BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific

BBC News World Edition
 You are in: Talking Point  
News Front Page
Middle East
South Asia
Talking Point
Country Profiles
In Depth
BBC Sport
BBC Weather
Thursday, 19 September, 2002, 10:36 GMT 11:36 UK
Your reflections
A year on from the terrorist attacks in New York and Washington, the consequences are still being felt around the globe. What are your reflections on the first anniversary?

When a colleague, a friend, or a family member called to tell you about the news did you turn on your television or radio? What was your reaction?

Do you think the terrorists counted on New York City and Washington D.C. being major media centres to ensure that their acts of violence would be broadcast around the world?

Do you think that the global news coverage of 11 September keeps the day alive as an event orchestrated by terrorists or an event that should never be repeated?

Some of the comments below have been sent by viewers of our interactive TV service.

This Talking Point has now closed. Read a selection of your comments below.

America got a wake up call

Mark, USA
When I saw how extensive the damage was to the first tower, I figured it was probably terrorism. When I saw the plane hit the second tower I had no doubt. America got a wake up call. It had better answer that call by finding and thwarting all of it enemies if it wants to survive as a free and open society.
Mark, USA

It shouldn't be just America, the entire world should fight against terrorism.
Ram, Hyderabad,India

I was in denial over the collapse of the first tower, believing that it had merely been obscured by smoke. When I finally saw both down, I also broke down. Having been there last year and having bantered with the workers I met a few months before the tragedy, I could imagine the horrific repercussions of what happened. We on the other side of the world are still affected by the events of 11 September as well.
Red Plana, Manila, Philippines

I wish the Islamic world would stop criticizing the west

Marcus, Wales
I wish the Islamic world would stop criticizing the west, the people of the west live in a free society, (yes it has its problems) but at least we allow all people to hold their religions and beliefs without being persecuted.
Marcus, Wales

I am horrified at the complacency shown towards the fight against terrorism. It is disrespectful to all those that survived and perished.
Alison Bradford, Essex, England

I am so sad because so many people died for us to understand that only together can we change the world. I remember that when I heard what had happened I cried for all the people that were lost. I hope that what happened made us realise that life is short, and we must love freedom.
Yudoras Ane-Maria, Valcea, Romania

We should do anything possible to stop terrorism.
Luis da Silva, Porto, Portugal

Sept 11, 2001 marked a new understanding of the way mankind is living in a changing world.
Steve Padilla, North Highlands, CA. USA

All we can do now is pray

Anna, Ireland
All we can do now is pray. For the victims, for the families and for the cause. We must pray that something as horrific as this is never, ever repeated.
Anna, Ireland

My heartfelt sympathies go out to all the families of the victims of this terrible act of terrorism. Here we are one year on and the problems of the world remain. Even though we remember this terrible event we seem to forget that the root cause has not been stopped.
Nigel Heath, Bristol

I would just like to say I acknowledge & admire the American people's strength, hope, faith, healing, and courage. I pray for peace, love & unity.
Arman Masters, Storrington, West Sussex

All nations should be together

Sergey Bykov, Kazakhstan, Zyryanovsk
All nations should be together, and we should do everything we can to stop the terrorism.
Sergey Bykov, Kazakhstan, Zyryanovsk

I couldn't believe it was happening. It was a horror because the victims were almost all innocent civilians, including the passengers on the airplanes. The thing that had the greatest impact, however, was the immediate outpouring of support from virtually the entire world. I believe it was the first time in history that the world felt like one world, not a collection of countries. God Bless all of you.
Mary, Lynchburg, VA. USA

The sight of those planes crashing into the World Trade Center towers still makes me feel sick. My thoughts are with those who lost loved-ones in this tragedy. In the hope of securing world peace in the future, always remember 11 September.
Matt, Sherborne, UK

Peace be with you

Terry, West Yorkshire, UK
I was absolutely appalled by the horror that unfolded on the twin towers on 11 September. God bless America, and to all those that died, may peace be with you.
Terry, West Yorkshire UK

It was a very sad day in the history of mankind; the murderers in the name of god killed so many innocent people and destroyed the magnificent World Trade Center towers. The whole world is with America to grieve for the dead and to take revenge on the murderers.
Naveen V, Bangalore, Idia

12 months on it seems just like yesterday. Every time I see the pictures and hear the survivors and their relatives, I cannot help crying. To think that anyone could even think of such an act, never mind actually carry it out, is beyond belief.
John Cartlidge, Stoke-On-Trent;U.K.

I sit here with tears rolling down my face 12 months on

Vicky Speakman, Oxford, UK
I sit here with tears rolling down my face 12 months on it's not any easier, even though I don't personally know anyone involved. What pain must those who have lost a loved one be feeling? My heart bleeds and my mind can't comprehend. Much love to all.
Vicky Speakman, Oxford, UK

Last year I spent the day in a numb silent trance. I looked and looked and looked at those awful images on TV and they still did not register as true, sadly they were. I felt grief, sorrow and a great deal of anger towards these cowards who hide behind one of the worlds great religions.
Stuart Penny, Dunfermline, Scotland

My thoughts and prayers are with all those who lost loved ones. Hopefully time will help to ease the pain and heartache. Those who died, will never be forgotten, as they are very special people. Terrorism will never win as good triumphs over evil.
A Tyler Howells, Wales

I love America and I am against Terrorism committed by any one. I give assurance to American that God is blessing America always.
Mohd.Saleem, Pakistan

On September 11 I was in Washington DC as part of a trip out there to see my brother. In the last 365 days I have come to appreciate my own mortality much more, I hope that I continue to do so.
Rob Denholm, St. Helens, UK

I did not personally know anyone in either of the towers but from the news coverage I have come to feel a personal and very real feeling of grief for these people. It is especially hard now after all the additional stuff has come out about how some people chose to stay and help those who were injured. When the buildings collapsed it was heart breaking to realise that people are dying, and for what, all they did was go to work to earn money to support their families.
Sandy, Johannesburg, South Africa

I find it encouraging people share hopes of peace

Anon, Manchester, England
Like many people, being familiar with the city and having known people in the past who worked in the World Trade Center, the events of 11 September made me feel sick to my stomach. However, I find it so encouraging to read comments from other people around the world who share hopes of peace and understanding despite our differences.
Anon, Manchester, England

The acts of murder on 11 September are still too terrible to comprehend for me. "Senseless" is the only word I can find to describe them. I hope my country can see that the best way to defend ourselves from future attacks like this is to show the world that we still adhere to the ideals our country was founded on. Attacking and killing more people in the name of defending freedom is not the answer.
Mark, Detroit, USA

It was a day that will forever be etched in my mind

Mark, England
It was a day that will forever be etched in my mind. I was flying down over Spain at the time when we noticed that the stewardesses were edgy. It wasn't until we landed that the pilot announced that something terrible had happened and that we should be prepared for some horrific scenes when we reached our hotel. Needless to say, the return journey was very sombre and everyone was just glad to be home.
Mark, England

I really feel for all those children affected by the terrorist attacks in the USA. Most people do not contemplate the death of a parent until they reach old age. They have had to deal with this at such a young age. These children will be haunted for the rest of their lives with the images of that day. There is never any excuse for attacking the innocent, no matter who you are.
Claire, Southampton, UK

I was sitting at home idly watching TV when this began. I remember praying that it was not real. I rang everyone I could think of to find out if they saw it too. I remember sitting there with tears running down my face at the thought of all those people in the towers. There is NO justification for this.
Andrea Braid, Bristol, England

This event was a painful scar on the history of the world

Chris, Nottingham, UK
This event was a great tragedy, and a painful scar on the history of the world. All I can hope is that through our collective, pain, grieving, and realisation, we will resolve to make the world a better place.
Chris, Nottingham, UK

Everybody must learn from that tragic event that violence can not be stopped by violent retaliation. We all must learn to live and appreciate the lives of any nationalities, and resolve all problems diplomatically. God bless all people around the world.
Larisa Chernysheva , Canada

When the second plane hit, my only thought was that life will never be the same. I don't know how things will change, but they certainly will. My perspective since that day has become deeper and more contemplative. Gracious! What seemed so important at work on Monday, 10 September, became rather petty and foolish that Tuesday morning. The bottom line is that life goes on. Count on it!
Sharon, St. Louis, Missouri, USA

My heart goes out to all of those innocent victims

Maria S. Mendez, Miami, USA
My heart goes out to all of those innocent victims, as well as their families. I can not express how much sorrow I feel each and every time I remember what occurred one year ago.
Maria S. Mendez, Miami, USA

Among all the ceremonies that took place immediately after September 11, the one that struck me the most was the playing of the American national anthem by the guard in front of Buckingham Palace. As Americans, I think we have a belief deep down that because of our power, our arrogance, and a million other things, that we aren't really that well liked by pretty much anyone in the world. That one ceremony I think made a lot of Americans feel otherwise, if only for a moment.
David, San Francisco, US

The most healing event that took place after the terrorist attacks for me, was when people in other countries responded by saying, "Today we are all Americans." The unity felt was profound. Imagine the joy when we will no longer be separated by country or race or religion. No longer will it by "my" country, but "our" world and "our" peace. Blessings to all.
M.L. Foster, Danville, CA

Their memory and the suffering of the people of NY demands that the fight against terrorism be pursued to the end

Nigel Travis, Manchester, England
I am a 43 year old fire-fighter from England. I have just finished watching 9/11, the unselfish bravery of my colleagues in NYFD did not surprise me. They were giants among men, and their memory and the suffering of the people of NY demands that the fight against terrorism be pursued to the end. "It is better to live one day as a lion, than a lifetime as a sheep"
Nigel Travis, Manchester, England

I will remember 9/11 when my naiveté came to an end. At 18, I never believed anyone could commit terrorism on such a large scale. And that night, as I walked the dead streets of my town (which were usually lively) I realised I would never be completely safe from harm, no matter where I am. My thoughts go to everyone involved in the tragedy of 9/11, be it something we hope never to see again.
Andy McGovern, Skelmersdale, UK

Nothing to say but GOD BLESS AMERICA!
Zohaib Afzal, Canada

One year on and Al-Qaeda have proved they have achieved absolutely nothing by flying planes into buildings. They have left America warmongering more than ever and my prayer is for restraint as no other country should suffer what they have suffered.
Pete, UK

Whilst I think a lot about September 11th, I did not lose anyone in the tragedy and feel it is not my place to talk about where I was at the time, or what I was doing - this should be the prerogative of those directly affected.

Whilst we all need to vent our feelings, I think people like me without real grief should talk less and think more, truly go outside ourselves to try to feel for those present there on that day. When I used to go with my grandfather to war memorial services I didn't really know what the minute's silence was all about, but now I think I understand it so much more.
Ceri, Wales. UK

Horror, disbelief, profound sadness. No words can help the people who lost fathers, mothers, lovers, husbands wives and friends to come to terms with their loss. It is a hope which comes from the bottom of my heart that President Bush and Prime Minister Blair will not use the grief of so many to help promote the case for an attack on Iraq
David Howard, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil

My fiancée lives in New York. Although it was not likely he would be in or near WTC, on 9/11 it felt as though anything could happen. It was two hours before I could get through to him by telephone, during which I thought I would go mad. How much more so for the people who lost loved ones?
Jo, London, UK

Here in NYC it is very quiet, very serious and sombre

Fiona, NYC, USA
Here in NYC it is very quiet, very serious and sombre. Also there is a great spirit of optimism, we all know NYC will come through this.
Fiona, NYC, USA

Americans seem to be quite bemused by some people's attitude towards this event. I'm 40 and I grew up with bomb sites, both from German bombs and Irish bombs. I walked to work through Hyde Park across the spot where a few hours later a bomb killed some horses and soldiers. I remember the bomb in the burger bar, in railway stations, in the City, Manchester, innumerable bomb scares. For me, and I think for many, the terrorist threat is just fairly ordinary.
Steve, UK

Today my thoughts are primarily with the firemen and the families of those who died. My brother is also a fireman. You live every day with the fear that something will happen to them. It's a nightmare you pray will never come true. My heart and prayers go out to all of the 9/11 victims and their families, but the firemen and their families weigh heaviest on my mind.
Rebecca Stapleton, Nashville, TN

I recently went to New York on holiday and I was shocked at what Ground Zero looked like and how big it was and was very emotional near a church where there were messages and things hanging up. God Bless America. You are our heroes, our friends, and my prayers are with you always.
Jo Snow, Tonbridge, Kent

I am a firefighter and Union president for Local 3918 here in Connecticut. My thoughts on that day are like losing someone in my family... That day I lost 343 members of my family. Words cannot describe how I continue to feel. My heart goes out to the FDNY and I will never forget!!
Michael Osiecki Middletown Connecticut USA.

My best friend died in the first tower

Phil Turner USA
My best friend Simon Turner died in the first tower to be hit. He was heading up a publishing conference. The message that came back was "Simon is not coming home." This devastated me, my business suffered, my family could only sit and observe as I tried to exist from day to day hoping that the next day would be an improvement on the previous one, I cried myself to sleep every night or passed out through drinking too much. My wife was quite often woken up by me crying in my sleep. The crying has stopped now, time has helped, however the loss is still there, he was like a brother to me.

He left a wife and an unborn child who is now a happy little baby who will never experience his dad's unique sense of humour and personality. It's Simon's 40th tomorrow which will also serve as a reminder. How people have thought about doing a film I cannot imagine. Just seeing a hint of a disaster movie makes me depressed. I am not looking forward to 'one year on' and will do my best to escape the media on that day, but I can't escape my memories.
Phil Turner USA

It will always be etched on my mind. I saw the planes crash into the towers live and I felt sick and dizzy. I am a senior citizen and I live in England. As far as I knew there would be no one killed or injured who was known to me. How much, much worse for people not in that position. I am so very sorry for EVERYONE who was affected.
Ann Norris UK

I've never identified with my people before that day

Josef Grajova Denver, CO, USA
September 11 was the first day of unity that I have ever felt with all my compatriots. I've been all over the world and never really identified with my people before that tragic day. The feeling was revealing and one that I'll never forget.
Josef Grajova Denver, CO, USA

A year on from this tragic event I wonder if we truly have learnt the correct lessons from this attack. Surely we should be seeking peace throughout the world as a result, rather then starting more wars.
Liam Leane, London, UK

I was so shocked and saddened by what happened on September 11th. What we need to do now is remove that element of risk. If there's even a remote chance of Iraq or anyone else repeating such a travesty, deal with it now. Let's not have to say years down the line "If only we'd done something sooner".
Richard Welsh, Manchester, United Kingdom

I had never felt so vulnerable

Abi, London, UK
I'll never forget the moment when it dawned on the inhabitants of my office that this was not just the worst aviation accident we'd ever seen, but a deliberate attack. Despite being so far away I had never felt so vulnerable; it made me realise how much we take for granted.
Abi, London, UK

I was flying into New York at the time of the attacks. We were diverted to Halifax in Nova Scotia. I would like to thank all of the people and organisations who looked after us. There were more than 40 airliners diverted to Halifax but we were all treated wonderfully.
Mike McClory, Huntingdon, UK

I find it hard to believe that it's one year. May God comfort the bereaved families.
Vivian Paul, United Kingdom

The true nature and impact of that day can only now be measured

Steven Cadman, Glasgow, United Kingdom
What sickens me is people who say they are tired of hearing about the 11th of September. I would say that one year on, with the aid of hindsight, the true nature and impact of that day can only now be measured and analysed in order to prohibit further vile deeds.
Steven Cadman, Glasgow, United Kingdom

As humanity we must learn forgiveness, as humans we must never forget.
Andrew, Barcelona, Spain

We were pained and horrified by this incident.

Sumiran Tandon, Delhi, India
For India 9/11 should not have been a shock as in past years we all have been suffering these kind of disasters and deaths. But yet, we were pained and horrified by this incident. I myself couldn't sleep for days, just with the thought that in the US hundreds of people must be mourning for their lost ones.
Sumiran Tandon, Delhi, India

Thoughts and prayers, especially for those who lost a loved one - how can anyone forget 9/11? How can those who support those who perpetrated the atrocity live with it?
Eileen Arnold, Devon, England

I am a proud American who can't understand why so many in this world hate us. People everywhere need to understand that Americans are peace loving people. September 11, 2001, was a tragic and dreadful day for peace loving people everywhere.
Gary Stein, Minneapolis, USA

All this outpouring of grief smacks of hypocrisy, when we consider more people died in the revenge attacks in Afghanistan.
James, UK

Blair and Bush are doing the right thing. A stop needs to come to those who inflict pain and fear into millions
Mark, UK

Some of the most depressing but heartening footage was of fire engines, ambulances and police cars racing to help people. Looking at that footage now, one aches in the knowledge that they raced to certain death in the pursuit of helping others.
Adrian, UK

I don't know what disturbs me more; the memories of that awful day a year ago, or the prospect of the UK and USA invading Iraq to add to the death toll.
Chris, Brighton, UK

Having returned from Manhattan three weeks previous to the attacks on the World Trade Center, I was saddened and very upset as I watched the events unfold live. My thoughts are still with those who lost loved ones, friends and colleagues on that awful day.
Andrea Farley Merseyside, UK

I think America should not let these hijackers win and on 11 September they should carry on with their 'normal' day.
Louise Shaw, Keighley

I was listening to the radio and suddenly the music was interrupted and the presenter said a plane had hit the World Trade Center. I just assumed it was a light aircraft accident. Then it said another plane had hit and everyone knew something big had happened. I just sat in front of the TV in absolute shock. I was nervous on my journey home that night, as I felt what everyone did; vulnerability.
Shona Fraser, East-Kilbride

I was ashamed of being a Muslim

B Sait Bradford, UK
When I heard about the attacks I was shocked and ashamed of being a Muslim. I felt as if I had lost someone very close to me and I felt really down.
B Sait Bradford, UK

Witnessing what was unfolding on live TV was totally surreal. The vision of people jumping from the towers was a dreadful sight. My heart was broken because these individuals must have known that they had no chance of survival. What I was doing that day now seems so irrelevant. I pray that a tragedy on this scale never happens again.
David Torrance, Scotland

On seeing the news as it unfolded I feared Armageddon, I still worry about where things are heading.
James S, Edinburgh

I still get upset of the thought of these poor children who lost their parents, I pray for them all.
Alison C, West Midlands

I thought I had switched on to a film channel

Beth Hooper, Redditch, Worcestershire
I thought I had switched on to a film channel but then the full horror hit home. Out of the ashes of horror must rise the twin hopes of peace and justice. My thoughts and prayers will be with the people who lost loved ones, may God bless them all.
Beth Hooper, Redditch, Worcestershire

It goes to show you that today's wars have no borders. We also must not forget that while the buildings were in the US, people from around the world also died at the World Trade Center. We must not forget them.
Russ, USA

September 11th is the day when the way we look at the world changed

Jeroen, Amsterdam, Netherlands
The events that took place a year ago deeply affect me still, even though I do not know anybody affected. September 11th is the day when the way we look at the world changed for so many of us. My sympathy goes out to all victims, their families and relatives.
Jeroen, Amsterdam, Netherlands

I believe this event in itself is blown out of proportion, but I think it is a good day to think about peace.
Ian Cunynghame, Brae, Scotland

Such a great evil, so much tragedy, we will remember and honour them by looking forward with honesty and hope.
Hannah Brian, UK

We thought we were under attack on a national level. The President was somewhere in the air but couldn't land, there were hijacked planes still in the air.
Marianne, Madison, USA

I pray for an end to the suffering. All of it. The suffering of the families who have lost loved ones; the suffering of we the public, who will never get these images out of our minds; the suffering of the injured, whose limbs and lungs may never fully heal; and I pray for the desperate and tormented souls who believed that this act was holy.
Kathryn, Kentucky, USA

They have just finished the reading of the names. It took two-and-a-half hours. Longer than it took for both buildings to be struck and fall. I broke down when I heard the name of our friends. I hadn't cried even last year. I now wept like I never have before.
Philip, NY, USA

As a recent university graduate in 2001, I never thought I would check my university website to find a list of missing and "confirmed dead" alumni, separated by class year.
Marc, Boston, MA

I'll never forget what we lost on September 11th

Lori Mellman, Columbus, OH, USA
That day changed me greatly. My co-workers and I felt the great need to give something back to this world, something that was taken from us. A group of us volunteered to deliver Meals on Wheels to the elderly on a weekly basis. We've been doing this for almost one year now. I'll never forget what we lost on September 11th. God, please watch over us all.
Lori Mellman, Columbus, OH, USA

This anniversary is an opportunity for us all to remember what happened then, and reflect on how we responded to it in the last twelve months. This tragedy cannot, must not be used to justify the bombing of other cities in other parts of the world.
Matthew, Cambridge, UK

I am still enraged about the fact that the CIA and FBI both had the info about the attack and they couldn't do anything about it. So I don't know what else to say when so-called good networked intelligence agencies do nothing about verifying their info.
Sami, USA

You all showed a tremendous amount of courage

Stacey Hirlam, Leeds, England
My boyfriend and I had been at the top of the towers only a week earlier and we flew home on the 10th after spending two months there. My heart goes out to all those affected by the terrorist attacks, you all showed a tremendous amount of courage.
Stacey Hirlam, Leeds, England

We must never forget. Freedom often comes at a heavy price and as hard as it is we have to be willing to pay it for the sake of ourselves and our children.
Anton, UK

I was watching it on the TV in our office in Frankfurt. I had just finished saying that in 1993 it took three or four hours to get down after the bomb went off. As I finished the sentence our tower collapsed. I still sometimes wonder if it would have been different if I had said nothing.
Carl, London

I will never forget the 11th of September 2001. I couldn't believe my eyes, thinking that this can happen only in movies. Today, after a year since the tragic event, America should look forward and continue its path as a leader of peace, democracy and liberty in the world.
Gjilan, Kosovo

This is a very sad day for many people across the US. I hate that this had to happen but this is life. We all just have to stick together and protect one another from the ones that want to harm us.
Cyara Byears, Memphis, Tennessee

The worst thing was being half a world away from my family and not knowing what would happen next.

Chris Ransom, Colchester, UK
On Sept 11th 2001 I was away working in Hyderabad, India. I'd just got back to my hotel room and switched on to the news that a plane had hit the WTC and then sat in stunned disbelief as events unfolded before my eyes. The worst thing was being half a world away from my family and not knowing what would happen next.
Chris Ransom, Colchester, UK

As September 11th arrives again, it brings with it a poignant reminder of the human capacity to inflict pain and suffering on others in the name of political power and religion. It also brings with it a message of reflection on one's own individual life and the impact it has on others.
Sarah, England

Twelve months on the pictures still send a shiver down my spine. I'm flying out to New York tomorrow, and I'll take some time out of my holiday to think of those that lost their lives, and hope this kind of horror is never repeated.
Clare, Bristol, UK

9/11 has changed my life so much. My heart and prayers go out to all the people who lost loved ones last year. It makes me so sad to know people are having to endure this pain all over again.
Teri Wimbley, Blue Ridge Summit, US

I remember the rumours and the whispers cascading down the office. Once the news was confirmed, further whispers grew, telling us that more planes were on there way to London. I'll never forget the feeling that everything was beyond control.
Rog, Brighton, UK

I was driving along the motorway when the shocking news came over the radio. All I remember doing is pulling up to listen in utter shock at what was going on. My thoughts are with the many who lost their lives and to the families they left behind, still.
Mark Duncan, Salford, England

Words cannot describe my thoughts that day as I have never experienced mass devastation and lack of respect for human life. I had been to NY previously and the highlight of my trip was standing on the observation deck of the WTC. To reflect on the situation knowing the sheer size of the towers and masses of people working there brought a feeling over me that I would never want to experience again.
Paul Martin, Manchester, UK

As we all remember what happened last year, where we were and what we felt, let us also remember those who remain on duty today. Both those protecting us and those serving us. Living in Europe as I do, and as a British ex-pat, terrorism is not new to me and is something that I have lived with the majority of my life. However, it is a very different feeling I have this year with my wife flying into and out of America over the anniversary - despite the empty seats on the planes.
Gus, Germany

I have worn my New York t-shirt to work today, I work for the NHS. To remember and to commiserate.
Barbara, Southampton, England

I left work at around 3pm to pick my two boys up from school last year. The radio was on and I couldn't really make sense of what was being said and then it sank in. I drove a lot faster that day to get to my kids. Even though this was happening thousands of miles away, I felt very vulnerable and extremely scared.
Adam Underwood, Blackburn UK

I was on an international flight to Cancun from Gatwick and was approaching Boston when the first plane hit. Our plane was turned back and landed safely in New England, USA. Today brings back REAL memories for me of the poor people and civilians that lost their lives in such a cruel and bitter way. May God be with all the people who lost loved ones in the tragedy.
Simon Sharkey, London, UK

Its hard to believe that a year has passed already, I don't have any real understanding of politics or the Middle East but I constantly come to the same conclusion that September 11th is unforgivable, its impossible to find any reasoning or understanding behind this - what will always, always stay with me are the phone calls made from the passengers and workers in the Trade Centre to their families -and the feeling of anger that there was absolutely nothing that I could do but watch -
CC, Staffordshire, UK

My most chilling vision is seeing people jump from a tower block knowing that they would die. The terror of what they must have felt to do this is unimaginable. I hope any actions taken in the last year, and years to come, prevent anyone from having to do this, or face anything like it, ever again.
Glenn Bird, London, UK

The anniversary of 9/11 should be used as much as remembering the terrible acts committed by others. Anyone who believes the western powers are totally blameless is adding to the problem.
Toby Smith, London

Today has a special poignancy

Ian Hunter, UK
As a Royal Marine I watched the events unfolding with fear but with the knowledge that as a deliberate act, the world would never be the same again and that we as RM would be going somewhere soon to do something about it. Today has a special poignancy - it is also my son's birthday.
Ian Hunter, UK

I was driving alongside the runway at the main airport in the British Virgin Islands where I was assisting in the redevelopment of the airport, when my colleague got a call from his girlfriend in Australia saying a plane had hit the World Trade Centre. At first we thought it was just a light aircraft. We raced back to the site office to find people walking round in stunned disbelief. As the events unfolded I sat at my computer reading the news updates and wondered what could possess anyone to commit such an act and what they really thought it would achieve.
Pete George, Woking, UK

I was working on a British Telecom switchboard when it happened, and all I knew to begin with was a flashed message on screen telling of a 'terrorist bomb attack' in USA - and to give the Foreign Office hotline number to concerned relatives. For me the most harrowing experience was going back to the switchboard and speaking to a number of people who had or thought they had relatives or friends in those buildings, or in New York - the phone lines there were down and there was just total distress - and there was so little I could do other than comfort them and offer them another number to call where they would hopefully find out some more information.
George, Middlesbrough, England

United we stand divided we fall

Stephen Brain, London, UK
As I sit at my desk this morning, I have a nagging feeling at the back of my mind "what will today bring?" It is these feelings that terrorists play on, and one of the human rights that they try to take away from us. United we stand divided we fall.
Stephen Brain, London, UK

Asked where you were on September 11 2001, I reply that I stood next to John Kennedy's grave when the plane went into the Pentagon. To have been half a mile from the act of terrorism that destroyed 300 lives and the impact on all those left behind, I still cannot believe in the 21st century the human race has not become "civilised". I live in hope one day we can live our lives in peace and harmony.
Adrian Alderslade, Gosport, England

As a young American growing up today, I have conflicting feelings about that fateful day one year ago. I am angry, hurt, and feel a vulnerability that I never knew until September 11. But, in the same breath, I feel so very lucky. I am glad that I was fortunate enough to learn in my youth the fragility of life.
Jamie Thomas, USA

There are no words to describe this

Marie, California, USA
I was just getting the day started when our phone rang and our middle girl said "Have you heard from Lori?" (she is the youngest). We had no idea what she was so anxious about. Then she asked if we were watching the TV. We don't watch TV in the morning. So it was she who told us our son-in-law was safe as he is in the US Coast Guard and often is at the Pentagon. His office is at Coast Guard Headquarters elsewhere in the DC area. We switched on the TV and were stunned at what horror we were seeing right before our eyes! It was especially meaningful to me as my last active duty tour, before I left for the Reserves, at Headquarters US Marine Corps was located near the Pentagon. I could walk there from my office so I was familiar with the side of the building the aircraft penetrated.
Marie, California, USA

One year ago today, I was watching the events of 9/11 live, on a television set in our tea room at work. My feelings of absolute disbelief and horror were echoed in the faces of my colleagues, of all backgrounds. It was the first time that I have seen a group of South Africans so in touch with each other, about anything other than sport.
Mike, Johannesburg South Africa

Today I am afraid. The air force has stepped up patrols across our city, fearing attacks on the base or on the missile development plant. I have to go to class at the university, but all I'll be able to think about are my friends in New York, especially those injured and killed in the attacks one year ago. This day is a sadness I will never be able to dispel; everything has changed, and I am afraid of the change.
Justin, Tucson, USA

Those faces spoke volumes

Alice Thompson, Baltimore, MD
When the reports of the fallen firefighters started coming across the news reports, I found myself drawn to a firehouse in downtown Baltimore. My brother, a firefighter for many years, is a member of this house. I walked in to find the firefighters - many red eyed - huddled around the television. My eyes skimmed their faces and those faces spoke volumes of their lingering hope that the reports of their fallen comrades was somehow inaccurate or that reports of miraculous rescues would be forthcoming.
Alice Thompson, Baltimore, MD

Numb for several days, I wondered why I couldn't cry and when I would be able to. I cried, I bawled, when I heard of the turbaned Sikh killed in Arizona "in retaliation." A Sikh! If we don't learn more about other cultures, there will be no hope for humanity.
Beth, Bergen, Norway

I was in my local pub after work and they had Sky News on the tele. They always had the news on in that place, so nothing seemed odd. Then the horrible pictures started coming in and everyone started phoning their families to say "I love you" and stuff, thinking it was World War 3. What I find even more awful than the terrorist actions is the way that some people in Britain have taken it upon themselves to avenge Islam for it. Two of the people I was drinking with on that day were Muslims and they have had verbal and physical abuse because of it.
Al, England, UK

What happened on the 11 September was a terrible thing. Many innocent people died over nothing. Many people lost a part of their city, and many were traumatized by the pictures they've seen. No sane man can say that this was done for a reason.
Goran Andjelkovic, Novi Sad, Yugoslavia

The sneak attacks were not justified in any way

M Dawson, USA
I was on the phone with my friends in mid-town New York City and I have family in Washington DC & Alexandria. All of us feel that for all the issues others have with the USA, the sneak attacks were not justified in any way. Peace makers, not war mongers are the ones that are going to get us out of this mess.
M Dawson, USA

The biggest thing that struck me and still strikes me now is how helpless I felt. I felt that anything I did just could not help those that died, or those that survived. I just sat staring at my hands wondering what I could possibly do to make this never happen again.
Tony Ratka, Minden, NE, USA

I believe we should concentrate our efforts on creating peace in the Middle East rather than starting a new war.
Brian, Brighton UK

Those images of death and destruction are indelibly etched in my mind

Neal Richardson, New York, USA (ex-UK)
I was one of the fortunate ones who managed to successfully escape from my office in the WTC. Those images of death and destruction are indelibly etched in my mind. I found it incredibly pleasing to hear the overwhelming support from around the world at the time. However, a year later, I am thoroughly disgusted with not only the lack of global support, but the anti-American comments. So many people throughout the world fail to appreciate that their peaceful existence doesn't just happen by itself.
Neal Richardson, New York, USA (ex-UK)

The thing I remember clearest of my visits to New York City is the World Trade Center. Seeing them fall, remembering all the people that worked in there, made it seem even more gut wrenching to me. I wish we could all just get along with each other and rid the world of the kind of extremism that allows this type of thing to happen.
Anon, UK

My reflection is one of deep sorrow. My heart aches for those who lost their family and friends. It still amazes me that those people who claim that they are so close to God can hold such evil, inhumane and repulsive beliefs. I, myself, am a Muslim, they are not. They are not even human.
Kamyar Marashi, San Francisco, USA

We had friends working at the WTC and surrounding area; we had friends in DC, across the road from the Pentagon; we had friends stranded across the country, unable to get home as all the planes were grounded. We saw the smoke, and the ash fell on us for days. The US government and NYC government lied to us all about the safety precautions in place (or not), and thousands more people are looking at premature death from the toxic chemicals spewed out over the city. I have cried over and again for the close calls and those who didn't make it. And, like many of the bereaved families, I will not allow warmongering to go unprotested. That's how it's affected me - it's made me appreciate peace even more than before.
Kaz, New Jersey, USA

It's made me more appreciative of little things

Julie Brown, San Francisco, USA
Several of my friends worked in the first tower and were never heard from again. They were all under the age of 28. It was the first time in my life I was actually afraid to live in this country, it was also the first time I stopped feeling invincible and realised that anyone you know could leave you at any moment. It's made me more appreciative of little things, and just being happy to be alive.
Julie Brown, San Francisco, USA

I am married to an American and we both watched in horror as the events unfolded. I was at work and people were telling me the towers had come down, I simply didn't believe it until I saw it with my own eyes. My wife was shocked at what she was seeing, especially as we were due to fly to San Francisco 2 weeks later. We went ahead with our trip, but you could sense the change in feelings and unitedness from previous times. We will never forget that day! Footnote: Anyone realise that 9/11 is the US Emergency number? Just a coincidence or not?
Andrew Whitelocks, Hinckley, UK

I was at work that dreadful day when someone ran downstairs to tell me the news. I ran upstairs to the TV to see the second plane hit. I was shocked and horrified that anyone could want, justify and commit such an act. My heart goes out to everyone who was affected by that day. I am currently in NYC travelling America and I will be going to Ground Zero on the 11th to show my support for the American people on the anniversary of that tragic day.
David, London

My thoughts are with America

Jo Conroy, South London
I still feel sick when I think of the fear those people must have felt and the amount of good people that were lost. My thoughts are with America and all the families who lost loved ones. The search for Osama must never end.
Jo Conroy, South London

I remember distinctly being evacuated from the 57th floor of the high-rise I worked in almost as soon as I arrived to work.
Amanda, Chicago, us

11 September, 2001 was the most eventful day of my life! My wife was in labour on the 11th and our daughter was born the next day. To add to a difficult labour, we have friends who worked at, or near the World Trade Center. Thankfully everyone close to us survived, although one friend lost a brother-in-law and her home. Having a new baby is our inspiration to make this world a better, safer place for all.
Martin, USA (British ex-pat)

I will never forget the feelings of revulsion, sadness, grief, anger and shock

My friend called me and said "World War three has just started". I turned on the news and was totally horrified by what I saw. My husband and I sat, unable to speak, watching it all unfold, and I will never forget the feelings of revulsion, sadness, grief, anger and shock. What kind of world is my two year old daughter inheriting?

I watched the towers collapse from the windows of my living room here in Brooklyn. From my distance it was such a small sound that came over the water. Like crinkling aluminium foil. The wind was blowing in our direction so our street was covered with ash and paper debris.
Nick, Brooklyn, NY

Watching those horrific pictures on the news a year ago, I remember thinking that if I'd seen similar scenes in a Hollywood film, I would have dismissed them as unbelievable. How human life can treated with such contempt by some people, I will never understand.
Andrew Town, Taichung, Taiwan

Whatever happened that day gave me a chance to look closely at my life and the people around me

Najib Murad, Dallas, TX, USA
Whatever happened that day gave me a chance to look closely at my life and the people around me. I now love those close to me much more than I used to before September 11. Also, I feel for the people who encounter September 11 every day: In Palestine, Iraq, India, Afghanistan and so on. In these countries every day people are terrorised and killed. On Sept 11, we should pray for the elimination of terrorism throughout the world.
Najib Murad, Dallas, TX, USA

Things were happening so fast. The President was whisked away in Airforce One to a secure location, people were being evacuated from the WTC and people with no hope were jumping out of the windows and dying right before our eyes. The first tower fell and several minutes later, the second tower. Those poor people never had a chance. I remember thinking: "God, I know you are with every one of those people right now."
Margaret, USA

I remember thinking I would personally be going to war to get these terrorists

Tom, England
I had an optician's appointment after the planes struck the towers. I walked there in disbelief while those around in my village hadn't seen the news and were carrying on as normal. When I returned home the towers had collapsed and I had a feeling I have never had, it was a mix of sadness, anger and hatred towards those who did it. I remember thinking I would personally be going to war to get these terrorists. The rise in anti-Americanism since last year frightens me and makes me ashamed of those who fall into it so easily. We must remember that the Americans are our friends and not the extremists.
Tom, England

I can remember the anger and bitterness I felt at seeing the attacks. One year on, and I can't say the feelings have diminished. I have no desire to see Bin Laden, or any other terrorist killed. But I long to see the causes of terrorism destroyed. In spite of my best efforts, I can't bring myself to forgive the perpetrators of this evil act. America is too great a nation to be put down by these cowards. If anything, the bravery and resolve of this nation are only strengthened more. The terrorists have achieved the exact opposite of what they wanted to achieve.
S Gobinathan, Ft Lauderdale, Florida, USA

I worked in the World Trade Center in 1993 and 1994, so I am very familiar with the area. I took my wife to visit New York in February 2001, staying a block or two away from WTC, beside the World Financial Centre. We went up to the observation deck, something I never did whilst working there. I am stunned by the scale of the devastation. I have not been able to really take it in since my wife phoned me at work to say that she had heard reports of the disaster on the radio.
John Hunt, Bournemouth, UK

I feel as though I have aged ten years, not one

David Stuteley, Birmingham, UK
11 September is my birthday. I was thirty-three last year, but I feel as though I have aged ten years, not one. I can't find it in myself to celebrate at all, which my son finds difficult to understand. We tried to explain the media images to him, but he is bombarded with images of death and destruction every day. I have told friends and family that I would prefer it if we 'moved' my birthday to the twelfth in future.
David Stuteley, Birmingham, UK

After 11 September the whole world has had to learn that that the need for global peace must be strengthened.
Umaru Saccoh, Gambia

I was so shocked, I just sat and watched the news, the pictures of people jumping from the towers and then running for their lives as they collapsed just made me weep. It still makes me cry now, thinking about all those people who have died. I hope that everybody will focus not just on remembering the dead, but also on making sure nothing like this ever happens again.
Elaine Robinson, Bedworth, England

My wish on the eve of my son's 11th birthday is that we can start on a path of understanding, trust and a common love of humanity, which can leads us to peace. If we do not strive for peace and an understanding of all peoples, cultures and religions, what hope do we have for the future?
Michelle Jamal, London, UK

My heart goes out to the families of all those that died

Shaun, UK
I was watching the events at work a few hours after the incident and remember being deeply saddened that the world had come to such a bad state that people thought mass murder was their only option. Other than that, there was numbness and disbelief that took me a few days to get past. My heart goes out to the families of all those that died, but I don't think there's anything I can say to make their suffering any less.
Shaun, UK

I was at home watching it on TV, but as terrible as it was I could not switch it off. My thoughts go out to the people who were there and those who lost members of their family.
Alan Klein

I was in Washington DC working six Blocks from the US Capitol. I remember watching as it unfolded on TV. I could not believe what was happening and wondered who had committed this horrific act? The next night I was down in front of the capitol at a vigil letting the terrorists know that what they had done had not weakened us but it had made us even stronger.
S. Donnelly, USA

I will say a prayer and light a candle tomorrow

Alison Pearson, London, England
My husband and I were 40 miles away on Long Island on holiday. 24 hours earlier at 9.30am we were standing in the lobby of the North Tower. I guess someone decided our time wasn't up. I will say a prayer and light a candle tomorrow for the thousands of victims.
Alison Pearson, London, England

I watched last year on a screen inside one of the European Space Agency (an organisation dedicated to peaceful use of technology) sites in Italy. I can remember the shock on the faces of friends and colleagues, Swedish, Norwegian, British, Irish, Italian, the nationality seemed to matter not at all.
Peter H, NL

I just could not believe it was happening

Helen Ledger, London, England
I remember watching the events live on television at work. I just could not believe it was happening. I have been watching some of the news clips from the time and I still can not believe that it will be a year since this dreadful event took place. I now live for today and still fear what will happen next.
Helen Ledger, London, England

I was on honeymoon in Corsica and didn't find out what had happened until 2 days after the attacks!
Derek Rusell, Peterborough, UK

The 11th of September is of particular poignancy for my wife and I because it is our wedding anniversary. Our thoughts go out to those who remember that date for tragic rather than happy reasons. I support action against terrorism, but I also want to understand what causes it.
Robert McColl Millar, Aberdeen, Scotland

When I heard the news, at first I didn't believe it. When I realised it was true, I cried

Nicola Bromham, Bagshot, UK
When I heard the news, at first I didn't believe it. When I realised it was true, I cried. I think we should all hold the memories of September 11th in our hearts and minds. It should be a reminder to be more compassionate towards each other and a reminder that this should never happen again.
Nicola Bromham, Bagshot, UK

The terrorists were fully aware that the World Trade Center was the Titanic of our age, a triumph of modern engineering and a symbol of the technological advances of western society. To destroy them was to puncture the collective consciousness with a one in a generation disaster. Had they simply killed 3000 people there would have been outrage, but they destroyed symbols of our society doubling the impact that their attacks had. This reminded people of just how mortal we really are despite the great things we can build.
James Newman, London, UK

New York despatches





Links to more Talking Point stories are at the foot of the page.

 E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Talking Point stories

© BBC ^^ Back to top

News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East |
South Asia | UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature |
Technology | Health | Talking Point | Country Profiles | In Depth |