Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: Talking Point
Front Page 
World 
UK 
UK Politics 
Business 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
Forum 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 



Tom Reid, Washington Post
"There's a lot of cultural power outside America"
 real 28k

John Morton, Baltimore, USA
"America has every right to defend itself from nuclear attack"
 real 28k

Bob Kirenga, The Hague, Netherlands
"The US only cares about its own interests"
 real 28k

Lucas Beeler, Atlanta, USA
"The face of America is more than Coca Cola"
 real 28k

Donnamarie Leemann, Switzerland
"Not all Americans are the same"
 real 28k

Mandla George, South Africa
"America has got to be stopped from employing bullying tricks"
 real 28k

Peter Chellini, USA
"Parochial analysis of world issues is banal"
 real 28k

Paul Murray, Spain
"We should all fly the flag for America"
 real 28k

Stephen Meyer, Australia
"Australia relies too much on America"
 real 28k

Art Van Kranenburg, Netherlands
"Much criticism of America is unbalanced and hypocritical"
 real 28k

Thursday, 21 June, 2001, 07:49 GMT 08:49 UK
Does Europe need the US?

Select a link below to watch Talking Point On Air


President George W Bush has faced angry demonstrators during his first tour of Europe since coming to the White House.

Europeans are angry that the Bush administration has turned its back on the Kyoto treaty on tackling global warming and the Russians are particularly fearful of the contentious US missile defence plans.

Despite a huge volume of transatlantic trade and political co-operation between Europe and America there is also a seemingly immense cultural divide.

On issues from defence and the environment to abortion and the death penalty, it seems there is a growing European rebellion against American values and culture.

Can the gulf between the two western power blocks be bridged or is the transatlantic alliance coming to an end? Is America now out of touch with the rest of the world?

Robin Lustig was joined by Tom Reid from the Washington Post for Talking Point on Air, a radio phone-in programme on BBC World Service and BBC News Online. You can add to the debate by using the form below.

This debate is now closed. Read a selection of your comments below.


Your reaction

  • Your comments since the programme
  • Your comments during the programme
  • Your comments before the programme

    Your comments since the programme

    It amazes me everyday that people around the globe still buy into the American theme of democracy. Bush has been appointed by the Court. We in America are now represented by a frightened man who wants to conduct his business behind closed doors. It is a sad state of democracy, but it has long been this way. And, look at his father, who continues his reign as the most powerful man in the world. Bush is more the puppet than even Reagan. Please, understand this, and the fact that, yes, we Americans could benefit from a more European point-of-view on the state of the world.
    Todd Kearns, Mancos, Colorado, USA

    I have only read one comment FROM the USA on this subject, and find it typical. It is all regarding Europe not being a military super-power, claiming that the EU could not exist without the US! Only the USA is INTERESTED in being a military super-power! Despite what the UK government (the US' lapdog, might I add) thinks, the REST of the EU in no way "needs" the USA, nor their interference in European affairs. Two thumbs up to France and Germany for giving the two-fingered salute to George Bush. Not all Americans like this president, nor their government. I am hoping to soon become an EU citizen myself.
    Phil Jurament, Boston USA


    Millions of people have fled Europe over the past several centuries, and we would do well to remember why

    L Cacchio, Missouri USA
    Millions of people have fled Europe over the past several centuries, and we would do well to remember why. It wasn't because Europe offered too much freedom, or too much hope, or too much prosperity, or too few wars, or too much tolerance of divergent views. On what basis can we say that the European world view in superior to the American?
    L Cacchio, Missouri USA

    I think that Europe is plagued with arrogance. Europe needs America but America could easily survive without Europe. I spilled my blood in Europe fighting in a regional conflict. Many of my close friends died on the beaches of France so that you could be free. And yet you are still arrogant and feel higher than Americans. If it were not for America, right now Britain would be a mere Diocese of the Third Reich. And after the war with The Marshal Plan and Truman Doctrine we rebuilt Europe and Americans sent their tax dollars over there to save you from communism.

    We rebuilt your economies and our militaries protected you. America has been there every step of the way to hold your hands and tell you its ok. And now when your American made economies start to work you want to leave us in the dust. You could not survive ten weeks without America.
    Tom Lukens, Illinois,USA

    The issue is not whether Europe needs the U.S. or vice-versa. It's plainly obvious we need each other and should demand an even greater relationship from one another for the greater good of everyone. The issue is rather, how does the U.S. develop a greater sense of global responsibility beyond its traditional role as military presence and treaty broker? And how do Europeans develop a greater sense of self-reliance and become a greater force in persuading Americans to be more internationally responsible?

    Americans, as a manner of habit, are uncomfortable with government leading an active role in any large-scale project. This is a major flaw and phobia in the American way of thinking. Americans like the idea of government as, at the most, a passive moderator, and not an active provider or regulator. Americans distrust government as being conscious and responsible, but rather usually see government as wasteful and self-serving.
    Ed Nicholson, Los Angeles

    I'm tired of the comments of my fellow disenchanted Americans saying that they disagree with our president's policy, so the EU needs to teach us a lesson. The idea behind our country is that it is governed "by the people", and the only reason that it feels like we don't have control is that lazy, complacent Americans let it get this way. Did you vote? Only 4 out of 10 of us did in the last election. If you want to make change, back it up with your actions. It's very easy to write to a Congress person, it's very easy to get to a voting booth. Don't sit back and expect someone else to "punish" us with sanctions. Let's not let is get that bad. Change is needed now, and all you have to do is vote in your local elections.
    Jeffrey McDonald, San Diego, CA, USA

    The EU needs the US more than the US needs the EU. The business news just mentioned that if California were a nation, it had just passed France as being the fifth most productive "country". The population of California is 36m and France is 58m. Many parts of the EU have repressive tax rates and layers of unneeded of management that stifle business growth. Many EU businesses prefer to be in a lower tax country, such as Ireland. I would be in favour, subject to a mutual vote, of making the UK the 51st state and forget worrying about the rest of Europe.
    John King, Eugene, Oregon, USA

    I think that the European Union needs the Americans as well as the Americans need the European Union to exist.
    Dr Victor, Donetsk, Ukraine


    I believe it is up to the EU to put its foot down and say "enough"

    Pieter Klerk, United States
    I believe it is about time that the EU put its foot down and told America "enough, it is our turn". With this whole idea of missile defence we are returning to the Reagan era and I for one am not ready to put myself through this again. It is time that the EU and GB tell America "thanks but no thanks". How long must we wait until the "World Power" Americans get to more important issues like Aids and global warming? If the powers of this country can't stop a stupid dream, then I believe it is up to the EU to put its foot down and say "enough".
    Pieter Klerk, Portland, Oregon, United States

    As an American who voted for Al Gore, I am ashamed that we are now represented by such an idiot who stated that he didn't believe in global warming (now his own committee tells him differently.) Yes, Europe can go it alone and should begin to exert its own will and America needs to learn a hard lesson that it has become an outsider in the "Family of Nations". We are so far behind on so many issues be it abortion, death penalty, environment, learning to work with rather than demanding always to be the leader. Only the Europeans can gain backbone and stand together against the stubborn and arrogant attitude of this administration.
    Helen Krishna, West Chester, PA, USA


    Thank God we have Mr Bush as president!

    Andrew (x Brit), USA
    Thank God we have Mr Bush as president! And I am happy to be on this side of the Atlantic Ocean. The attitude of anyone who dislikes the USA is usually one of jealousy. Typical socialist attitude.
    Andrew (x Brit), Greenville SC, USA

    "Is America out of touch with the world?" What world - there's something beyond our borders?
    Paul Komarek, Pittsburgh, USA

    Americans seem sick and tired of interfering in Europe and I'm sick and tired of it too. The US Government seems to think it has the right to act as the global police officer whilst Europe daren't wipe its own behind without permission from the US. Sure we need the US as an ally, and the US needs Europe as an ally whether it believes that or not, but can't we just leave it at that?
    Ian Chapman, Middlesbrough, UK


    I think it is wrong to impose the views of Europe on the US

    Zach Nuebel, Colorado, USA
    None of us would be here without the other. America would have never existed without Europe and Europe very well could have fallen if it was not for America. We are tied and whether you like it or not we're very much alike. However I think it is wrong to impose the views of Europe on the US. We cannot dictate much that occurs in the EU and yet Europe is supposed to have a free hand to do whatever you wish to America? The US is its own country with our own laws, customs, society, and beliefs. You cannot expect us to see eye to eye with you on everything. Nor can you demand that we halt a programme we've already spent billions of dollars on. The thought that it might spring a new arms race is true, but do you think we are not in one already? We have been for the last fifty years - just because it isn't on the surface doesn't mean it's not there.

    So yes we could survive without each other, even do well for ourselves in the process. But would it be preferable or even advisable? I think not.
    Zach Nuebel, Colorado, USA

    Europe does not need America. They may have needed help in the past but now they are in a position to stand up on their own feet. But I do believe that if Europe and America stand by each other in international disruptions then they have more chances of stopping a war.
    Catherine William, Oxford, Britain


    I regard the signs of differences between Europeans and Americans as a positive sign

    Deryck Bernard, Guyana
    I regard the signs of differences between Europeans and Americans as a positive sign and a blessing to the world. There is no benefit to civilisation from a unipolar world. Cultural diversity must manifest itself in lifestyle and political choices which emphasise those differences. There has been a tendency for journalists and politicians to over-estimate the degree of dominance of global cultural values. As someone who has lived in both cultures, it has always struck me that the differences in approach are profound and deep-seated. As a citizen of the third world, I find the differences comforting.
    Deryck Bernard, Georgetown, Guyana

    The only thing America is good for is the 'industry' Bush always refers to (frequently when defending his decision not to sign the Kyoto agreement)- this means the few elite people who make a profit from such industry.
    Tamara, Sydney, Australia

    Bush's stance stems from nationalist paranoia, born of a lack of knowledge of, and any real interest in, matters outside of the USA. Whether the world likes it or not, the USA is the most powerful country, in economic and military terms and it must therefore take on the position of leader in those fields, together with that of counsellor, peace maker etc. However, to do this satisfactorily that country needs an electoral system which ensures that its elected leaders get their positions not through simply the power of money and favour, but through a knowledge and sympathetic appreciation of things sometimes far removed from American domestic considerations.
    Roger Griffiths, Bristol, England


    Americans have an enormous amount of goodwill towards other countries

    Shane, USA (Australian)
    Americans have an enormous amount of goodwill towards other countries - if any of your listeners doubt this they should visit America to experience it themselves. Many America-bashers forget that World War II, essentially a messy Asian and European affair, created America as a superpower. Americans care as much about other countries as citizens of other countries care about most other countries - not much. Americans are interested in the rest of the world to the extent that they feel that other countries should become free and healthy democracies. Again, this is because Americans care most about their own freedom and liberty within their own country.
    Shane, Saint Paul, USA (Australian)

    "Europe" will never be a military superpower. Most European nations spend less than 2% of their GDP on defence, and that number is shrinking. The United States is twenty or more years ahead of Europe in military research. The armies of Europe are incapable of even defending themselves. If the EU had tried to intervene in Kosovo without U.S. help, the war would have ended with Serbian troops marching through Paris.
    Jeff, Omaha, USA


    Americans have no common purpose beyond their self-aggrandisement or accumulation of personal wealth

    James BlueWolf, Lakeport, USA
    As an American Indian, I have to laugh when the topic of narrow mindedness is brought up, especially when Hitler is mentioned. Spanish Europeans, British, French and American invaders killed many more of our Peoples on this soil than Hitler ever dreamed of! America is not great because of her political or economic systems but because she stole the richest lands on the face of the planet and proceeded to exploit the huge and broad-based resource. She has succeeded in enriching a portion of her population by polluting the air, water and environment, and developing technologies without examining the consequences - while trying to convince the rest of the world of her moral integrity, while exporting consumerism, militaristic commitment and roller coaster technological development with an empty promise that it will bring the entire world a more peaceful, bountiful and fulfilling life.
    James BlueWolf, Lakeport, USA

    I agree with Andy, Isle of Man. There seems to be a mix-up between anti-Bush and anti-US. Dubya and his corporate friends are perceived by all right-thinking people, both in the US and in the rest of the planet, as being anti-world. As he and his friends kneel and pray at the altar of the Great God Dollar, they don't seem to care in the slightest about anything other than the accumulation of their own wealth. Please don't confuse Dubya and his all-consuming greed with the feelings of the vast majority of decent Americans. They feel equally horrified at his contempt for anything decent.
    Mark Rees, California (Ex-Pat)

    The dream of "Europe Nation" will not work - too many deep-seated traditions, separate cultures, languages, and political differences. In fact I see the USA has naturally formed the "Euro/Asia Nation" as the immigrants and colonies from their mother countries learned to live and work together with the goal of forming a large free market economy which is rooted in English culture. So does Europe need USA? Or does USA need UK, France, China, etc, etc? Yes.
    Neil, Atlanta, Georgia


    I believe it is key that Europe and the United States keep their relationship strong

    Patrick Cooper-McCann, MI, USA
    I think what some Europeans may not understand is that even though President Bush is in office, most Americans disagree with at least a few points in his policy. I myself personally disagree with his stance on the Kyoto treaty and the death penalty among other things. I believe it is key that Europe and the United States keep their relationship strong and continue to grow together.
    Patrick Cooper-McCann, Hazel Park, MI, USA

    If Europe needs greed, corruption, global warming, and hatred; then Europe needs the US. Frankly though, it looks to me as if you have quite enough of your own.
    David Clifton, Boulder CO, USA


    Europe not only looks much different but has different needs

    Riz Rahim, USA
    Does Europe need to be more independent of the US is perhaps a better and more pertinent question, since even minor powers with little to do with each other still have some level of inter-dependence in this day and age. With the Iron Curtain gone, communism no longer a threat and Russia reduced to an economic basket-case, Europe not only looks much different but has different needs.
    Riz Rahim, USA

    I dream of the day when America can bring our troops and politics back home. Leave European politics to the Europeans...
    Edward, Central USA

    Today, Europe needs the US more than the US needs us. However, tomorrow, soon, we will need each other, if only to counter-balance China's huge powerhouse. Meanwhile, Europe needs to build itself as a political and military power, and not just an economic one. It also needs to quickly proceed with EU enlargement to fortify its eastern borders. A reasonable dose of EU-US (constructive) criticisms will do no harm and help both sides find the optimum.
    Noel Nicolas, London, UK

    Regardless of whether the EU needs the US or not, this is our planet, everyone's planet. The US, by not agreeing to the Kyoto treaty affects all of us. Sure other countries may have not agreed to it, but the US emits the largest amount of greenhouse gas into the atmosphere. This arrogance of the US thinking that it knows what's best for the rest of the world has to stop. Additionally, the president considering missile defence a higher priority than our planet, further demonstrates US aggression and its destructive ways.
    Dan, Sydney

    Firstly, I don't consider myself European, and I don't want anyone to say I am otherwise. I consider myself British, and I think we, the British would do much better as the 51st American State, than as part of a failing Europe with a failing currency. It's time to detach from Europe, and stick with our American friends, who helped us many, many times, and could continue to do so for centuries to come.
    Andrew Hannay, Shrewsbury, UK


    George Bush is not the demon he is being portrayed as

    Ken W, Tallahassee, Florida, USA
    The anti-American vitriol and histrionics posted here are very disturbing. I have concluded that this attitude is being fomented by "America haters". Everyone should take a deep breath. Calm down, everything will be all right. George Bush is not the demon he is being portrayed as.
    Ken W, Tallahassee, Florida, USA

    The trouble is that while the present US administration is inward looking, it has key policy decisions that have made the world more unstable - Kyoto, Star Wars, Middle East. They do not wish to take an active positive role in international affairs but make decisions that affects us all negatively.
    Francis Stevens George, Oslo, Norway

    What is the point of this debate? Europe is already the 51st State of the USA. The USA earned this moral right to the territory on D-Day. They are just modest about mentioning it. Have a nice day ...
    Adrian M. Shryane, UK

    I am not a fan of Dubya, but I find the criticism of him by Brits and Europeans in general more than a bit disingenuous. The ABM treaty is based on the dubious Mutually Assured Destruction (M.A.D.) theories of the 1960's and should be challenged. And as for Kyoto, the Brits and Europe should put their money where their mouth is and ratify the doggoned thing, if they really believe it isn't seriously flawed. I'm sick and tired of the America bashing. Get a life out there, people! All your anti-America drivel sounds like the rantings of a spoiled child who says, "I hate you" to daddy whenever you don't get your way.
    Don Truitt, Panama City, Florida, USA


    Just because we've been Americanised in the past, doesn't mean we have to stay that way

    Arkady, Tokyo, Japan
    Just because we've been Americanised in the past, doesn't mean we have to stay that way. Europe and indeed most of the world, can do without their interference, especially when it comes to military power and Hollywood films.
    Arkady, Tokyo, Japan

    Regarding the issue of the importing of American culture, I think it is an issue of choice. American films and music, even including the fast-food culture, thrive or fail by the number of people willing to spend money on them.
    Jeffrey Curnoles, Pennsylvania

    Europe and the United States are of the same blood. Our relationship is so close that we should all be able to disagree, and then work toward togetherness. We all love our culture and our children. The distinction which sets us apart, will also bind us together. Let's remember our common past, sacrifices and move forward together. Yes, we do need each other. Respect for each other must always be paramount. I, as an American love my country. I also respect Europe.
    Boatsan, Buffalo, USA

    I'm in complete shock after reading the messages left by Europeans about their feelings on the USA. I now regret that even one American died protecting Europe from Nazism or Communism. We should have left you to your own devices.
    Charlie Coffin, Charlotte, NC, USA

    Your comments during the programme


    Not once did I encounter any negative comments about the United States or President Bush

    Eugene Foster, Chesterfield, VA, USA
    I just returned from Europe after visiting Germany, France and Ireland. During this short trip, (2 weeks) I talked to many people and not once did I encounter any negative comments about the United States or President Bush. I realise that two weeks is not much time to make an educated analysis of how Europeans really feel about America. Europe should not be condemning President Bush about Kyoto, since not one single EU country has ratified the accord. Most people are not aware that the United States with only 5% of the world's population, produces 50% of the world's food supply.
    Eugene Foster, Chesterfield, VA, USA

    I would love to see the US withdraw its troops from Europe and be done with Nato. The Cold War is over. Aside from importing oil, we should lower our world-wide profile and concentrate on internal policies.
    Dave Holtz, Indianapolis, USA

    Esperanto died a death. Mandarin Chinese is now the MOST spoken language in the world (due to China's huge population). But English/ American is still the most WIDELY spoken. How can Europe effectively unite when no common language exists? When the UN peacekeeping dirty work needs doing and the dust has settled from other nations backing out for whatever lame reason, who's left standing there? The allies of the USA and UK. 1939 to 1945 may be a while ago, but not too far removed for some of us to remember who our real friends are. English speaking nations should stick together.
    Darren (English), USA


    I don't think that we in the US have anything to apologise for

    Arvind Rao, New York, USA
    I don't think that we in the US have anything to apologise for. The "social problems" we're criticised for are nothing compared to Oldham, Rostock or Marseilles. We are truly a multicultural society and while our lapses are well publicised, the racism here is nothing compared to Britain, France, Italy or Germany. I'd be very happy to stop paying taxes to keep troops in Europe.
    Arvind Rao, New York, USA

    The United States and the EU have more in common, than they do differences. It is important that they stay close and try to bring the rest of the world into harmony.
    Robert, London, England

    Nick from Boston refers to Europe "bringing the US into line". Bringing us in line with what, European values? Hello, we're not European! We need each other from a trade perspective, nothing more. If you want fireworks try to pressure us as Austria was recently pressured for Haider. Remember, there are two sides to every story.
    Thom, Ohio, USA


    I was in Gothenburg for the Bush demonstration two days ago

    Reidun Heiene, Oslo, Norway
    I was in Gothenburg for the Bush demonstration two days ago. I love both the US and European people (I lived both places) but we are witnessing our democracies being pulverised. What we see is the removal of power from national and local level into the WTO (which has a standing committee making sure that EU, NAFTA, APEC and the other regional trade agreements obey WTO). The system is driven by lobbying and secret negotiations; it is destructive to the environment; it increases poverty in both rich and poor countries.
    Reidun Heiene, Oslo, Norway

    We should not be talking about a divorce just now, even though that attracts a lot of interest in the media. Europe can be patient for four years with an American President that most of us (here too) don't want.
    Douglas Bredahl, North Fork, California

    In today's world cutting ties is simply not possible. Europe needs the USA's military might. The USA needs the diplomatic clout of its European allies. As for the supposed culture gap, the overall recent trend is that it is closing, not growing wider. Europe's economy is becoming more like America's free market system, and European style government programs have taken root in the US. If Europeans are truly dismayed over recent US actions, then the answer is to continue to engage them in dialogue. Cut ties with the US, and all your fears of us becoming a "rogue superpower" will come true.
    David M Gable, Warsaw, IN, USA


    America is such a huge place, though, it's easy to get wrapped up in what's going on in our own affairs

    David, Chicago, USA
    Believe it or not, there are Americans who know what's going on in the world and are sensitive to other cultures and politics. America is such a huge place, though, it's easy to get wrapped up in what's going on in our own affairs and not be aware of what goes on in other parts of the world. It's also time to stop the name-calling and the whining. We have more in common and share more values than not. If you want things to be different, then get over yourselves and do something about it.
    David, Chicago, USA

    European intervention in the Balkans only succeeded because of US air power. Many Americans complain about having to act as the world's policeman but I wonder if the "pax Americana" came to an end whether Americans would suffer the same crisis of identity that the British suffered when we had to give up our Empire? I think Europe has two options. Co-operation with the US or confrontation. Unfortunately I think there are forces at work within the EU determined to turn it into a super-power with the sole intention of confronting the US. The danger of such a strategy cannot be over estimated.
    Phil H, UK

    Could someone please point out that more than one country has actually ratified the Kyoto Accords? I know there is one, but it is neither France, Germany, the UK, Spain, Portugal or Japan. Maybe the EU will be so kind as to ratify it first. The EU and USA need each other, economically and militarily. And there aren't exactly hordes of Americans deciding to emigrate to the EU. Quite the opposite.
    Shaun S, Denver, CO, USA

    Your comments before we went ON AIR


    Europe dwarfs the United States in terms of economy, exports and population

    Rob Holman, London, England
    Europe dwarfs the United States in terms of economy, exports and population. The military potential is vast, with the right level of investment. Also, Europe is far more efficient and eco-friendly than the US. I think there should now be international sanctions against the United States, until it reduces its output of greenhouse gases. Who needs the US? I think Europe is fed up with being bullied, and is quite capable of standing up for itself.
    Rob Holman, London, England

    Of course Europe needs the USA! Indeed the only thing that individual countries of the EU can agree on is their envious loathing of everything and anything American. We are the cement that binds together this contrivance. The EU only offers antithesis. They are against this and contra that. But when will the EU propose anything as a practical alternative other than the tired blandishments of discredited socialism and feel good "green" touchy feely stuff that has no practical benefit to anyone? If the EU is so keen on the Kyoto Treaty, then why is Romania the only European country to ratify it? You hate us but still sit about whining and moaning, waiting for the USA to led. Grow up!
    Peter C. Kohler, Washington DC, USA

    Bush needs to think before he acts. His actions are those of a spoiled child.
    Gabriel Vargas, Mulege, Mexico

    We see the EU as a great market place for US products and we seem to be in love with anything made in the EU. I think the UK stands to profit greatly as the business link between the two. I'd buy some stock in that.
    Chris Meadows, Winston-Salem NC, USA


    So far the EU has been reasonably effective at addressing the economic concerns of its member states

    David Mellor, Washington DC
    This debate is particularly ridiculous. It is makes the initial flawed assumption that Europe exists as a single unified entity. There is as much contention and disagreement between national European leaders as there is between the nominal "Euro" leadership and the US. So far the EU has been reasonably effective at addressing the economic concerns of its member states. However, it has proven ridiculously ineffective at even addressing basic security needs. At some distant time in the future if "Europe" as a unified entity comes in to existence, then the question of "Does Europe need the US?" will possibly be a valid one.
    David Mellor, Washington DC

    Since Bush took over, it's as if we've transported ourselves back in time about 50 years. His policies are worrying and his abilities as a world leader are extremely questionable. Bring back Clinton I say, at least he was harmless!
    Kate, London, UK

    Europe is fuzzily defined and national pride will ultimately doom it to failure. The USA is beset with social problems and likely to destroy itself from within. I can't see that either can solve the other's problems. We can only, as we have been doing for so long, trade together for mutual benefit. We must accept, I think, that the future belongs to China.
    Gary, UK


    Turn your back on America to join the French and Germans at your peril

    Alex James, London, England
    Turn your back on America to join the French and Germans at your peril. The UK has always had a special relationship with America, something of which the rest of Europe has always been envious. They would love to drag us into their melting pot of thinly veiled self-interest, infighting and bickering. The UK must stand tall and hammer home the fact that we hold a unique position in the world at the centre of trading between America, Europe and the Commonwealth. Bush is bad news but he won't last and we mustn't let his policies do any lasting damage to our relationship with America.
    Alex James, London, England

    I'm from the Czech republic and I want my country to become a member of the EU. But I suppose that Europe isn't unfortunately able to solve its own problems without US help - for example recent war in Yugoslavian Kosovo. I think that European politicians have the ability to make things more complicated than necessary. I can't understand why most of European politicians don't agree with US plan to build new "SDI". The only thing that we (Europeans) can do in the relationship to the USA is to criticise. I think that Europe can't refuse USA as its partner, because Europe needs USA more than we're able to realise (unfortunately).
    Jan Netopil, Olomouc, Czechia


    It is time for Europe and Asia to work together

    Nick, Boston, USA
    We should face facts - the US is an irresponsible, selfish and unreliable power. It is time for Europe to make the facts clear - that we should operate without American influence, and should create a better and more civilised global system. It is time for Europe and Asia to work together, and to bring the US firmly into line.
    Nick, Boston, USA

    With all this 'America' bashing, it would be interesting to look into the future, of a world where the United States and Europe were not allies. Please remember, the US has many natural resources at its disposal, and also has a very modern industrial /technological infrastructure. Compare that to Europe, an over crowded landmass with limited natural resources. If we are not allies, what side do you think could handle a direct conflict with a growing communist powerhouse similar to the USSR?
    Mike, USA


    The EU and the UN have the power to tell the US to 'take a hike' if they so desire

    Jim, New Orleans, USA
    There are people in America who are sick of the United States taking the role of the 'world's policeman'. Many people do not realise that President Clinton utilised the military more than any other president in history during peacetime. The EU and the UN have the power to tell the US to 'take a hike' if they so desire. I have heard from so many Brits that the US is so much more than Britain. I really think that they need to take a good hard look at what the US is truly like. While I love this country and all it stands for, there are many many problems at home which could be solved if we would worry more about what happens here in the US and less about what happens in the rest of the world.
    Jim, New Orleans, USA

    As an American I sincerely apologise for George Bush and his ignorance. The European Union keeping him from destroying the world is our only hope.
    Lori, USA

    America is merely suffering from the hangover of the last 50 years. It is still clearly the only real superpower, a status which has been awarded over its huge economic and military growth since the 1950's. As such it has had the freedom to do as it chooses with this power. Just as critics were saying that the Labour party had become arrogant with its majority, so the US became arrogant with its power. The shift of power however, is changing. The EU's economy is at the same level as the US, and with the introduction of a European army, reliance on American military might will also reduce. Still, America has always been a friend to Europe, this at least should not change.
    Mark Stubbs, London


    Europe also needs to understand that it is no longer the USA's largest trading partner. Latin America is.

    Jerry, USA
    Europe has been relatively peaceful for 56 years. This is probably the longest peace in Europe's history, and Europe can thank the USA for making it possible. It is tiresome to hear the Europeans talk of the dumb, unsophisticated Americans who don't know anything about diplomacy or politics when, left to their own devices, Europeans really mucked up the world, and if it were not for America, would do it again. Europe also needs to understand that it is no longer the USA's largest trading partner. Latin America is.
    Jerry Bailey, Fort Worth, Texas

    In America there an awful lot of people that are in favour of the death penalty, but against abortion. In Europe there are a lot of people that are pro abortion, but against the death penalty. I fail to see what the problem is. In America there a lot of people that want a first class military without getting involved in world affairs. In Europe there a lot of people that want to be involved in world affairs without the military muscle to back it up. In America we have some of the most stringent environmental laws in the world, but a lot folks would like to get rid of them. In Europe you have a country that likes to nuke tropical islands while still pretending to be environmentally conscious, and lets not forget the country that still hunts whales. What a merry bunch of ninnies!!!!
    Mario T. Majors, Yokosuka, Japan

    Yes my European friends, go ahead and encourage the EU and the rest of the world to leave the USA behind. Perhaps 50 years from now when China is a superpower and Indonesia is at the very least a threat to Australia the EU will come to Australia's aid when its economic and political sovereignty is endangered. Yes cousins, you can be sure the Belgians, Greeks and Danes will sail to Australia's (you can use a variety of scenarios as an example) aid in a time of crisis...
    Craig, San Jose, CA

    I am ashamed of those Americans who write that we acted in WW2 only to help the Europeans. Nonsense! It was in our own interest to stop a fiend like Hitler, and to stop the Japanese aggression. The main problem between us today is Mr. Bush and his cohorts, who got into office in a most peculiar way. There will be a lot of pressure from Americans themselves about his policies, and with both the Europeans and Americans disturbed about everything the administration here has in mind, everything should come out for the better. Keep up the criticism -- we need your help.
    megan sweet, camp sherman, oregon


    Just try cutting economic ties across the Atlantic. You couldn't if you wanted to.

    Don, USA
    I laugh at much of the naiveté expressed on this question, which is moot but carefully phrased to inflame nationalistic fever. You talk as if the world is still in the 19th century. That would have been a more appropriate century for isolationist talk because it's much too late now. How much nationalistic integrity do you think your country has in this day and age of multi-national mega-corporations? When the Ford Corporation of America can continue to collect stock revenues from German companies during World War II what chance do you think there is that any western nation is going to be allowed to cut off another. You want to cause a world depression that will make the 1930's look like a beach holiday? Just try cutting economic ties across the Atlantic. You couldn't if you wanted to. As far as world leadership is concerned Europe has their chance in Macedonia right now. Bush is sick of that Balkans mess so if the KLA refuses to leave Macedonia then Europe can remove them themselves. I'm sure the KLA will vacate when faced with Europes' internationally respected EU rapid deployment force armed with sputtering indignation.
    Don Drakulich , USA

    Europe should consider the fact that the US is pulling away from its European roots at an ever-increasing rate. Hispanic and Asian emigration into the US will soon make the people of European extraction a minority group. Bush is right in not pandering to Europe and increasing overtures toward Mexico and Latin America. This group is currently the US largest trading partner and its importance will continue to increase.
    Peter Cuneo, Dix Hills,USA

    The question implies Europe is a power on equal footing with the US. Neither economically, not militarily, is this the case. The UK would more likely petition to become the 51st state than leave NATO, and we all know France is too scared of Germany to trade NATO protection for the EU. As far as the US being out of touch with the rest of the world, this is simply not the case. Europeans are just out of touch with reality.
    Eric, Seattle, USA

    I am an American student currently studying in Japan. The general European consensus seems to be that all Americans are narrow-minded and unconcerned with the rest of the world. If Bush were to represent all of America, this would certainly be true. However, when judging the American people, it is necessary to remember that half the population did not even vote for Bush. Furthermore, numerous contacts with home have made it abundantly clear that the American youth detests Bush and his policies.
    Sarah, Toyohashi, Japan

    This entire debate seems driven by an ill-justified sense of hysteria on both sides. Obviously, Europe is hyper-aware of the US's economic and military influence in the world. At the same time, some Europeans seem utterly ignorant of the unprecedented political, social, and cultural influence that Europe wields throughout the world. If European press and public opinion realized how influential Europe has become, they might not be driven by insecurity to lash out at America in bitter, mean-spirited tones. Americans who have sacrificed much for Europe might not feel ungratefully maligned. And the whole vicious cycle of transatlantic name-calling might be avoided.
    John Senior, Washington, DC, USA


    The United States is the biggest obstacle in Europe's approach towards Asia

    T J Won, Seoul, South Korea
    Despite having all the conditions that make her every bit as equal, if not better, as the United States, Europe's unnecessary dependence and reliance on America is decreasing potential cooperation between the European Union and the Asian community. As the dominant Western power in the Pacific region, the United States is the biggest obstacle in Europe's approach towards Asia, and that will have devastating effect on Europe's economy and its influence on the world in the long run.
    T J Won, Seoul, South Korea

    The citizens of the European countries need to understand the impact of the division developing within the US. The election says it all. Half the US people agree with the same European values and they want strong ties with Europe.
    Mark, Indianapolis, US

    The EU is becoming ever more powerful with its euro army and economic stability, the US is now close to recession I believe that President Bush is worried the EU will be the next US.
    James Smith, UK

    As the USA seems always to come to the aid of Europe, World War I, World War II, Cold War, Balkans, it is difficult to imagine Europe without US support. Perhaps we should ask when has Europe ever helped the USA (or the UK for that matter)
    Keith Miles, London England

    Europe needs the United States for its own political stability. Without the United States the Europeans would soon be fighting wars among themselves as they have done for thousands of years. Our troops stationed there for over 50 years have presided over the longest peacetime is the history of Europe. This is not a coincidence. The US can make it "alone" without Europe, of course with some sacrifice. However Europe needs the US for its long-term political stability and financial survival. My ancestors (Hopkins) came over on the Mayflower to escape to freedom. Millions of Europeans followed. You, Europeans, built the United States. We are your friends and distant relatives, appreciate what your ancestors created. History shows they have saved you from yourselves time after time.
    Joe Arko, Plano, Texas, U.S.

    Having lived in the US and parts of Europe, there is no doubt in my mind that most Americans do not know what is going on in the world around them. That is why it is difficult to understand why Europe does not agree in many sensitive issues including global warming, abortion and arms. Much as Europe needs America, America itself cannot depend on itself for everything. That is why it is necessary that George Bush does not take a hard line in those issues that of interest to the rest of the world.
    J K Parlin, New Jersey, USA


    Remember half of us Americans did not vote for Bush.

    Marcus Lloyd, USA
    What the rest of the world needs to remember is that the United States is a nation of many different people. We do not all think of one accord and are not a giant mass of coca-cola guzzling people. Sure Americans tend to be narrow-minded. But remember half of us Americans did not vote for Bush in the election and as hard as it is to believe we do care about the rest of the world. But in a nation so powerful only the voice of those currently in power will tend to be heard by the rest of the world. Sure Europe needs America but it doesn't have to be that way. As all Americans know we always look to Europe for guidance even though we may not admit it
    MARCUS LLOYD, TALLAHASSEE USA

    As an Englishman staying in the US I have realised that yes, Americans are ignorant of what goes on in much of the world, but in a country of this size they have no need to look overseas. There are many problems within the US that needs tending too so it is understandable that at times the rest of the world comes second. Europe is all too ready to criticise the US when they try to control the world, and then attacks them again when they decide not to intervene. Unfortunately Europe and especially the UK are reliant on the US for many things, economically and militarily and so it is something we have to accept for now. A united Europe will strengthen our position but this is a long way off, especially with the British resistance to European induction.
    Neal, MI, USA

    I find it amazing after reading so much negative, narrow-minded dribble from the Europeans in this forum that they believe we Americans are the ignorant lot. So much talk, but no action. The European's desire to become a super-power seems to be based entirely upon jealousy of American influence and power. Stop talking and do something about it. But of course Europe is not really known for action. That is our job. Europeans talk Americans do. That's the difference and that's why Europe will always need the United States.
    John T., FL, USA

    Naturally Europe needs the economic might of the US to sustain our standard of life. This goes without saying. We need each other. However, think of it this way. If you were having a party, and the biggest, richest guy in the communal house decided to start setting fire to the furniture - everyone would agree that he should stop. Now imagine the big, rich guy stating 'I'm personally having fun burning this furniture so I refuse to stop. What would you think of this guy? That's what Europeans think of the American Kyoto policy.
    Dave Rawlinson, London, UK

    Of course Europe needs the U.S.! The 20th century, with its two world conflicts (three if we take the cold war into account) will most likely be seen by future historians as the era against totalitarianism i.e. communism and fascism. The U.S. played a major part in all these conflicts and tipped the scales in favour of parliamentary democracy paying a heavy price. We must never forget that. On the other hand, the nations of Europe, with centuries of history on their backs, have a long way to go before they agree upon a collective foreign policy.
    Dimitris S. Mentis, Athens, Greece


    Leadership comes through moral high ground and ethics, not by economic leverage exerted on others

    Norman, SanJose, Costa Rica
    It is high noon at the Bush corral and time for US leadership to realize that their interests and rights stop where those of the rest of the world start. Leadership comes through moral high ground and ethics, not by economic leverage exerted on others. True the US economy has been a major contributor to world economic growth. Only a dogmatic die-hard would argue that this is not so, but then again, there is a price for growth and it is plain wrong for the US to seek the achievement of its economic goals by ignoring the rest of the worlds interests. The EU and the US need each other, those who claim otherwise are adopting foolish ethnocentric positions that are unrealistic; just as it would be foolish for the US to believe that the rest of the world- and namely Europe share and are committed to American values and priorities. Yes globalisation is not a two way street, but rather like a traffic circle: we either all drive in the same direction albeit- at different speeds - or Risk not getting anywhere soon. Unfortunately Washington believes that it is the rest of the world going the wrong way....
    Norman, SanJose, Costa Rica

    Europe and the US do need each other in various ways. However, the US has royally mishandled its role in the last decade. It has put too much energy into carrying out a nonsensical campaign designed by tunnel-visioned American politicians, who unlike European politicians, have had absolutely no diplomatic training whatsoever. Intervention in Europe without fully comprehending European issues, which include east and central Europe as well as the EU, is absolutely absurd on the part of Washington. If Washington reorganizes and educates itself and becomes sensitive to European needs, it would certainly be a valuable ally. Europe is more than just a geopolitical playground; it's home to 700 million people and thousands of years of civilization.
    Anna Maria Venetou, Thessaloniki, Greece

    Europe is trying to assemble what America has had for more than two hundred years. All policies aside, the EU needs to look inward and concentrate on it's own problems. I'd be willing to bet that the new EU melting pot that is in its infancy is going to boil over before it even gets started, while the US continues to do what it has always done. Europeans will soon find that saving the environment, while important to a point, will quickly fade in importance when the unified economy is not providing the commoner population with basic happiness. Remember, fundamentally, the US is just a bunch people that migrated from the rest of the world motivated by a better life.
    John A, Upsate New York, USA

    Bush is not the problem, U.S. arrogance is. A people totally consumed by their life style and the money it takes to fund it. America is the modern-times Roman Empire, seeing only itself when it comes to human rights, morals, justice and economy. The time has come for the U.S to stop pushing its nose into every corner of the world, and to put an end to its Coca Colonization of the world. America is more then a way of life, it's a state of mind. And it's bad.
    Nimrod Halpern, Tel Aviv, Israel


    What our American friends need to realise is that Globalisation does not infer Americanisation

    Lawrie Elder, Dubai
    The days of the US deciding European economic and military policy are over. What our American friends need to realise is that Globalisation does not infer Americanisation. A global economy and socio - political structure, demands that everyone changes its ways to reach majority consensus. Failure of the US to recognise this will hurt them a lot more than Europe.
    Lawrie Elder, Dubai

    Thank goodness that French president Jacques Chirac had the courage to stand up and say what other European leaders only mumble behind their hands: that President Bush's proposed nuclear missile defence system 'is a fantastic incitement to (nuclear) proliferation.' In other words, Bush is more concerned with stimulating the American economy through a massive escalation of military spending than through any meaningful strategy to stabilize world peace. It is not by chance that General Colin Powell is constantly at his shoulder during this trip. Any way he might dress it up, Bush is selling a return to the arms race on this trip, and most Europeans simply don't want it.
    Alix Sharkey, Paris, France


    I moved back from the U.S. to Europe due mainly to the "culture vacuum"

    Kambiz Shahri, Zurich, Switzerland
    I have lived extensively in the U.S. and am an European. The way I see it the 2 cultures complement each other: U.S. gung-honess offsets European "dithering". European cultural resistance, offsets American naiveté and uncouthness, when it comes to the rest of the world. However, if only the Europeans "believed" in themselves, then the U.S. would not factor as much in our psyche. I moved back from the U.S. to Europe due mainly to the "culture vacuum". Do we need the U.S.? Yes we do for practical reasons, but not at the cost of putting up with what is a precocious and spoilt culture.
    Kambiz Shahri, Zurich, Switzerland

    I have to agree that the rash of anti-American sentiment I have seen here and elsewhere is really quite absurd. Certainly America has problems and flawed policies, but so does Europe, and the rest of the world for that matter. If you disagree with American actions or policies, state it, but do not insult the people. I for one, would never dream of making a blanket insult directed at the people of Europe. Additionally, please remember that several hundred thousand Americans have died on European soil in the past hundred years, fighting against European tyrants. America is not perfect, but no one else is either.
    J. Whitebread, USA (currently Japan)

  • Search BBC News Online

    Advanced search options
    Launch console
    BBC RADIO NEWS
    BBC ONE TV NEWS
    WORLD NEWS SUMMARY
    PROGRAMMES GUIDE
    See also:

    08 Jun 01 | Europe
    Bush's tricky European tour
    Internet links:


    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


    Links to more Talking Point stories