BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific
BBCi NEWS   SPORT   WEATHER   WORLD SERVICE   A-Z INDEX     

BBC News World Edition
 You are in: Talking Point  
News Front Page
Africa
Americas
Asia-Pacific
Europe
Middle East
South Asia
UK
Business
Entertainment
Science/Nature
Technology
Health
-------------
Talking Point
Forum
-------------
Country Profiles
In Depth
-------------
Programmes
-------------
BBC Sport
BBC Weather
SERVICES
-------------
EDITIONS
Monday, 22 July, 2002, 08:33 GMT 09:33 UK
Would you vote online?
E-voting could replace the traditional ballot box by 2006, a government report has suggested.

Online polling, accompanied by postal votes and voting by telephone, would replace ballot papers and ballot boxes under the plan.

Commons leader Robin Cook wants to develop online voting as means of attracting the under-40s back to the democratic process.

But critics say that technology alone cannot reignite interest in politics.

Can e-voting reverse the low turn out in local and national elections? Would it encourage more young people to vote? Or do you feel that it is merely a gimmick?

This debate is now closed. Read a selection of your comments below.


Your reaction

I've worked in IT for over 30 years, have stood for Parliament, have been a local councillor, and have campaigned in elections many times. There are two vital conditions. The first is that the system must be equally accessible to all. I do not want a political bias in favour of those most likely to use new technology to vote. (I think my party might gain by such bias, but I don't want it to.) The second condition is that e-voting must be at least as secure against abuse and error - by voters, parties or authorities - as the present system is. Every part of the process must be auditable. Every part of the process, except that which identifies how an individual voted, must be published. .
Robert, Reading, UK

I think the day is coming when we will all sit in our dark little homes and never have to interact with another human being throughout our life. So, briefly, no.
Steve S, USA


Allow voters to vote on all bills and laws affecting them

Stephen Hollinshead, England
If a secure method of voting online can be introduced where the identity of the voter can be confirmed, then why bother electing MPs at all? Why not bring in full democracy and allow voters to vote on all bills and laws affecting them rather than have MPs represent them. Like any vote in Parliament the vote should be open so anyone can see how people voted would make it difficult to rig the vote electronically
Stephen Hollinshead, England

I don't vote offline. What makes Politicians think I'll vote online? Until they learn honesty and to keep their election promises it will just be a waste of time. Democracy as practiced in the west is a total sham.
Paolo Sammut, UK

No, I personally wouldn't vote online, The act of walking to the polling station, and physically casting my vote, is an important part of the ritual to me. However for disabled, or otherwise housebound people it could be useful, and governments in future would not be able to disregard their wishes so easily.
Jack Burge, England


The present system is completely transparent.

Peter Judge, UK
The present system is completely transparent. Every process, except the individual's actual vote, can be observed by a candidate's team of agents. They can observe how many people attend to vote, and can oversee the postal balloting process. They can observe the ballot box being sealed in the polling station at the close of the polls, and they observe the boxes being opened, and the papers being counted, at the count.

How could I as a candidate or agent see into people's homes to see who was voting, and more importantly, whether or not they were being coerced? How could I see into the computer system to see that all the votes are actually being counted, and are being correctly allocated? If you can answer these questions, then I would consider e-voting. As it is, I wouldn't trust it an inch for a real election.
Peter Judge, UK

Giving me some decent choices is the only thing that will make me vote!
Thom Leggett, UK

I bank online. I buy all of my books, CDs and DVDs online. I order library books online. I even order pizza online! I have never had a problem or a worry about security. I would think nothing of voting online too; as far as I'm concerned it's a natural extension. It would be quick, simple, easy and would fit in with doing other things. Pop home, check your email, vote, catch the headlines. I hope it happens.
Bodie, UK


Independence please

Si Bishop, England
I am severely disabled. Even postal voting means I have to ask someone to go to the letterbox for me. Ease and independence please.
Si Bishop, England

The government has just withdrawn the option to submit tax returns via the web because the system didn't work. Web-based voting would devalue the system.
Kathy, UK

Unfortunately I don't think it will encourage more people to vote as many people just don't care or are just too busy complaining about the government to bother to vote.
Mark Davies, UK

I'm in my mid-40s and certainly would vote online if I could. It's not just young people who would be prepared to bring elections into the 21st century.
Pete B, UK

No. The present system requires much manual labour in counting but that means that any major abuse should be spotted by someone. With computer voting it only requires the figures to be altered by one dishonest person in a position to have access or a hacker and no-one would ever know.
David Gee, England


Everything about polling stations is off-putting

Phil Woodford, London, England
One of the most spurious objections to e-voting is the issue of security. Under the current paper-based system, you are not required to provide any identification and you mark your voting paper with a pencil! Secure electronic systems surely win hands down over such a quaint and trusting arrangement.

Everything about polling stations is off-putting and old-fashioned. Even the signs that sit outside look as if they've been dusted off from World War II. I half expect to be told the butter ration has been cut again when I'm handed my voting paper.
Phil Woodford, London, England

Technology makes things virtual, and that cannot replace the physical mark on a ballot paper; the honesty of the human touch.
Pete, England


An electronic record would exist linking your name to who you voted for

Al, UK
An electronic record would exist linking your name to your number and subsequently your vote and ultimately who you voted for. It certainly removes the ability to have your vote kept between yourself and the ballot box. And we would be relying on the integrity of the government not to use the information it has gained from the process. Government?/Integrity? Mmmmmm...
Al, UK

This government has already shown itself willing to lie over every other matter - who would police the vote? They are so in awe of Microsoft I would wager a considerable sum on that organisation being paid to set it all up. In the IT world there is a well known phrase: Security or Microsoft - pick one.
Michael Snow, UK

Our county trialled the e-vote in the last local elections. So on polling day I find my voting info giving me my PIN number for the e-vote, only to see the website for voting closed a full two days before polling day! So after all that I couldn't take advantage of what I feel is a revelation in the polling stations and still had to juggle my day in order to fit in the trip to the local polling station.
Andrew Margetts, UK

In parts of Sheffield during the last local elections it was possible to vote via text or email. I've yet to see the results of this, but myself and all my friends voted using text and email. It was very easy and fitted in with what ever you were doing. The sooner this is put in place the better.
Rob, England

it is always in the interest of the individual to have an opportunity to express their opinion. Only then can England deem itself amongst the top democratic societies on the planet.
Robbie Massey, England

Voting online is an excellent idea. I missed voting in the last election because I suddenly had to work late due to a colleague's illness. I started work at 6am and didn't finish until nearly 11pm. My polling station is 14 miles away from where I work, so I couldn't get there and back in time to do it during the day.
Leanne, UK


There has to be a ceremonial side to it

Jan Lapeire, Belgium
It's a bad idea. It's too close to tele-voting. Voting is an honour. There has to be a ceremonial side to it.
Jan Lapeire, Belgium

During the recent council elections, my borough had electronic voting. I was treated to the spectacle of a council worker 'helping' an elderly gentleman through the process. She looked over his shoulder throughout the multiple votes. I fear municipal workers will use these systems to monitor how we vote.
Nick, UK

I would not (and do not) vote - period. None of the parties come close to matching my values; they are mostly a bland copy of each other with some minor differences. If you want to encourage responsible voting, it will take more than gimmicks.
Lee, Winchester, England


Systems like this are wide open to abuse and fraud

Andy M, England
People worry enough about banking online, let alone something that is as important as casting a vote to elect the next government. Systems like this are wide open to abuse and fraud. What safeguards are being proposed to stop people hacking systems and changing the results of elections electronically? And can we ever trust the results again?
Andy M, England

I too would vote online, for the same reason that I read my news online, manage my finances online, and do a lot of my shopping online - convenience.
V McGloin, UK

Voting in this country is supposed to be anonymous. With the government insisting on ISP snooping on the internet, the voting could be monitored and would not remain a secret. This information could then be used against the individual by the less scrupulous members of society.
Eric Warriss, England


The government will only get more of a turnout through the novelty factor rather than the political process

Craig, Scotland
I'm not being funny but why would I pay money to vote in the form of a text message or dial up connection via a PC? I know this might seem petty but multiply it by a few million and the phone companies will make a mint! The government will only get more of a turnout through the novelty factor rather than the political process.
Craig, Scotland

I would be interested to know who would get the contract to develop the systems to handle online voting. So far the government's choices have produced overpriced flaky systems!
Jez, UK

They don't quite seem to understand why people are not voting. It isn't because they can't be bothered. It's working all hours of the day to make a decent living and also because we don't trust politicians anymore. Try asking the people why.
Stuart, UK

I'm all for alternative methods of voting. Last time around, I left for work before the polling station opened, and I had an evening class which meant I didn't get back until after it had closed. I would have happily voted had I been able. Of course, this raises the question of whether voting has any effect, but I think that's for a different debate.
Anthony M, UK

I wouldn't vote online because I simply wouldn't trust the technology. What happens if the server crashes halfway through polling day?
Adam, UK

I've been peripherally involved in the development of a safe, secure online voting system. I know, therefore, that it can be done. I know, too, in answer to Adam, UK's question about servers crashing, that it's quite possible to have enough duplication that one server crashing won't materially affect things.
However, I also know the Government's record for actually doing things successfully, especially contracting things out, and I am extremely sceptical about whether they will manage to organise it in a secure or practical fashion. I'm looking forward to seeing it, though.
Jenny, UK


I don't think they are going to get much more of a turnout

Phillip Holley, UK
I'm all in favour of increasing the ways in which I can cast my vote. I don't think they are going to get much more of a turnout by introducing it as they have done nothing to interest people in the political process. Most people don't feel that politicians are acting on their behalf. I wonder how many people could even name their MP.
Phillip Holley, UK

Of course the turnout will be higher, young people like me can't be bothered walking to a polling station, but if it takes a few moments online, the turnout will be far higher. And hopefully if we get a different crowd voting we might actually get a decent government in power instead of the old liars that we normally have.
Alistair, England

Sorry, but I don't agree that a higher turnout is necessarily better. Voting is a hugely important decision to make and should not be done on a whim by a text message over a pint at your local or through your TV during the adverts. If people can't be bothered to send a postal ballot or take a short walk to the polling station, what makes Robin Cook think they will bother putting any thought into who to vote for?
Chris Neville-Smith, Durham, England


They could do it while waiting for a bus

Sarah, Reading, UK
I think it will be better to be able to vote online - unlike Chris from Durham, I believe that a higher turnout results in greater authority for the government. I think that a lot of people who claim that they don't vote because they don't believe in politics, actually would vote if the method was so easy that they could do it while waiting for a bus.
Sarah, Reading, UK

I'm highly sceptical as I don't believe there are adequate security measures. I agree with Chris Neville-Smith about whether a higher turnout is necessarily a good thing. Just because you get millions of young people voting for Pop Idol and Big Brother doesn't mean that this would be suitable for general elections. At least the fickleness in those votes only affects a few desperate wannabes. A general election affects the whole country. Politicians must get the general public interested in politics again and then they'll vote after serious consideration.
Christine, UK

Of course I would vote online, I'm lazy!!
S Milne, UK

 VOTE RESULTS
Would you vote in an election online?

Yes
 77.06% 

No
 22.94% 

6160 Votes Cast

Results are indicative and may not reflect public opinion

See also:

17 Jul 02 | UK Politics
07 Jan 02 | UK Politics
11 Jul 02 | UK Politics
08 Apr 02 | Science/Nature
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Talking Point stories are at the foot of the page.


E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Talking Point stories

© BBC ^^ Back to top

News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East |
South Asia | UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature |
Technology | Health | Talking Point | Country Profiles | In Depth |
Programmes