|low graphics version | feedback | help|
|You are in: Talking Point|
Friday, 22 June, 2001, 09:06 GMT 10:06 UK
Baldness: Is it a bar to a top job?
Iain Duncan Smith has high hopes to lead the Conservative Party, but he faces one challenge that his rivals do not.
With modern politics so dominated by image, many believe that a full head of hair is always going to triumph over baldness.
Duncan Smith could be joining the likes of William Hague and Neil Kinnock in the arena of follicly-challenged challengers.
One newspaper has even suggested that a bald man can never again lead the Conservative party.
But what do you think? Is baldness really a bar to the top job?
This debate is now closed. Read a selection of your comments below.
The leader of a nation not only has to be a good party leader, strong minded, charismatic etc. but also has to seem prime ministerial. Unfortunately a bald head is a major disadvantage. As trivial as it may seem, this is a major lesson the Tories need to learn if they are to gain re-election. The likes of Hague, Iain Smith can never lead a party into government
Let's look at this realistically. One has to, if one wishes to be leader of any nation, at least appear youthful.
Phillip Porteous, Cumbria
A full head of hair may look the part for indoor photo sessions, but the more follicly-challenged among us don't look as hideously windblown as Tony Blair did on the few occasions he actually went into the real world to meet real people.
I can't believe this is even up for discussion. Put the right person in the job and let them get on with it.
I'm as bald as a coot. I'm also quite ugly, as a result of many years playing rugby. I run a successful IT company, and I've never encountered any problems with anyone as a result of being "trichologically challenged".
Parliament is not a stage for a fashion parade. Baldness is not a deformity but trying to cover it is......
If baldness isn't a bar to top jobs, then it certainly should be. And I speak as a person with a full set of hair.
If you form an opinion about which candidate you will vote for by how much hair they have you must be dense. Tony Blair won the election because he is honest and his policies aren't steeped in greed. Stop making excuses for the Conservatives.
God only made a few perfect heads. The rest he covered with hair.
Louis Charles, France
As a baldie I can say that I prefer being bald to having hair. I don't have to spend the ridiculous amounts it costs to have my hair cut. Also, it has never stopped me getting a good job. But if the real reasons that Hague wasn't voted in was because of his hair then it shows how shallow our society is becoming.
Vanity is a distraction, a weakness. If we were all so vain as to choose our leaders, our decision-makers based on how the public thinks they ought to appear, then we shall forever be sentenced to living in a vain, weak, distracted society lead by vain, weak distracted leaders.
What about Ming The Merciless? He's bald and controls half the Galaxy?
Unfortunately it is true. Look at any meeting of senior managers of an organisation. Look at all those silver tops.
Ray W, Australia
Urho Kekkonen was the President of Finland from 1956 to 1981, dominating Finnish politics for a good part of the 20th century. A powerful character, Kekkonen was re-elected to the office four times. He was a former top athlete and famously fond of beautiful women. And yes, he was completely bald from his mid-40s.
No, but if you're the wrong person for the job it makes it worse.
Patrick C, UK
Hair has never been an issue - and I hope we never sink to this as a marker for suitability as a leader. It is just the unfortunate fact that William H seems to be some long lost relative of ET.
Of course it makes a difference. Think of the last few presidents of the United States, all have had good heads of hair. It is a matter of presentation.
Jesse Ventura (Governor of Minnisota) proves that bald ain't the issue - it's leadership and honesty about your purpose and the ability to communicate those ideas that win elections.
It is not what is on top of the head that matters, but what is in it.
Looks play a major role in our society, especially in the west where Hollwood and fashion magazines have brainwashed our next generation. Politics is becoming a fashion show, with thick hair finishing in first place. Young voters are voting for youth.
Matthew D., US
What about Churchill? He wasn't exactly over-endowed in the hair department in later years, and look at how he galvanised popular opinion during the war. In any case, judging by the amount of hair Tony Blair has lost in the past four years, it won't be long before his 'appeal' will be looking decidedly thin.
Mr. Hague may have been bald, but he may have disproved the aphorism that 'grass does not grow on a busy street'. I think the fact he was not a particularly good leader may have had something to do with it. Perhaps Ken Clarke is not such a bad option. He is slightly bald or perhaps slightly hairy?
Which to choose - the hairless or the heirless?
We should limit the job of politicians to bald people and do away forever with hair-brained government schemes.
A 1990 study in the US looked at the proportion of baldies in elected office. Of 522 officeholders only 31 were fully bald. I quote from Gersh Kuntzman's recent book 'Hair': 'instead of 31 fully bald men in office, there should have been 118 if our elected officials resembled society'. Looks pretty conclusive to me; psychological studies regularly show that bald men are judged to be less trustworthy, less masculine and less attractive than those with hair. Not that Portillo's hair makes him particularly trustworthy in my opinion...
Helmut Kohl and Francois Mitterand were baldies who seemed to do OK, as did Trudeau in Canada. Hague's failure had little to do with his baldness and everything to do with being leader of an unelectable, out of touch political party!
If image is the only thing that counts God help us. My vote had nothing to do with hair or lack of it.
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites
Other Talking Points:
Links to more Talking Point stories
|^^ Back to top
News Front Page | World | UK | UK Politics | Business | Sci/Tech | Health | Education | Entertainment | Talking Point | In Depth | AudioVideo
To BBC Sport>> | To BBC Weather>>
© MMIII | News Sources | Privacy