most beautiful country I have ever been in. The people of Venezuela don't deserve this. Something needs to be done. the question is who will?
Sebastian Candelon, England

This is simply another attempt to destroy a democratically elected President

Martin, Wales
Chavez was democratically elected. The Right failed to overthrow him in a coup a short while ago. This is simply another attempt to destroy a democratically elected President who refuses to embrace the corruption and despotism championed by the old order. The fact that America wants to continue to exploit Venezuela's oil reserves is not a coincidence either. If we believe in democracy then only the Venezuelan ballot box can decide his fate, at the proper time - whatever business and Bush thinks of the decision. That's the way democracy works.
Martin, Wales

I'm a high school student and I haven't had classes since Monday, the day the strike began. It's been 4 days and the strike is still on. Despite this, nothing is more valuable than democracy and freedom, both being threatened by the authoritarian and communist-sympathising government of Chavez. I'll keep supporting the strike and I and my family will "stop" for as long as it is necessary to make my rights respected by the government.
Alexander Marzuka Venezuela

It is terrible to raise your kids under this regime that is taking away our liberties
Mauro Paez-Pumar, Venezuela

What can the world do for Venezuela? Or we do not deserve international help for our human rights? At this moment, the UN's Blue Helmets are welcomed in our country.
Hector Merino Venezuela

Christmas seems to have been put on hold.

Debby Kemball, Venezuela
It would be fair to say that every Venezuelan one speaks to is depressed, worried and anxious and Christmas seems to have been put on hold.
Debby Kemball, Venezuela

I've been marching ever since last year, because I want to have the opportunity to live a decent life. Not under a crazed "president" who wants to imitate Fidel Castro!
Alexandra Heyer, Venezuela

I believe in my country, I believe in God in I believe that Venezuela is going to be better when Chavez is gone.
Alejandro Perez, Venezuela


Key stories

Background

TALKING POINT
See also:

06 Dec 02 | Americas
05 Dec 02 | Americas
05 Dec 02 | Americas
23 Oct 02 | Americas
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Talking Point stories are at the foot of the page.


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Talking Point stories

© BBC ^^ Back to top

News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East |
South Asia | UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature |
Technology | Health | Talking Point | Country Profiles | In Depth |
Programmes