Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education

 You are in: Talking Point
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Thursday, 4 October, 2001, 12:25 GMT 13:25 UK
Tony Blair's warning: Did he reflect public opinion?
Prime Minister Tony Blair has warned the Taleban that they will be defeated and warned them to surrender the terrorists or surrender power.

In his speech to the Labour Party conference in Brighton, Mr Blair said the atrocities of September 11 had caused governments around the world to consider and change. He said it was time for the west to overcome its ignorance of Islam, but that it was also time for Islam to overcome its prejudice against America.

The Prime Minister accompanied his warning to those harbouring terrorists with a promise that everything possible will be done to avoid civilian casualties in any action that might be taken.

Do you think Mr Blair hit the right chord with his speech? Do his views reflect current public opinion three weeks after the attacks?

This debate is now closed. Read a selection of your comments below.

Your reaction

We didn't ask to be dragged into this, but we are sure going to finish it now.

Lance O, US of A
Tony Blair hit the nail right on the head. That was an excellent speech and we are in the U.S. are proud to call everyone in the U.K. our friends. These madmen do not understand anything but force. To ignore this and pretend it didn't happen would be a huge mistake. Diplomacy does not work when there are people that have their own agenda that they will try and carry out no matter what the consequences. We didn't ask to be dragged into this, but we are sure going to finish it now. Thank you Tony Blair, citizens of the U.K. and everyone else in the world for your pledge of support.
Lance O, US of A

Thanks Vin Agosta! Ignorance? I guess, the only thing left out is, lecture on ignorance from the US!
Bill, Netizen

If all the people of the UK cannot comprehend that this war on terrorism is necessary, then you have a problem even greater than terrorism - ignorance.
Vin Agosta, SF, USA

It is precisely his kind of blundering and bullying politics that fuels the fires that rage in these fundamentalist madmen's hearts.
Glenn Barker, Canada

The man is dangerous, will lead us into dangerous waters, and can't be trusted.

Bob Harvey, UK
Megalamaniac claptrap. It is implausible that the world, even acting in unison, could find the resources or the will to track down every terrorist. It is unlikely that it can do so in such a way that more will not arise. This is pure pandering to a public mood, and comes very ill from a man who has been totally unable to deal with terrorists in Northern Ireland.

I don't know how detached from reality you have to be to make statements this ridiculous, but our "esteemed" premier seems to have reached that happy elevated position. The man is dangerous, will lead us into dangerous waters, and can't be trusted. When he has delivered all those doctors and nurses he so airily promised us, disarmed the IRA and UDF, and sorted out racism in the UK - then I will believe he can take on the rest of the world and change it.

But as it is, nothing has improved one jot since he came to power, and this promise of his will be as empty as all his other pronouncements.
Bob Harvey, UK

Blair understands clearly that the attack on September 11 was an attack on secular democracy as much as an attack on the USA. I am amazed to find those who feel that appeasing the Taleban and other Islamic fundamentalists will stop terror. To those folks I would advise closer study of Chamberlain/Munich/and Hitler.

I didn't vote for Blair and I wouldn't vote for him in the future but the man is in his element with this conflict. I have no doubt that unlike some labour and liberal cowards this man will not let this country down. If I have to die fighting a war for this country then I want to die fighting for my freedom not hoping that this conflict goes away and that it's someone else's problem.

Do any of the people criticizing the speech on this board read his statement in FULL, or are they responding to what they infer is the hidden intention? Because if we all respond in this manner, then the hopes of any sort of resolution through dialog are very seriously at risk.
Anon, Canada

Mr Blair you are a hypocrite.

Jack Gibberd, UK
Mr Blair you are a hypocrite. Happy to leave the Third World in squalor and crush any voice dissidence, whilst offering us platitudes. 6,000 people have died, in an admittedly diabolical act but we, in the West, deliberately condemn 100's of millions worldwide to starvation and misery for our own ends. Where is our morality? We hold the rest of the world to ransom and call it free trade, our lives are built on the backs of the poor and Muslims get a particularly raw deal.

In forty years our living standards have escalated three times, whilst the rest of the world remains unchanged. Our larders and houses are littered with products that contribute to world oppression. We talk of innocent civilians and indiscriminate loss of life but the World Trade Centre is a symbol of our control and suppression.

Bin Laden is no more than a product of our greed and thoughtlessness. Kill him or gaol him, it doesn't matter one jot. The resentment that is felt by the worlds oppressed will not go away. Poor countries are too fearful to stand up to the West and our arbitrary set of values, for fear of your economic or military reprisals but the undercurrent in their populations, will only be intensified. - You cannot treat the Third World as though it is an inner city housing estate.

So Britain stands shoulder to shoulder with the USA to keep the world divided into haves and have-nots. And I have to be bombarded by the one-sided diatribe from our supposedly 'free' press. - I feel deeply ashamed of us.

But you, Mr. Blair, disgust me. This is a huge and wonderful opportunity, for us in the First World, to examine and understand, what has generated such a catastrophic tragedy. But all we do is react with aggression and outrage and demands for retribution. Anger will never be the answer, it will only generate more anger. And, anger is ultimately destructive. We don't need a warmonger, Mr. Blair, we need a visionary.
Jack Gibberd, UK

Like his predecessors before him, Blair obviously has no intention of making the UK an independent country.

I can assure you that Tony Blair does not speak for me by putting the UK on the war front. While I condemn the US attack, one need only study their foreign policy to understand how this came about. Like his predecessors before him, Blair obviously has no intention of making the UK an independent country, he too is sucking up to the USA, and doing so rather disgracefully I might add. The USA's enemies don't have to become the UK's enemies. This was not an attack on the "free world" but an attack on USA. Looks like another fine mess you got us into Tony.

I think he's right in approaching the problem head on. The conflict has begun. It's naive to think that by inaction, attacks won't happen in other countries. There must be many responses. It seems inevitable that military responses will be needed, and certainly humanitarian responses.
Brien Alkire, US

Thank you PM Blair and the people of the UK as in all times of great sadness and loss it is so important to have your friends beside you. There are so many details to work out and political choices to make but it is very comforting to know that the UK is right beside us!
Carolyn, USA

RIGHT ON Tony, I could not have said it better. Tony Blair did a fantastic job on his speech. If this massacre had have happened in the UK instead of here, we would still be shoulder to shoulder. As an American, I thank you all for your kind words and prayers. We of course will all fight for freedom, but this time we need to stick around and help this poor country to be a productive member of society.
Judy, USA

Address the issues close to home first then talk about world.

Param, USA
Probably the public opinion of US, but definitely not of UK! Would have been more appropriate had he warned IRA supporters too (in the same tone as Taleban). Address the issues close to home first then talk about world, otherwise it loses the seriousness however strong the delivery might be. Just like Bush!
Param, USA

When Germany had it in mind to take over Europe in World Wars I and II, the British gladly accepted the support of American troops and industry toward the preservation of THEIR country. I gladly thank all citizens of the UK who support the US in its time of crisis, and shame on the rest of you who think Tony Blair has done anything less than fulfil his responsibilities to the best of his abilities. Maybe the next time the Germans want to make you eat sauerkraut, we will let them.
Joe, USA

Tony Blair for President!
Miguel Cervantes Sahagun, USA

Bravo Mr. Blair! No dancing around the issues for you. And certainly no question where you and our friends in the UK stand. Despite the destruction and pain, we've been given a rare opportunity to improve our world. Along with many other Americans, I'm proud you're shouldering that burden with us.
Cathy, USA

Sometimes you have to go to war to get peace and peace is what most of the world seems to want. Unfortunately these terrorist attacks will continue if not checked. I view any actions that the U.S. and Great Britain might take strictly as self-defense and liberation for the people of Afghanistan from their nightmare of a government. America was minding its business when thousands of people were brutally attacked for doing what millions of people do every day - going out to earn a living. Thank God for people like Tony Blair that get it.
Chisomo, USA

He laid down the gauntlet. Hopefully, the nations of this world will pick it up and run with it.

John, Canada
An excellent speech. It surpassed that of President Bush. It did so for the following reason. Not only did it state in no uncertain terms what is being done and what needed to be done to end this reign of terror but it also stated what must be done to bring about the kind of world we all hope for - a world where people of all races, religions, colors, live in freedom and at a subsistence level worthy of their dignity as human beings. He laid down the gauntlet. Hopefully, the nations of this world will pick it up and run with it.
John, Canada

By mentioning aid and the avoidance of civilian casualties he's trying to soften the impact of coming war and get us all to unite for this fight against a concept. As for Shaun's message on 'some of the mistakes the US made' well, does Sudan, Libya etc ring any bells?
Daniel, UK

I think he said the right words but they could have been a little harsher.
Marie lee, USA

The ultimate ruling on the merits of the actions being talked about and taken by both our countries will come with time. Unfortunately, time is not a commodity we have to spare in this day. Whatever the long-term outcome is, this American, for one, is very proud of Mr. Blair's statements and our mother country's public resolve to stand beside us in our time of need. Your country represents to a great many of us, the finest in humanity and courage and it has always been so. History has shown that we can learn much from our cousins about being strong and fair in a time of hostility and sorrow. You're a class act. God Bless the UK.
Richard Comerford, USA

Terrorism is the deliberate targeting of civilians, not action against a military target that results in unintentional civilian casualties.

Brandon Shaw, USA
The idea I have heard expressed occasionally that by using military force, the U.S. is countering terrorism with terrorism is ludicrous. Terrorism is the deliberate targeting of civilians, not action against a military target that results in unintentional civilian casualties. For the U.S. to make a weak response to the attacks on New York and Washington would be like hanging a "kick me" sign around our necks. Killing civilians by design is not an acceptable form of presenting a grievance.
Brandon Shaw, USA

I want to let Mr Blair know that you can fight with individuals, but you can't fight the whole. Whatever goes around comes around. You don't want people to bother your people, don't bother their people. I strongly believe that by changing the Afghan Government, things will get even worse. Leaders are nothing but human beings. In fact, Blair is even stupider than I thought. Think and think again before you induce people to violence
Soya Djigue, Mali

Tony Blair says he has seen the proof that Bin Laden was involved in the US attacks. If so, then why doesn't he show it to the Taleban? After all, the Taleban has agreed to hand over Laden if they can be shown the evidence. Isn't this reasonable? After all, in a democracy you are assumed innocent until proven guilty.

So what does Blair have to hide? Could it be that he really has no evidence against Bin Laden at all? I wouldn't be surprised if he hasn't.
Bilal Patel, London, UK

Stop spouting threats and present the evidence

John, UK
Before his Tony-ness commits this country military action I, for one, would like to see a little bit of the evidence they have (if indeed they have any). I'm no fan of Bin Laden or the Taleban, but then I also gave up trusting the word of any politician (be they our own in the UK or in the US) many years ago. So when it come to such an important decision as this, I think the public have a right to be informed of the facts. So your Tony-ness, will you please, please, please, please, stop spouting threats and present the evidence. If its as compelling as Nato say, you will have me and most of the rest of the reasonable world behind you in weeding out and destroying these people and there organisation
John, UK

Maybe Tony Blair doesn't reflect everyone's opinion here in the UK, but if you let terrorists get away with this then worse attacks will happen. Standing by the US is not just good for UK - US relations, but it is the right thing to do. Lots of people in the UK fear reprisals but you have to stand up to evil and be prepared to take some casualties to save many more lives and our way of living.
Chris, UK

When Mr Blair encourages his own sons to join the front line fight against terrorism I might then to start taking him seriously. For a man who sanctioned the release of hundreds of indiscriminate killers it really was some performance. Mr Blair is fooling no one who has half a brain. Come on Mr Blair, I give you a direct challenge to encourage your sons to join the armed forces as infantrymen and to take your message directly to the terrorists, and while you are at it, maybe you can persuade Jack Straw to offer the services if his son.
J Rimmer, Isle of Man

I congratulate Prime Minister Tony Blair on a speech which I found to be very much to the point. As Winston Churchill once said "The only thing we have to fear is fear itself". Terrorism will be confronted and defeated. All decent men and nations will join in this fight until victory is achieved.
Tom L., New Jersey , USA

I think Tony Blair is dragging us all into a war. He seems more the fighter than Bush, although we need to fight terrorism but Tony seems to be taking this fight more than Bush. I will like to point out that America did not take such stand on our behalf when the IRA were killing people in this country. Tony seems to thrive very well in crisis when we have our own problems to deal with in this country. I personally have never heard him address the IRA terrorists in this manner.
Jordan, UK

All this pacifist stuff is just sickening. It is not only sad that you have no intestinal fortitude, but apparently no moral backbone either. However to your country's credit, you have a great leader in Tony Blair. His speech was right on the money. At least he understands how important it is to have a friend that you can really count on (read USA), and has the character to lay it on the line when your best friend in all the world needs a little assistance. Point of fact is that we don't need anyone's help to exact justice on those murderers, but its always nice to have a friend to help out. Intelligent people realize that the USA and Great Britain really have only each other as allies. The rest of the Nato members are just full of hollow words. When push comes to shove, they can't be counted on for anything.
Kenneth, USA

What many around the world probably do not recognise is that Tony Blair is taking the British people to war without consulting the democratic process by using Parliament. Whilst it was recalled once that was an event where no debate or voting took place. Although recalled on Thursday that will be a staged affair where MP's will be instructed not to cause trouble. If large-scale surveys were conducted the reality is that most of the public are extremely cautious about using our military and certainly feel any use must be concise and short. The British people do not in anyway believe this is an attack on Islam, it is against terrorists no one else. Tony Blair is leading our country like a President not as an elected Prime Minister. We should go to the UN and use their powers to convince the world community that this is not a campaign against Muslims.
Martin, UK

I am British. Blair and Bush just want to test more weapons. There is no proof that we have been given that the Taleban were behind this. It may be true but until the US prove in a legal type situation i.e. to the satisfaction of a trial judge that the evidence is correct and not manufactured by over-enthusiastic investigators then they cannot in conscience bound go to war. They will be judged accordingly. Anyway, bombing Afghanistan will not end terrorism, just spawns more
Gus, Italy

Re. Tom's comments: I agree that the WWII policy of appeasement was flawed but it's easy to have perfect hindsight after an event has occurred. I also agree that terrorism is very destructive but one man's terrorist is another's freedom fighter. Look at the international community's role in fuelling civil wars and funding "terrorist" groups throughout the later half of the 20th century.

If my memory serves me correctly the US was in an isolationist state at the time of Hitler's rise and only came into the war after Japan attacked Pearl Harbour late in 1942. As late as April 14 1942 Roosevelt sent a telegram to Hitler offering trade (among other things) in return for peace. It is also strange that you see "times of war" as a given, since we were assured that concrete evidence would be shown first. This is no time for finger-pointing. No country is blameless. The US deserves to seek justice for the attacks. This is, however, one of the worst ways to do it.

Bombing for peace. I fail to see how that will work. This is not to excuse the actions of Al-Quaeda; but the consequences of violence will always be greater violence. Say Bush obliterates the Taleban. Will that make the West more or less popular with its critics? Will it breed more or less "fundamentalist" anger and violence? The West's leaders should be taking a stand against their own people and refusing to go to war.
Chris Longridge, UK

Some people are forgetting that these acts took not only US lives, but hundred of Brits as well. Blair is correct in his condemnation and other countries that lost people should be as equally courageous. One simply does not negotiate with mass murderers. They've had their time to correct themselves and have only gotten worse over time. It's time for intervention from the people who have had successful democracies and were target of their madness. To not stop it is to accept it.

It is sad that Tony Blair shares the views of the US

Stash Domiszewski, Oman
It is sad that Tony Blair shares the views of the US, although not surprising. If anyone believes that bombing Afghanistan or any other country will lead to greater peace in the world they are surely mistaken. As I'm sure Tony Blair and Mr Bush are fully aware, the people of this region feel that the US and British foreign policies need to drastically change in order for peace to be possible. Bombing will only reinforce the 'anti' feelings and I dare to predict will lead to more "terrorist" attacks.
Stash Domiszewski, Oman

I am very moved by Mr Blair's continued support and efforts. He has stood beside the US in many times of need, always sticking his neck out to help in any way he can. A true friend indeed.
DeAnn, USA

This all sounds like a pathetic attempt by the Prime Minister to bolster support for himself at a time when the public is questioning his party's home performance so far. Shame! If military action is the way to beat terrorists, then why was it not applied in N Ireland after the attack on Canary Wharf? A rhetorical question since we're all perfectly aware that the UK's superior military strength in Belfast has only helped to broaden the divide and drag out the conflict further! It is precisely his kind of blundering and bullying politics that fuels the fires that rage in these fundamentalist madmen's hearts.
Glenn Barker, Canada

Outstanding job by Mr Blair

Michael Murray, Ottawa, Canada
Outstanding job by Mr Blair. The Taleban need to know that they will be held accountable by other countries not just the USA. It's comforting to see other world leaders speaking out.
Michael Murray, Ottawa, Canada

This is all well and true and very just. Could someone please tell me what Tony Blair plans to do about the terrorists on our own doorstep. People have been dying in the UK for thirty years and now with a single act in the US (the saddest I have ever seen in my life as I am in New York at present and was during the attack), we must now wipe out terrorism from around the world. I want to know why now? This is something that should have been started in England years ago.
Mitchell Badillo, Ipswich - UK

Blair needs to look himself in the mirror, and he will see some aspects of the Taleban in himself and his government. Listen to him talk about the plight of the children told they were about to die (yes, he is right it was horrible and undeserved), but he of all people should be the last to use that example, for there were and are Children in Iraq, who were not only told similarly by him and his allies, but in their case they do not die a swift death. May God help the world against the terrorist (whoever they are), but we will not begin to solve this unless the world can feel for all peoples, the plight they feel and felt for America in this tragedy.

Finally a Prime Minister who is not afraid to tell the truth, and represents the opinions of the silent majority of British people. He is not afraid to spell out exactly who these criminals are, and to condemn their twisted version of Islam. God Bless America, and God Bless Tony Blair - a man of courage.
Frances Black, Canada

Can we see the proof before you commit us to war?

Sal M, San Francisco, California
Prime Minister Blair should not have threatened Afghanistan. I thought that diplomacy and negotiation were the first steps to resolving conflict, but the USA and UK refuse to even discuss the issues with the Taleban. Mr. Blair and Mr. Bush keep insisting that there is proof, but neither has been able to produce this proof. Can we see the proof before you commit us to war?
Sal M, San Francisco, California

Tony Blair is right. Nothing can justify what was done to New York, America and thousands of innocents on 11 September. The US must now destroy the evil that threatens America and the civilized world.
Bob, USA

Mr Blair's threat to Afghanistan can be termed as "overreaction". He has also compounded the terrorist attack on the USA with Islam and the West. The attack cannot be termed as attack of Islam on the West or USA. If the threat is in the perspective of Islamic Afghanistan giving shelter to Muslim Terrorist then a long war between Christianity and Zionism on one side and Islam and truth on the other side cannot be avoided. The world must consider and remove the causes of terrorism. The British Government must also consider the policy of giving shelter to the terrorist groups in Great Britain. Democratic freedom does not mean that killers, plunderers and criminals should be given shelter.
Inam ul Haque, Pakistan

Mr Blair pulled off an exquisite speech

P DuBock, UK
I think Mr Blair pulled off an exquisite speech. He is doing the best he can in a situation like this and I believe that it is our responsibility to help our American friends at any cost. After all, they would do the same for us. He is representing the UK well and my support goes to him 100%.
P DuBock, UK

A typical Blair speech apparently promising all things to all people, with a nice soundbite on almost every conceivable issue. While most people would agree with the theme of social justice, this rambling speech promised much that would be unachievable by even a superpower, but will deliver little. I am appalled by the use of the terrible events of September 11th to cloak domestic failings and to try to push the UK towards early entry into the Eurozone.
Michael Dunphy, UK

Force is the only language these people understand

Ed Brauer, London, England
Tony Blair has been absolutely correct in his stance so far. Force is the only language these people understand.
Ed Brauer, London, England

The Prime Minister's is quoted as saying: "I say to the Taleban, surrender the terrorists or surrender power. That is your choice." In the same speech he condemned the Taleban as a regime that oppressed the people of Afghanistan and flooded the streets of the West with drugs. So what are we to think: if the Taleban give up Bin Laden, we will allow them to operate? Or we will object and destroy them at a later date? Let's have a consistent policy towards the Taleban and say that we wish to see them removed rather than these bizarre choices which have no bearing on reality.
Philip Whitchelo, UK

Tony Blair is going to lead us straight into the Third World War.
John Johnson, UK

Blair was spot on and although I didn't vote for him, on this issue he has been outstanding. God bless America!
P Cunliffe, England

Tony Blair has been a rock during this crisis

Peter C. Kohler, USA
Tony Blair has been a rock during this crisis. Every American was deeply touched by his coming to Washington to hear the President's speech and by all outpouring of sympathy and support by the British people. And we know that unlike all other "allies", Blair's words and gestures will go beyond that to resolute action and support.
Peter C. Kohler, USA

Excellent speech by Mr. Tony Blair!
Paul, USA

For the first time in my memory we here in the USA got to hear almost all of Mr Blair's speech instead of just a token few seconds or minutes. I wish CNN had kept it going to the end. This American thanks him for his words of support and for acknowledging that every country is impacted by the tragedy.
Henry H Broer, USA

I appreciated Mr Blair's remarks. I have some knowledge of Islam and of Middle Eastern culture and I do not believe a weak response will serve the free peoples of the world.
Mari, OH, USA

I sincerely hope that Blair doesn't reflect public opinion

Sharif Nashashibi, UK
I sincerely hope that Blair doesn't reflect public opinion. After all, it is no surprise that with his knee jerk, outspoken, unquestioning support for war, London is now the prime target for more terrorist attacks. What will public opinion think of him when body bags start turning up in our capital?
Sharif Nashashibi, UK

America and the UK are probably the only two countries with the conviction, capability and determination to stamp out terrorism. All the other countries in the so-called alliance agree with the US and UK as long as they are not involved in military action themselves. Obviously some countries in the alliance have skeletons in their cupboards. The only language the terrorists understand is force. The negative side of this involves the number of innocent civilians that inevitably will get caught in the process.
Roger Ferreira, UK

By mentioning aid and avoiding the issue of civilian casualties he's trying to soften the impact of coming war and get us all to unite for this fight against a concept.
Daniel, UK

He has no idea what public opinion is

Chris, UK
He has no idea what public opinion is. Parliament is still out and he seems to have no intention of recalling it in case someone doesn't agree with what he is doing.
Chris, UK

Why didn't Goeff Hoon make this speech? Surely it's the job of the Ministry of Defence to undertake any campaign against the Taleban. Does Tony Blair actually talk to any of his cabinet colleagues, or is he just trying to deal with the problem single handedly?
Hugh, UK

The best speech I've heard him give. Just as Bush's, with Blair present, to the US Congress was. Strong but reasoned.

I didn't listen to the speech as my time is too valuable to waste listening to a puppet on American strings.
Ned, UK

I am surprised by Mr Blair's outright threat. However I believe it's needed and justified.
Ray Sovereign, US

I do not think that Blair is considering the views of the public. This isn't new. He is acting like a vigilante, which he never did after the Omagh bombings, for example. He must stop the funding of all terrorist organisations, not just Islamic.
Anon, Hong Kong

I don't know a soul that likes war, but I see little other choice. I am puzzled by any other concept. I have a son in the marines and he is prepared to go. Yes, I agree with Blair's statements.
B Nance CA, USA

I was struck by Mr Blair's stance on global participation to eradicate the terror scourges from our civilisation and also the fact that he emphasised that all nations should step back and rethink its opinion on other atrocities which have occurred or may occur in the future. We, too, have sceptics in our country but now is not the time to debate the 'principals of politics'. Instead, the debate should be focused on humanity and what we must all do, together, to assure a peaceful co-existence for us all.
Sheila Reeder, USA

Tough talk is not enough. It is time for action

Chris, USA
Tough talk is not enough. It is time for action. Let's stand together and be united to show terrorists that premeditated, cowardly attacks anywhere in the world will not be tolerated.
Chris, USA

Of course Mr Blair was right to threaten the Taleban. What Osama Bin Laden did was inexcusable and cannot go unpunished. I know that Americans want justice for this horrible tragedy and I believe that other countries do as well, because this was an attack against freedom and liberty. It is time to launch fierce military strikes against the Taleban, and we must oust that evil government. Osama Bin Laden must be put to death, there should be no trial. The US and Britain are the defenders of freedom and democracy and we cannot let the terrorists control our lives. The world should be a safe place to live. I whole heartedly support Mr Blair.
Jerry Pietrovito, USA

I believe that Tony Blair had the right to say what he did and I agree we need to stick together with other Nato countries as one. We can beat the war on terrorism.
Nicola Gregory, France

I am anything but a Blair supporter, but as far as his stance on the attacks goes he has my full backing. The US has always been our greatest friend and we should rally behind them. It's as simple as that. We can all wax lyrical about some of the mistakes the US has made over the years in their foreign policies, but we too made naive and costly misjudgements. It is inevitable. By any measure, the disgraceful actions visited upon the US on September 11 can never be justified. We must help our friend take action to ensure such misery never happens again.
Shaun, Teignmouth, UK

Not my opinion. I abhor the idea of going to war. I think that we should set an example of booting out the terrorists we harbouring in our country, freezing all assets of known terrorists, destroying the drug fields in Afghanistan thus hitting both their finances and the drug trade and educating the Afghan people so that they may find the power to overcome their own government. But I do not think we should go to war. I would rather spend my taxes on education and healthcare in this country before destroying someone else's. As Ghandi put it "an eye for an eye makes everyone blind". This kind of overt retaliation will only fuel the fires of hatred and we have far more to lose than them. I wouldn't declare war on Afghanistan and I don't agree with my taxes funding Tony Blair's political opportunities. I don't think it is a fitting tribute to those who died that we go forward and cause more massacres. We owe them more than that.
Sharon B, UK

Re. Sharon's comments: Hiding your head in the sand is the quickest way to have it cut off. Do you have any historical sense of what happens when madmen like this are appeased? Do you remember Hitler- and what your brand of response brought the world then? bin Laden, like Hitler, has de facto declared war on the US and begun to massacre civilians. Had the US ignored Hitler's declaration of war on us, stayed home with our heads in the sand, and taken the stance that "this is not America's war", Europe would certainly be a far different place today- and I doubt if you'd have much say about what healthcare and education looked like in the UK. Moreover, it is not the poppy fields of Afghanistan that finance this terror, but coordinated sources outside the country. Pacifism is a fine philosophy, but sheer fatalism in times af war: get your head out of the sand and look around you.
Tom, USA

No, but then he never has reflected my opinion. Maybe that's why I didn't vote for him.

Blair's speech: Did he hit the right note?



3630 Votes Cast

Results are indicative and may not reflect public opinion

Links to more Talking Point stories