Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBCi CATEGORIES   TV   RADIO   COMMUNICATE   WHERE I LIVE   INDEX    SEARCH 

BBC NEWS
 You are in: Talking Point
Front Page 
World 
UK 
UK Politics 
Business 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
Forum 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 


Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

SERVICES 
Monday, 4 February, 2002, 17:44 GMT
Where should Margaret Thatcher's statue go?
An eight foot tall marble statue of the former British Prime Minister Baroness Margaret Thatcher is homeless.

Under current rules, a statue cannot be erected in the House of Commons until its subject has died.

The sculpture, which comes complete with a handbag, could be displayed temporarily in London or in Arizona - where Lake Havasu City has offered to look after it.

However, Conservative MPs are calling for the rules to be changed to allow the statue to be installed in Westminster for the 20th anniversary of the liberation of the Falkland Islands.

Where would you put the Iron Lady's statue? Do you think it should be displayed in Westminster?

This debate is now closed. Read a selection of your comments below.


Your reaction

The statue should be placed in her home town of Grantham, Lincolnshire, pride of place next to Sir Issac Newton. I think she had more guts than the sycophantic, playing to the gallery politicians that we have today. She did get a bit to big for her boots near the end though.
Steven Ashford, Great Britain


Just because she was memorable, doesn't mean she deserves to be alongside such legends as Winston Churchill

Pete, UK
Just because she was memorable, doesn't mean she deserves to be alongside such legends as Winston Churchill and Lloyd George. I think too many people remember her as memorable for all the wrong reasons for her statue to be displayed in what's meant to be a institution representative of EVERYONE in the country.
Pete, UK

I suspect that the reason that death is required before the statue can be entered into the house is to ensure that only the genuine greats are admitted. Lets wait a few more years to see if history's verdict on Mrs T is the same as her sycophants. I doubt it. In the meantime there must be a basement somewhere where it can be put away so that it doesn't scare the children
Barry P, England

Thatcher was one of the greatest PMs this country has ever known. In the face of major change in the global economy (including the onset of globalisation), she took a pragmatic view which included making tough and unpopular decisions and policies because she knew they would be in the interest of the nation. Just look at the way that London Docklands exemplifies the widespread regeneration of our inner cities through enhancing, rather than opposing, market forces. Maggie brought us into the modern age, making us the world's 4th largest economy as we are today. Wherever the statue goes, it should help those doubtful of her positive influence that the Iron Lady had all the resolve that this nickname suggests.
John , Reading, UK

Margaret Thatcher did irreparable harm to the UK. She made greed not only acceptable but fashionable. It had been neither before. She turned people against one another and she created a culture where value of community and family were superseded by a love of money, power and status. Most of my suggestions as to where to put the statue are far too rude to write. I don't want to remember her and I am sure that when she finally turns up her toes the pubs and clubs of Great Britain will be as full as they were when England beat Germany 5-1. Here, though, is one suggestion for the statue: melt it down, sell the metal and give the proceeds to the poor!
Michael Roberts, UK

The statue should be taken to Athens, Greece and permanently displayed in Acropolis in the same place Athena's statue once stood. Since the British Museum and Tony's government is not willing to send back what was stolen from Athens, they should at least send Maggie's statue. The Greeks can use a good laugh in these most difficult of times.
Dimitris, USA


How about the entrance hall of the new MPs office building, to replace all those massively expensive trees?

John, UK in USA
It is true that the UK needed a good kick up the backside in the late 70s. Maggie did this with some style. But then she went on to deny the existence of society, to remove the safety net of the welfare state wherever she could, downgrade the NHS, encourage greed and intolerance¿ and so on. Her legacy is in part a modernised, reinvigorated society (yes it does exist) and in part boom & bust and railway privatisation. On balance a necessary evil. The statue? Not in Parliament while she remains with us. Grantham is a good idea, or one of the major museums or public buildings? How about the entrance hall of the new MPs office building, to replace all those massively expensive trees?
John, UK, in USA

You foolish Brits who can't appreciate a great PM don't deserve her statue. Send her over here to the States where she is loved!
William Cooke, USA

Might I ask, why make a statute then you don't know what to do with it? To me doesn't sound like the reputedly forward planning British society.
R. Abila, Kenya

I am not a Conservative but I have to agree with Ralph Cook (below). Thatcher brilliantly masterminded the recovery of the British economy and Britain's sense of self-worth in Europe in an era when we had been wallowing in gloom and self pity as a third rate European nation. She did much to lessen the class divide by facilitating private enterprise among the poor and unemployed. Few would doubt the impact she had in ending Britain's growing isolation from America, or undermine her lack of dithering or compromise in a crisis. She took to heart the truism that in a man's world women have to be at least twice as good to gain the same approval. Let's do unto her what she has done for the nation: reverse the rules and give her pride of place at Westminster.
Simon Cameron, UK

I found an ideal location for the statue beside the M275 Motorway heading out of Portsmouth. The statue can stand on a plinth, next to a collection of warships that have served this country as much as she did, so as to inspire passing motorists with that Falklands spirit. The name of this location? John Pounds scrapyard.
Nigel Baldwin, Portsmouth UK

The State of Britain today is an expression of English culture. The reason London, Manchester and Birmingham look so run down and third worldish is the lack of ambition of the people who live in the UK. Margaret Thatcher attempted to drag this country into the 20th century. She wasted her efforts. Anybody with any ambition should emigrate to Canada, Australia or the US. Perhaps in 20 years when European culture prevails this grey 2nd world country may deserve Margaret Thatcher's Statue. Of course, most of the present residents will be dead from lack of decent healthcare, killed in a rail crash, or murdered for their mobile phone or car.
Finlay McMillan, Canada

Privatise it! break it up into little pieces with various parts going to each shareholder, proceeds go to the crumbled rail system and the NHS
Mark Coley, USA - ex-pat British

The first woman P.M. and one of the best since 1944. She has a place in history, her statue should be displayed prominently until it can obtain its place in Westminster. She was a little controversial, the Poll Tax, this though, although it could never become popular; applied correctly would be a fairer form of taxation than the current rating system.
Peter W. Pearce (Capt REME Retd), USA/UK

Love or hate her, she spoke her mind, so the perfect location the Statue just has to be Speakers Corner.
Klondike Pete, Canada

It is a crying shame that there is so much opposition to putting up the statue of Margaret Thatcher in Westminster. She is a unique leader, and one of the greatest, a modern-day Joan of Arc. Imagine if the American People cried out against putting up the Lincoln Memorial in Washington D.C. Failing all else, I'll be glad to take in Margaret Thatcher's statue and put it up in my backyard.
Jeff, USA


It's going to get defaced wherever its put.

Ruth, Scotland
Although undoubtedly seen as an egotistical, power crazy medusa by many, she was a strong Prime Minister when we needed her - particularly with regard to the Falklands War. As Tories want it erected to commemorate the 20th anniversary why not give it a temporary home in the House. Lets face it though, it's going to get defaced wherever its put.
Ruth, Scotland

I am 30, and so was relatively young when Maggie was at the helm of the UK. She did seem to get people working for themselves... the only thing I didn¿t like towards the end of that Conservative run was that they seemed to be moving further to the right with legislation like the Criminal Justice Bill, and I think that summed them up by that time - they had gone too far for the average person on the street.
Cam, UK


The statue must surely be kept in Grantham

Chris, UK
Don't change the rules. Memorial statues ought to wait for the death of the party. Thatcher deserves a statue, whether or not her policies are now popular - just as Churchill and Lloyd-George made mistakes, but were still great leaders. The statue must surely be kept in Grantham until it is appropriate to move it to Westminster.
Chris, UK (in Australia)

What about the Natural History Museum, amongst the other dinosaurs?
John Exell, England

Personally I loathe the cult of greed and selfishness she epitomises. However one cannot deny her influence. As a testimony to our British sense of humour I suggest that a similar sized statue of Ken Livingstone is produced and the two displayed opposite one another in some central London location.
Geoff Hanbury, Wales

Reading some of the comments about Lady Thatcher here it strikes me that she can incite some very passionate responses, both negative and positive! She had a resounding effect, then, on the British political awareness? Some memorial to anyone with or without a statue!
Pat Ellis, Wirral, England


Our city would love to take care of this statue

Travis, Lake Havasu City, USA
I think our city would love to take care of this statue and display it until the day comes that it can be moved back to its intended location. We have the Beautiful London Bridge here in Lake Havasu and this statue would fit here very well for all to see.
Travis, Lake Havasu City, Arizona, USA

I wasn't really a big fan of the woman but you must admit she knew how to control the house. Plus she was an excellent wartime leader (Blair could learn a few things about coping with war AND home issues). I think the statue should be displayed. She deserves to be remembered.
Richard H, UK

Why not put it in Tony Blair¿s' back garden? After all he seems to adore the woman enough to carry on her work through his policies!
Nigel Tregoning, Cornwall, UK

I agree with some of your readers that this statue should be placed in the chamber of horrors and that someone should start to work on one of Princess Diana, to be erected on the Mall, directly facing Buckingham Palace. Now that would be a noteworthy shrine to a beloved person and be a constant reminder to those occupants in the palace that this lady isn¿t going anywhere!!
Kaye, Canada

What a waste of a lovely piece of marble. There must be more worthy people who could have been sculpted!
Cathy Harrison, England

Westminster is the ideal place for a remarkable woman of Great Britain who was Prime Minister for no less than three consecutive terms from 1979 to 1990 and was robbed of her position by her MPs and not the people of Britain.
Vijay K Vijayaratnam, UK

Created a society based on self importance and greed rather than community which we are still living with today. The cellar of the Commons would be a great and fitting place where it can stand alone and therefore a mirror of the society she helped to create.
Mark, United Kingdom


Prime Minister Thatcher's statue should be placed in Washington DC, because we appreciate her more than the UK does

Marc Atkinson, USA
Prime Minister Thatcher's statue should be placed in Washington DC, because we appreciate her more than the UK does. I wish she could have changed her citizenship and run against Clinton back in 1992.
Marc Atkinson, USA

Lady Thatcher's statue deserves to be displayed in a prominent place until it can be moved into the House of Commons. She is the greatest leader since Winston Churchill. It amazes me how the leftist-socialist try to rewrite history in Great Britain. I wonder where the UK would be today without her 12 years in office.
Bart McMurry, USA

A great PM. I doubt it. Her big ideas were to reduce the role of the state in peoples lives and reduce the tax burden.
Instead all she could do was reduce her own surplus spending at the same time as selling off the assets. Hardly a stellar achievement, especially with the increases in VAT and reduction of higher rate tax.
That must've meant that the great majority paid more. In return we've embraced job insecurity as a way of life, we travel further and longer to work and when we get to work we work longer hours.

Govt spending as % GDP
1978-79 = 41.2
1980-84 = 44.3
1985-89 = 40.5
1990-95 = 42.0
A statue to these achievements, hah.
Gareth Husk, Canada

Thatcher may not have been the best Prime Minister in British history, but has anyone since been half as charismatic, or more inclined to speak their mind, no matter that their opinion is not "PC"? As for where to put her statue, somewhere near Parliament as a tourist attraction seems appropriate, at least until it can reside in the Commons. Perhaps her statue can be placed against one wall, with her "Spitting Image" puppet on the opposite wall?
Anthony M, UK


It's far more important to have a statue of W. E. Gladstone

Tom, UK
Don't change the rules. I dislike Thatcher strongly but I accept that she deserves a place in Parliament eventually. It's far more important to have a statue of W. E. Gladstone in place who was also a landmark political figure and who is still not represented amongst the other statues - although his great rival Disraeli is!
Tom, UK

I'm sure that the Natural History Museum would be delighted to have such a representation of this, soon to be extinct, breed.
Phil Hicks, UK

As one of, if not the greatest Prime Minister we've ever had, this Statue should take pride of place in Trafalgar Square along with our other national heroes. Thatcher turned this once lazy, work-shy, state-dependent country into a model of a modern state. It is only right that the longest serving Prime Minister of the last century should be celebrated. After all, if she was so unpopular why did she win three elections? She was, and still is a national treasure and it's a pity she can't step in and sort out the mess that 5 years of New Labour has created.
Andrew, England

It should be put somewhere out of reach. Otherwise I fear it would get the same treatment that the Churchill statue did only rather more rapidly
Matt Bailey, UK

Perhaps Gerry Adams has a space in his new office?
Philip Hicks, UK


This woman dragged this country kicking and screaming into the modern world.

Sven, England
Strange people, you lot. This woman, who may have at her time dropped spending and irritated the odd lefty dragged this country kicking and screaming out of the pre-war dark ages and into the modern world. This is the ONLY reason we are the 4th biggest economy in the world, have low employment, and generally an acceptable standard of living. I am in debt from being a student, it's life nowadays. This statue should be placed where it belongs - outside parliament for everyone to remember why we are so prosperous today.
Sven, England

The greatest Tory ever to live! The only Prime Minister that actually made policy decision that had some effect. We would be a Banana Republic now, if it wasn¿t for her.
James, England

The statue should go outside the main entrance to the Palace of Westminster. Maggie was a wonderful and strong PM, and should be visible to Tony Blair every day, to remind him what a good PM should be like.
John Atkins, England

In true Thatcherite spirit it should be sold off to the highest bidder to do with as they please. Proceeds could go to the NHS.
Steve, UK

We Americans appreciate a 'love me or hate me" personality, who shakes things up. From here is seems she said farewell to the welfare state, with all its inevitable proliferation and dumbing down of standards. Arizona may not be everyone's idea of America, but out west, we know what a "real" man with guts is - and she has 'em. The Arizona climate would probably be very good for the marble, preserving it until the English can come to terms with the '80s and 90's.
Bill Bartlett, U.S.A.

Her statue should be given a prominent home at the new Scottish Parliament building in Edinburgh as her governments policies were a large factor in encouraging the Scots to vote to bring about the creation of the Parliament.
John, Fife


Tony Blair is as much indebted to the Iron Lady as any Tory.

Ralph Cook, UK
You need to be in your 40's to appreciate the state this country was in back in 1979. If you can't personally remember that, do not presume to judge her! This country was then becoming both impoverished and ungovernable. Her later excesses not withstanding, Tony Blair is as much indebted to the Iron Lady as any Tory, and should be pleased to have the statue in the hallway of 10 Downing Street for as long as her continued survival keeps it out of Westminster.
Ralph Cook., UK

The Chamber of Horrors
Andy Brown, UK

I vote for its inclusion in the Chamber of Horrors, but failing that, if Arizona want it they can have it. Will they take the real thing as well?
Siobhan, UK

The public spaces of this country are so full of masculine heroes, its about that female achievements were celebrated... even if Thatcher's policies were appalling.
Peter Hemming, UK

A homeless Thatcher? Dump it in a shop doorway with a few copies of 'The Big Issue' and wait for the £20,000 Turner Prize.
Simon N, UK


She is the only Prime minister who wasn't afraid of the media!

Dan, UK
It should take pride of place outside the houses of parliament! She is the only Prime minister since I was born who wasn't afraid of the British media! She could teach the likes of Tony Blair a thing or two about being a real man and standing by his election promises.
Dan, UK

I would put it on top of her.
Alan, UK

Why not put in Grantham, where she was the constituency MP for so many years?
John, England

I could think of plenty of places. Sadly none of them printable.
Andrew Harris

Lady Thatcher remains one of the most significant figures, and certainly leaders in British 20th century history. It is time for these rules to change and for the Thatcher statue to take its place in the House of Commons.
Rory McKnight, UK

Why does a statue of Margaret Thatcher even exist? I think it's an insult to have this standing anywhere, as it represents someone with extremist views towards isolation and intolerance, which have no place in today's society.
David Bell, England

Why change the rules?
Parliament prides itself, rightly or wrongly, on adherence to tradition. Changing the rules to accommodate a statue of Thatcher seems terribly like political points-scoring by the Tories.
Colin, London


Crush it into chips and use it for something sensible.

Jenny Radcliffe, Durham
Speaking as someone who watched public spending drop throughout her childhood because of Maggie's policies, who is now in tonnes of student debt because of her legacy, I think that the best thing to do with this statue is crush it into chips and use it for something sensible, like renewing paths in a municipal park or something.
Jenny Radcliffe, Durham, UK

I would answer but I'm afraid my response would be too rude!
Kirsty, UK

It would make a great companion for the angel of the north, in an area where her policies had the most profound lasting effects. I can't say it would last long though.
Alan Wood, UK


In Aldershot, the home of the Parachute Brigade who gave so much in the Falklands war

John, France
I believe Mrs. Thatcher was one of the great Prime Ministers. She rescued UK from the grip of the Trade Unions and started to eliminate the Welfare culture. She also stood up for Britain in the EU. Therefore I think a suitable public place should be found for her statue in Aldershot, the home of the Parachute Brigade who gave so much in the Falklands war or indeed Portsmouth as a tribute to the Navy's contribution.
John, France

Paint it to be life like and place it on the English side of the Channel tunnel . Anyone trying to get through illegally will decide that they'd rather go back than face the iron lady herself.
Pete, Wales

In my honest opinion, this statue should never go into the house of commons based on her disastrous government. I believe in judging someone by his/her merits, and the simple fact that she was our first female prime minister does not mean that she did a good enough job to warrant a statue in her honour, before or after her death. The only other people with statues in the house of commons are Lloyd George and Winston Churchill, both of which gave an excellent contribution to our country. Margaret Thatcher, with her "no such thing as society" ethos, did not so as such does not deserve the huge honour that several (I would imagine almost all conservative) MPs want.
Chris Nelson, UK

I wouldn't mind seeing it in the Commons right away. However, that's a dangerous precedent to set given the current PM - there'd be wall-to-wall Tonies in a heartbeat - Tony bringing Peace to the World, Tony slaying the Dragon of Terrorism, Tony Walking the Waters of the Channel (euro in hand), Tony Healing the Sick...

The thing to do is to put it either where she's best regarded, or where it would annoy the most people. So that's either Port Stanley or Brussels. Votes, anyone?
Sean, France


Stand it proudly next to Big Ben as a landmark for London..

Mark Blackburn, Essex
Stand it proudly next to Big Ben as a landmark for London. She is more important than any tourist attraction in London. She was the greatest leader this Nation has ever seen. People should be able to remember her for all she did for this country. Bill Shankly has a statue outside Anfield, Don Revie has one outside of Elland Road - why can't Thatcher have one outside Westminster?
Mark Blackburn, Essex, UK

Its at moments like this that I would dearly love to be a pigeon.
Vincent, England

Mrs Thatcher's statue should go in the 'vacant' plinth in Trafalgar Square. She is the most memorable - if not the most loved - of all our Prime Ministers of the post-war period. (Notwithstanding Sir Winston Churchill, who is really regarded as a wartime PM).
Stephen Phillips, UK

Why not put it somewhere on the Falkland Islands - with her back to Argentina. The islanders would appreciate her statue the most. Then by the time she dies, all these people that didn't appreciate her back home, might have grown up!
Chris Barnett, UK in Germany.


There is an empty plinth in Trafalgar Square.

Anthony, England
Possibly outside the TUC HQ as a reminder to them not to abuse their Powers. Or maybe at the entrance to the Channel Tunnel, - which is her greatest achievement, as a permanent annoyance to all those EU officials as they sweep by in Eurostar. There is also an empty plinth in Trafalgar Square where the statue would be well appreciated particularly by the pigeons. Maybe the writing underneath should read, - 'She was not as bad as her detractors make out, neither was she as good as her supporters think'.
Anthony, England

This statue should have been commissioned following her death - why has it been finished so early when everyone was aware of the rules?
Chris G, UK

Britain is a traditional society, respect it. Sculptures are needed when the subject is no more but the subject is. We'll make do with the sculpture at Westminster when the Iron lady is no more.
Bate Arrah, Cameroon

I would put it down one of the coal mines her government closed down.
Graeme Thomson, UK

I don't know whether there is a place reserved for tributes to those who responsible for destroying much that was good about the nation. Perhaps the Imperial War Museum?
A Alexander, England

Thatcher's statue should first be positioned outside every closed down coal mine, then outside every dole office, every inner city housing estate, every comprehensive school that was once a grammar school, every Tax office, every old people's home and finally outside every under funded hospital in the land as a testament to a Prime Minister whose only concern was to look after the rich at the expense of the less well off under the pretence of making people stand on their own two feet.
Phil, UK

See also:

01 Feb 02 | UK Politics
Thatcher statue unveiled
26 Jan 02 | UK Politics
Margaret Thatcher: Tory titan
21 Jan 02 | UK Politics
US city wants Thatcher statue
24 Dec 01 | UK Politics
Lady Thatcher statue homeless
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Talking Point stories