Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education

 You are in:  Talking Point
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Monday, 25 March, 2002, 10:29 GMT
What would your Desert Island Disc be?
Desert Island Discs will commemorate its 60 years with a gala concert from the Royal Festival Hall which will be broadcast on BBC Radio 4 on Saturday.

The popular radio programme has evolved gradually over the years, and has a simple format.

Each week a guest is invited onto the programme to select eight records they would take to a desert island.

The man behind the tropical idyll was Roy Plomley, who presented the show until 1988. The idea is said to have come to him after his coal fire went out in his digs in Hertfordshire in 1941.

Sue Lawley is the current presenter, and politicians vie with celebrities and great thinkers to appear on the programme.

Which disc would you take to a desert island?

This debate is now closed. Read a selection of your comments below.

Your reaction

An optimistic way to get off my desert island!

Murray de Schot, The Netherlands
It's got to be "Message In A Bottle". NOT that I'm particularly fond of either the song or The Police, but it may be an optimistic way to get off my desert island!
Murray de Schot, The Netherlands

Here's my eight::

1. Diana Ross - 'Ain't No Mountain High Enough'
2. David Bowie - 'Starman'
3. Dusty Springfield - 'Son of a Preacher Man'
4. Four Tops - 'Reach Out I'll Be There'
5. Frank Sinatra - 'My Way'
6. Shirley Bassey - 'This Is My Life'
7. Madonna - 'Vogue'
8. Beatles - 'Yesterday'

Colin, UK

I'd take the 8 longest songs ever written.
Martin, England

Any record by Diana Krall - that woman's voice is so suited to whiling away the hours on a desert island.
Kevin Jones, UK

It would have to be either Mountains of the Moon by The Shadows, or else their version of Crockett's Theme from Miami Vice.
David Hazel, UK

Fog on the Tyne featuring Gazza. Paradoxically it might keep you sane!!
Steve, UK

"You" by the band Gong. The album with something of everything!
Jim, USA

Appropriately, Beyond the Sea by George Benson

Toby Cottrell, UK
My choice, appropriately, is Beyond the Sea by George Benson. My one luxury would also be a short wave radio.
Toby Cottrell, UK

My disc would have to be Graceland by Paul Simon. Every track is well written and performed. It just chills me out every time I listen to it. It is my perfect vacation CD.
Emma, USA

It would have to be Parachutes by Coldplay. It gives me peace when I listen to it.
Lily Flores, USA

Why don't people choose some serious music instead of boring, moronic and repetitive pop records? Has the standard of taste completely disappeared? My pick: Bartok's Concerto for Orchestra - Chicago SO, conducted by Fritz Reiner (1955).
Lee Churchman, Canada

Disco II by the Pet Shop Boys. It's the only record I've ever danced to by myself - and I would need to do that on a deserted island.
Steven Roelofs, Chicago, IL, USA

Chuck Berry - Johnny B Goode.
Shaun, UK

Any eight you want to provide, as long as all eight of them are sung by Ella Fitzgerald.
Rucker, USA

Tough call. Either The Velvet Underground and Nico by the Velvet Underground, or Rain Dogs by Tom Waits. Blonde on Blonde by Dylan or The wild, the Innocent and the E-street Shuffle by Springsteen wouldn't be off-putting either.
Mark van der Born, The Netherlands

These are my eight. Special songs that mean so much to me, evoke many happy memories and put me in a peaceful, tranquil and sublime mood. And they bring a big smile to my face too!
1 Eternal Flame - The Bangles
2 Tropical Loveland - ABBA
3 The Sign and/or Life Is A Flower - Ace of Base
4 This Girl's In Love With You - Dionne Warwick
5 The Power Of Goodbye - Madonna
6 Right Here Waiting - Richard Marx
7 Michelle - The Beatles
8 Could I Have This Kiss Forever - Whitney Houston and Enrique Iglesias.
Tabitha Munzara, Zimbabwe

In no specific order
1 Hey Jude - The Beatles
2 Hey Joe - Hendrix
3 Layla - Clapton
4 Little Wing - Stevie Ray Vaughan
5 All Right Now - Free
6 Riders on the Storm - The Doors
7 Roxanne - The Police
8 When the Levee Breaks - Led Zeppelin
Michael, Canada

Every song is gorgeous

Will Bell, Canada
It has to be Hounds Of Love by Kate Bush. I can't believe this masterpiece is already over 16 years old. Every song is gorgeous, but the second side in particular would comfort me, alone on an island.
Will Bell, Canada

The Who - Live At Leeds.
Ash Newell, Texas, ex-pat Brit

I will be very happy to have a classical piece of music which lasts for about 59 minutes so that I can spend 59 minutes enjoying the music, 1 minute arranging to replay it repeatedly and still knowing that time has gone by hour by hour. Thank God I have not chosen the One Minute Waltz.
Teo Eng Leong, Singapore

It is a masterpiece and a classic

Geoff Walsh, UK
For me there is no finer representation of as many genres of music as George Gershwin's 'Rhapsody in Blue'. It is a masterpiece and a classic, and I would need nothing else.
Geoff Walsh, UK

Easy. Only one possible choice - Baba O'Reilly by The Who
Brian, England

The second Peter Gabriel album, known in the US as "Security."
Jennifer Ethington, USA

There can be only one choice for top record to take to the desert island. It has to be the Theme from Boss Cat.
Christopher, UK

When asked which of the eight you would choose, if one only was allowed, it would have to be "Every time we say Goodbye" sung by Ella Fitzgerald.
Godfrey Osborn, England

Just sublime

Gavin Clark, England
Either Flamenco Sketches by Miles Davis I can listen to this and hear something different in it every time or In the Garden by Van Morrison - just sublime.
Gavin Clark, England

Only 8 songs!!!

1. Mr Jones - Counting Crows
2. In my Life - Beatles
3. Watching the Wheels - John Lennon
4. Motorcycle Drive by - Third eye Blind
5. What I go t- Sublime
6. Otherside - Red Hot Chilli Peppers
7. Tears in Heaven - Eric Clapton
8. If 6 was 9 - Jimi Hendrix

Ads, UK

It would have to be Shiny Happy People by REM - this song never fails to cheer me up!
Karen, Wales

Has to be Bohemian Rhapsody for me.
Shaun, Teignmouth UK

Hmmm, eight tracks, tricky... but here they are..

1. Todd Rundgren - 'I saw the light'
2. Manic St Preachers - 'Faster'
3. The Hives - 'Hate to say I told you so!'
4. The Who - 'Won't get fooled again'
5. Mansun - 'Legacy'
6. Bluetones - 'Are you blue or blind?'
7. Focus - 'Sylvia'
8. Pickettywitch - 'Same old feeling'

And for my one item I would choose...rolling tobacco.
Tony, UK

Hey Jude from the best group in the world ever. It is just a brilliant song and evokes so many happy emotions
Joanna Preston-Wyse, UK

See also:

29 Jan 02 | TV and Radio
Desert Island delights
30 Dec 00 | Entertainment
Sue Lawley: 30 years behind the mike
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Talking Point stories