Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: Talking Point
Front Page 
World 
UK 
UK Politics 
Business 
Sci/Tech 
Health 
Education 
Entertainment 
Talking Point 
Forum 
In Depth 
AudioVideo 

Wednesday, 9 May, 2001, 14:37 GMT 15:37 UK
Space tourism: Will it catch on?

US businessman Dennis Tito has become the world's first space tourist.

Mr Tito blasted off on a 10-day trip to the International Space Station (ISS) on Saturday and has paid Russian space chiefs a reported $20m (14m) for the privilege.

The flight is a dream come true for the Californian financier, who has been trying to join the elite club of space travellers for decades.

Many believe that this is just the beginning of space tourism and plans are in place for huge "luxury cruisers" which will carry up to 500 tourists into space for prices starting at "just" $100,000.

Are you interested? Will travelling to the outer limits catch on? Or is it sunshine and sand for you?

This debate is now closed. Read a selection of your comments below.


Your reaction


I hope that space tourism does not catch on too fast

HNS, USA
I hope that space tourism does not catch on too fast. While I am not adverse to it, I believe that there is still a lot to be understood about our universe, and it is best left to people who know what they are doing. If someone has $20 million to waste, they can invest it in space research, or in research on earth itself. There are a lot of worthy organisations that could use that kind of money, and help society profit from it.
HNS, USA

It's hard to imagine that the space age has lasted for half a century and only now in 2001 do we have the first space tourist. By now we should have gone to Mars and colonised the Moon. It's all very well saying that this is just science fiction but had we kept the space programme on, 2001 really could have been 2001!
Richard, Wales

I wonder how long before Branson is sniffing around this new route?
Mark, UK

I understand from the BBC that James Cameron is hoping to visit the ISS by 2003. Is it too much to hope that he might stay there and therefore ensure that he does not subject us to more insulting travesties like 'Titanic'?
Mark Rees, California (ex-pat)

Bravo, Tito, I am proud of you...you will be forever in the Earth history book. I think Russia will have to start building a new MIR-2 outpost station (together with "space bus") which can be used as a space hotel, not just because it's profitable, because other nations need to know more about the cosmos, and how our Earth is small. The Earth is just a cradle, normal man cannot spend his whole life in cradle...so let's go farther into space...
Alexei, Russia


This is a lesson for us all, never give up on your dreams

Dave, Canada
Space tourism will definitely be a reality one day - it's the next logical step for a species of curious, inquisitive primates, which is basically what we are. I would be willing to bet that Dennis Tito's success in life probably has been fuelled by that boyhood dream that became his passion. From dreams come goals and from goals can come the fulfilment of dreams. This is a lesson for us all, never give up on your dreams. Well done, Denis!
Dave, Vancouver Canada

I think it will catch on. Initially, as in every other field, it will be the privileged wealthy who get first bite but that will change. It was less than 20 years after flight was "invented" that planes took on fare-paying passengers. It has been 40 years since we first went into space. Surely it's about time those "elitist few" opened up the doors and let the general population in on the excitement. Had I the money, I'd book a ticket right now.
Graham, UK

I think it won't catch on until the fares are a little bit cheaper.
Brian Milner, UK

I think space is dramatised that much on TV and in films that people will not really think they're missing anything - it'll be the thrill of the ride that appeals more.
Andy Moon, England

I think that space tourism will catch on but will everyone pay large sums of money just to do something that Neil Armstrong did in 1969?
Akream, England


NASA are being a little childish and elitist about this

Martin, UK
I'd do it. I reckon by the time I'm 60 flights should be down to about $100,000 and I'm already saving. It is a childhood dream come true and I'll be there! NASA are being a little childish and elitist about this I think.
Martin, UK

I for one am more than happy for Mr. Tito. Maybe he is opening the door to space for the rest of us. I will probably not live long enough to get to space myself, but maybe the young people of today will get there. Access to space for the chosen few will come to an end eventually one way or another. All who dare to have a right to reach for the stars.
Tom Ellis, USA

I doubt it will take off (if you pardon the pun!). Just look at the economics of Concorde - there are not enough people out there with the kind of cash needed. And if there are, perhaps they should be taxed a bit more!
Richard G, UK

Tito endangered nobody's life, was not a burden on anyone, went through all the training and paid his way. I'm just surprised that NASA, who is continuously looking for ways to save and raise money, would be hostile to something that can become a lucrative business and can fund their scientific endeavours. Right now they are funded taxpayers who are no closer to visiting their "purchases" than they were 200 years ago.

Most people are forgetting that scientists only recently started going to space, before that it was military personnel and pilots. The fact that a lay person can become an astronaut and visit space should be a cause to celebrate. Dennis Tito is the first person in half a century of space flight to prove that space is a viable place for our children. He should go down in history as a pioneer in his own right.
Sirtaj, Australia

NASA started it by taking John Glenn up for a birthday present. Both his trip and Tito's were wasteful and dangerous.
Ken Roger, USA


Poor NASA, they have held on to their elitist hero status for so long

Jack Simpson, USA
Poor NASA, they have held on to their elitist hero status for so long, now they must let part of it go due to a space tourist named Dennis Tito. The news yesterday said that the people at NASA were under incredible stress due to the fact that Tito was aboard the ISS. I know how they feel. Years ago I was a paratrooper in the U.S. Army. I was under the impression that I was a member of such an elite group. No one could do what I could do. Then civilians found out how much fun it was to jump out of airplanes. Now, everyone who wants to skydive can do it with very little trouble. I, who was so impressed with myself and my accomplishment, do not jump anymore. I enjoyed being special. Now, with anyone and everyone jumping, it just isn't special anymore. So, NASA, wipe away your tears and join the rest of us who were, at one time, special.
Jack Simpson, USA

I'd love to go to space and wait for the day when I can afford to pay for it.
Aamir Bhatti, USA/PAKISTAN

If this is a way of generating a lot more money for space research then I'd say "go for it". Of course participants should have to sign away all rights to sue, if something goes wrong. I'm sure that, like me, many feel that commitment has decreased since the Apollo landings. If there had been enough money and determination we would probably have put men on Mars by now. Maybe space tourism might help us achieve this goal. For the vast majority who can't afford a trip outright perhaps some form of lottery would prove an excellent way of getting even more money in.
David Getling, England

I think to actually view the Earth from space (not on TV) would completely alter everyone's perception of how we all co-exist on this insignificant piece of rock. I await the day I can go with excitement.
Dan F, England


Mr Tito should pay the full cost for his space vacation

Paul, USA
Mr Tito should pay the full cost for his space vacation, which would probably be around half a billion dollars, not the measly $20 million he paid.
Paul, USA

Mr Tito's visit to the ISS is marvellous! Your report of NASA reaction highlights their elitist attitude. It is NOT a issue of safety but of power and big-brother control.
Anthony J. Sanner, US

It is a great idea to be able to go into space for research purposes, however not for fun. I believe it will be elitist and damage the ozone further.
Mark Ty Faltin, UK

Raising mass out of the Earth's gravitational field is a very expensive business. It has been estimated that the cost of an astronaut carrying a single ballpoint pen on the Apollo missions (in terms of extra fuel load) may have been as much as 50,000. So, in order to be profitable, the proposed craft for 500 space-tourists will necessarily require them to be packed in like sardines. The threat of deep vein thrombosis is worrying enough in conventional airliners due to the limited opportunity for passengers to extend their legs. But the likelihood of this life-threatening condition being aggravated in low orbits under negligible accelerations for long periods of time, and the increased possibility of incremental damage to both somatic and semantic tissues from cosmic rays in a properly shielded craft are likely to be immeasurable. As such, most doctors would advise against space travel on the basis of severe danger.
Dr Paul Jenson , UK


Space tourism is as inevitable as terrestrial tourism

Arri London, EU/US
Congrats to Dennis Tito and the Russian Space Agency. Space tourism is as inevitable as terrestrial tourism. A certain segment of the human population likes and needs to see new places. As for saving the environment or putting the money to other uses, if Mr Tito had wanted to do that, he would have by now. NASA's whingeing sounds very much like sour grapes.
Arri London, EU/US

Astronauts have many times said that once someone has seen Earth as a whole, it is hard to see it in parts again. Maybe every world leader should be sent into space for a week.
Rajeev Dutt, Germany

A week in the International Space Station is like a week in a cell of a maximum security prison (maybe worse). However I wouldn't mind a 1-2hr space flight if it's 100% safe. If not, virtual reality will do it for me.
Max, NZ

Of course the space industry should be helped with revenue from space tourism. Perhaps that way, we may finally get a manned mission to Mars before most of us retire!
Tim Abernethy, England

With finite resources here on Earth, space really is our future. If the explorers of the 15th and 16th centuries had waited for the creation of a perfect society before they set off on their travels, no-one would have ventured further than their own coastline. Space tourism will provide an important boost, financially and socially, to our inexorable migration towards the stars.
Phil, UK


Why would anyone want to stay in a cramped capsule in space?

Mark, UK
Why would anyone want to stay in a cramped capsule in space, with only small windows out of which to view the world beneath? There will be no new cultures to explore and smells to smell. However if you have the money and want to spend time in these cramped conditions then go now, before charter operators start taking everybody into space.
Mark, UK

In every exploration, from Neolithic times to the present, there was always an elite group of explorers that went first. When the first wave of tourists began to follow, they were wealthy, desperate or forced. Only when the second wave of tourism began - when the tourism infrastructure was in place, the destinations became desirable and the cost dropped to middle class affordability - did the opportunity become fully realised. Humans are forever reaching out. Our hand has now extended that much further. Tito has every right to appropriate Neil Armstrong's words as this step forward is as significant, if not more so, to the people of the world as the first steps on the moon.
Craig Thomler, Australia

I think NASA should be supporting Dennis Tito instead of trying to hinder his marvellous achievement of being the first tourist in space. It's time that these egocentric bureaucrats at NASA realise that space should be available for everyone, not just an elite few. All I can say is Good One on You Russia, another First in Space!
John Hess, Oregon/USA


Tito is a pioneer who has already written himself into the history books

Simon Cornforth, UK
Like it or not, Tito is a hero for all the Star Trek fans out there who would do anything to be in his shoes. I know I would. It's been mentioned that we should worry about what's happening 'down here' before we go 'up there', but if we could see our world from space, perhaps more would be persuaded that the planet we live on is very small in comparison to the Universe and should be respected for it. Tito is a pioneer who has already written himself into the history books, it's just a shame that we all are not as privileged as he is. I hope I see the day that I can join the 'tourists in space'. Much respect. The Earth is beautiful, we all know it, so why not appreciate it in all its glory.
Simon Cornforth, UK

I'd go if it was remotely affordable - like the price of a new car. It'll surely be a big business within a couple of decades.
Reginald Martin, Canada

I hope Dennis Tito learns how to drive the rocket into space. Then, when he comes back, he could buy it and set up some kind of space tourism business.
Carlos, UK

Do any of you "Trekkies" out there realise how uncomfortable and deadly outer space is? If you want to be constantly bombarded with radiation, watch your bones and muscles degrade, drink your steak and chips through a straw, get used to using a vacuum cleaner as a toilet, and spend your time never knowing which way is "up", then go for it. Me...after being designed for thousands of years to exist in our atmosphere, gravity, temperature and protection from solar radiation, I think I'll go to the Canaries!
Paul Fosbery, England


This is a door that cannot be closed now

Peter Cook, USA
I can't wait to read his book and see the movie if one is made. NASA is coming off like an organisation that is elitist. Sure space is dangerous but what if the Europeans and British had allowed only their professional explorers to travel to the New World? People will die and get injured in the process of populating space and planets. It's something we have to accept. I am glad the Russians have opened the door, if only by a crack, for everyone else to have the chance to go into space. This is a door that cannot be closed now.
Peter Cook, USA

Yet another case of Just Because It Can Be Done, It Should Be Done. Well, so many beautiful places on the planet's surface have been visually and culturally ruined by all the tatty, grasping paraphernalia of commercial tourism, so I suppose it's only a matter of time before the same fate befalls "the final frontier."
Simon Feegrade, England

Since the entire space program (here in America) was built on the backs of the American taxpayer, I'd like to see an increase in space tourism. That way, we could all be refunded our share for this 'commercial' venture. I don't pay taxes to support other 'private' facilities for the rich and famous (other than Congress of course). By all means, let's use more tax dollars to find diversions to spice up the droll and boring lives of the well-to-do!
Paul A. Lux, Florida, USA

Don't think I'd bother really. There are still far to many interesting and beautiful places ON Earth to see before I'd want to spend lots of money to go up into space
Mike, UK

The idea that this has just broken open a huge rush into space by tourists is kind of silly. I don't think we need worry about camera-clad tour groups in Hawaiian shirts dumping empty oxygen canisters all over Tranquility Base. The cost is not going to go down anytime soon. "Space Tourism" will be a novel way to separate the extremely wealthy from their money, while giving them the ride of their lives. If they can help defray the huge costs of this research, and are willing to meet the training and physical requirements, I say let them subsidise it!
Frank Bailey, USA


It should be available for everyone and not just for the rich and famous

Michael Pala, UK
I would very much like to go into space. When space tourism does become reality, it should be available for everyone and not just for the rich and famous.
Michael Pala, UK

If I could afford it, I would love to see our beautiful earth from space. After saving for a charter supersonic flight on Concorde for three years, I felt privileged to have done that, and got so close to space. Concorde was a wonderful experience, but space would be the next logical and wonderful step. It also makes you appreciate what a precious earth we are lucky enough to live on.
Phil W, UK in USA

Congratulations, Mr. Tito, on bucking the system and putting this whole space adventure into perspective. I entirely agree with the Russians, it's about time NASA looked at what they have to offer and offered it to the public. For sure it's not affordable for everyone, but then they don't have the capacity to take a whole lot of people up there at once. Mr. Tito and our Russian space colleagues are to be congratulated!
Ash, USA

I applaud Mr Tito for his perseverance, but I hope that mass space tourism is postponed until a vastly less polluting method of reaching orbit is developed.
J Grimston, U.K.

I, like Mr Tito, share the same dream since childhood, and I would love to make such a trip. After 50 years of space programmes reserved exclusively to astronauts, I think it's time for ordinary people (like me) to have a go too.
A Parks, England


If I had $20m I'd be standing in line, right behind him

Ian Stimson
To see all of Earth in one view, and 1000 times the stars visible from its surface, what price can you put on that? Suffice to say, I'd pay it if I could, gladly. Dennis Tito has made real what only a few years ago was a dream for anyone with a long view. If I had $20m I'd be standing in line, right behind him.
Ian Stimson, UK

Can anybody think of anything more boring than floating around in confined space, frightened to touch anything in case you break it? Fair enough, the take-off would be fun - as would the landing - but come on... get a life. Tito is probably bored to death and already writing his book to pass the time. Also, let's focus on Earth before we go further afield in the cosmos looking for other planets to destroy.
Andy Bennett, Oxford, England

Never mind popping up for a holiday - the way we're treating our own planet, soon space will be the only place open for us!
Derick, Ireland

What's the point in travelling away from everything and everyone into the absolute void emptiness of timeless space?
Alex Christakis, Greece


Space exploration has not made the jump into "real life"

Paul Drinkwater, UK
Expansion and exploration beyond our own planet should be a goal for all humankind. Space exploration has not made the jump into "real life". It's specialist and out of reach. This tourist thing seems to have generated more interest in space than I can remember. It's brought it back into the realm of ordinary people - very wealthy people true, but not scientists or military pilots with years of training and that seems very positive to me. We are nearing the technological point where "cheap" launch vehicles are attainable. If the potential funding available from the leisure market can pull that day forward, all the better.
Paul Drinkwater, UK

I would be interested in seeing some research into the environmental costs of each launch into space. I guess that the main damage is to the atmosphere, especially the upper atmosphere. I did once see a comparison of one jet liner producing the equivalent damage of 4000 badly tuned older cars. The upper layers of the atmosphere are especially sensitive to pollution, from dumping re-entry vehicles too.
David Broatch, New Zealand

It's a great idea. I'd like to think that fifty years from now, taking a 'vacation' into space will be as common and harmless as taking one at a typical seaside resort. I'd relish the opportunity to launch into space. It must be a fantastic sight. I envy Mr Tito and I hope he enjoys his trip.
Mick Deal, UK


Dennis Tito has proved that space is for all humanity

John McVey, Scotland
I think in many ways this is more important for ordinary humans than the first lunar walk of Neil Armstrong. This really does open up a whole new frontier to humanity, whereas previous access to space was merely at the discretion of government agencies. As an aside, I think politicians and leaders of polluting industries should be sent into space, just so they can see the beauty of the planet they're destroying. One thing Dennis Tito has proved is that space is for all humanity, not just the military!
John McVey, Edinburgh, Scotland

I would only go into space if they did air-miles.
D. John, UK

Commercial aviation didn't exactly start out as low-cost, low-risk. If I had that kind of money to burn and my family were pleased to be rid of me, I would be queuing up for the ride on that booster too. I would be less happy about the shuttle though. Reliability needs simplicity and the shuttle is a bit too advanced to be reliable for this potential space-tourist.
Hugh Kennedy, Germany

When Tito returns to Earth, everybody dress up in ape suits. Pass it on!
Brian Mccaul, Ireland, Planet Earth

His flight - the first tourist space flight - is the beginning of the era. And Russians made it possible. Just as the first satellite, the first man in the space (Gagarin), the first man stepping out of a spaceship into the open (Leonov), the longest stay in a spaceship. We did all of it. Even after sinking the Mir (which has more than paid off for itself by contributing to the mankind's knowledge), Russia's still setting milestones in the opening up of space. I personally can hardly stand sea ships, let alone spaceships... so all the more thumbs up for Tito and the Russian Space Agency.
Vova, Russia

Nice if you can afford it. Just goes to show the gap between haves and have-nots isn't getting any smaller.
P, UK


There is nothing out there except.... Space!

Joseph, UK
What is the big deal? There is nothing out there except.... well "Space!" Unless there is something like a five star hotel on the moon instead of a rather tatty lump of metal floating in our outer atmosphere, I would prefer to buy myself a private jet and a luxury yacht and spend the rest of my life travelling this beautiful planet (instead of a couple of days in a vacuum!).
Joseph, UK

I am interested in astronomy, but at the moment I would rather stay on the blue planet and look at the heavens. And the cost involved outweighs my interest in astronomy.
Manjit Singh, England


I would travel to space if I could afford it

John Ngassa, Britain
I have always liked stories about space, science and astronomy. Seeing a civilian-tourist go to the ISS is a big step forward for humankind. If the Americans are not in favour I think the Russians should encourage it. I am so pleased this is happening and I would travel to space if I could afford it.
John Ngassa, Britain

They would have to pay ME to set foot in a space ship. And they would then have to drag me screaming and kicking into the wretched thing. Love Star Wars, love Star Trek: don't need or desire the real experience.
Jane Green, English in Italy

I found NASA objections to Dennis Tito's trip a bit ironical. Christa McAuliffe who was a school teacher with a degree in history, was selected by NASA for the ill-fated Challenger trip in 1986. Surely Dennis Tito with his background as rocket scientist who has in fact worked for NASA is no less qualified for the trip.
Surodeep Roy, India

Money makes the world and the universe go around apparently
Arthur, New Zealand


A new frontier will be opened up

Ed Butcher, Wales
The reason that manned space exploration has stagnated in recent years is the lack of a cheap, reliable, and reusable launcher. The Americans don't seem to be seriously interested in the project, and the Russians can't afford that kind of investment. I think that the promise of the huge profits possible from space tourism could be the one thing to generate the necessary investment. Once cheaper ways to get cargo and crews into orbit are available, a new frontier will be opened up, that in my opinion will have huge potential benefits to mankind.
Ed Butcher, Wales

Tourism is the biggest industry on the planet, why shouldn't it be the biggest one off it?
Mo Ahad, UK

I'd love the chance to go into space and I expect that in the years to come it will become more popular and affordable. In a way it's a bit like any new opportunity; initially for the filthy rich then gradually becoming more accessible. I just hope it happens soon.
Shargil, UK

I think it will pay off for Tito. Not only does he get a great experience but when he gets back he will be a minor celebrity. By writing a book, doing media interviews and speeches he should be able to recoup a reasonable amount of his outlay. As for me, I've offered the wife a place on the Mars mission!
Charles, UK


I'm sure the appeal of space tourism has significantly decreased since astronauts from the MIR space station reported that they spent months in a hot, humid atmosphere that smelt of fungus and dirty socks

Alice, Australia
Will tourists be taking their litter home with them or will space agencies be providing waste bins?
Jonathan Farber, UK

I'm sure the appeal of space tourism has significantly decreased since astronauts from the MIR space station reported that they spent months in a hot, humid atmosphere that smelt of fungus and dirty socks.
Alice, Australia

Where can I sign up?......
Tony Pigram, UK

Tito's trip will be seen as a watershed in opening up space flight to the masses. I find significant irony in his trip, as this huge first step in commercial space tourism was brought to us by a country without a strong history of free enterprise. Russia has added another first to add to its list of impressive space accomplishments. One has to applaud their pragmatism and vision. A successful mission will not only have other tourists lining up at their door step, but will provide a significant positive boost for both their commercial launches and their international credibility. The US missed a huge opportunity here, I believe thanks in part are due to our increasingly litigious and therefore risk-averse culture
J E Douglas, USA

Up until now commercial activity in space has largely been confined to launching satellites. Space tourism further extends the scope of human endeavour beyond our world, and provided that it's carried out with proper regard for safety I think it can only be a good thing.
Bob Mottram, UK

I wouldn't mind a go at it as soon as they sort out how to make space commodes work.
Walt O'Brien, USA

Of course I'd go. After decades of waiting for mankind to get back to the Moon, explore Mars etc, it has become increasingly obvious that there is a major problem with the way 'space exploration' is being run. Governments have neither the politcal will nor the money - let alone the vision - to get the job done. They think in 4-5 year time frames and put re-election before the greater good.

I say let's open the programmes up to private industry and a first step towards that has got to be demonstrating profitability whether it comes from asteroid mining or tourism who cares. Good luck Tito, you've taken a step forward for us all.
Tony Swiecicki, Indonesia


Tito had a dream, and he made it come true. I admire that

Zoltan Bartalis, Canada/Sweden
Let's not forget Mr Tito is a former rocket scientist, received extensive training by the Russians and gives a helping hand during the Soyuz mission - so his flight is not completely a passive joyride. He had a dream, and he made it come true. I admire that. For being able to say that I actively participated in the building of the International Space Station as an astronaut, I would pay that kind of money.
Zoltan Bartalis, Canada/Sweden

I think rich people paying to get into space is a great thing. Investors who fund (or would fund) space tourism ventures will see there really are people willing to shell out the loot to get there, and hopefully a real space tourism industry could happen.

For man, who is always destined to experience wonderful things, space is simply a dreaming destination. By his nature, he should be fascinated by the thought of soaring in space. But as it is a very expensive journey, one has to be either a Gagarin or a Tito to secure that privilege. For one should be a space scientist or a millionaire to smell any chance of it. An ordinary tourist of this era can imagine being there only if scientists can discover a cheap blasting machine, a sort of a flying saucer.
Rajan Kafle, Nepal

Space is the final frontier and who would not want to play Star Trek? There is bad news, however, as it promises to be the most unearthly experience at the same time it is also the most expensive.

I think space tourism should be discouraged and instead, tourism of third world countries should be encouraged who are desperate for every bit of cash that may come their way.
Osman Aftab, Pakistan

As for the common people, I don't expect any reasonable price (if you consider $100,000 reasonable) to be attainable in any less than 20 years. As for me, I know I can wait 20 years...
BD, USA


Why not part mega-rich people from their money and make this industry blossom for the benefit of the whole mankind??

PL, Finland
Nasa is chronically cash-strapped, Russian space exploration is on a shoestring budget, the whole concept of exploring space is almost at a standstill due to lack of funding. So why not part mega-rich people from their money and make this industry blossom for the benefit of the whole mankind??
PL, Finland

I agree that space-tourism is a matter of time. But we can't refuse now. Tito's money is vitally important for Russian space projects. Everybody knows that our science of space stations is the best, but we have no money to develop. If we get the money we need, we'll help our planet and international flights.
Dmitry, Russia

I wouldn't want limited space-related resources going to give the rich and famous an ego-trip around the world. Until we can fly a shuttle to the Moon or Mars and have the dome space to open up a Hilton, let's keep space science and exploration based. And if a rich person still wants to go? Than send your CV to Nasa.
Stephen Kenney, USA

Of course space travel will catch on! I am not particularly interested, but there are many people who have been obsessed with space from an early age. As soon as it is affordable and perhaps even before it is really safe, there will be thousands queuing up to see space close up.
Emma T, Australia

If Tito can afford to subsidise the Russians then let him. People who spend money drive economies, people who hoard their cash just slow down progress.
R Myers, Australia


Does anyone really believe this is a bad thing?

Dave Thomas, UK
Yes. We must expand our horizons and Mr Tito's example should be one to follow, He has fulfilled his dream whilst assisting the Russians with their commitment to the ISS. Does anyone really believe this is a bad thing?
Dave Thomas, UK

This is one of the ways to raise money to increase space research and exploration. It is becoming more and more expensive to continue space exploration. In the beginning only Russia and US could do it, now in the case of the Space Station there are many countries involved.

Many very rich people are capable of paying such a high price and we should take this opportunity.
G Fazal, Canada

As an environmentalist AND an adventurer I am torn between the arguments for and against space tourism. I would definitely jump at the opportunity for space travel if I had it, but would hope that efficient technology is soon developed which alleviates the pollution and wastage produced by current launches. The theory is here now and will only be put into practice once mass-production brings down the costs. I'm eager and waiting!
Martin Mitchell, Australia

We have scarred this earth... now let us mess with space (we have, already)!! If I had the money, I would invest in salvaging what is left of our planet earth!
Bharath, India/USA


I think we should face it, it's a complete gimmick. What is there to see, apart from the Moon and Earth?

Ed Alexander, England
Mr Tito has obviously managed to make his own dreams come true. But I think we should face it, it's a complete gimmick. What is there to see, apart from the Moon and Earth? Two weeks stuck on a cruise liner in the Pacific would drive me insane, let alone a fortnight staring at blackness.

In the future, space travel will be something that people will do once, and once only. It will not be the near future either, because I don't think that most people can afford $20m. I believe that we should spend more time and money on researching how to exploit the natural resources of other planets.
Ed Alexander, England

Commercial space flight is dogged with a terrible safety record. Who would want to fly by aeroplane if 1 in 10 flights crashed? Or 1 in 100? Tito knows the risks and was prepared to take them for the novelty of it. I'll wait a few decades for the technology to prove itself before I buy my ticket...
Simon, USA

I can't see space tourism as a problem if it is properly dealt with. As in these (still) early stages of manned spaceflights, when one cannot blame space tourism being mass tourism, benefits are certainly worth the possible risks. During this short space-age history, I don't remember any organisation ever complaining about new possibilities to get more funds in the space programme, whether national or international.

And when tourists are well trained and prepared for the space flight, I believe they won't harm the scientific work done at the ISS. In fact, has anyone thought about having a scientific study on space tourism? Now there's a concept to study further.
Petteri Pyrro, Finland

I think the biggest mistake we make is in thinking that space tourism is somehow "good" for the human race. Space tourism means space colonisation, by autocratic kingdoms (companies).

There's staggering poverty, desolation, and aggression in the world already to deal with, why are we so excited about jumping out of our world? The metaphor of staring at the stars while living in the gutter comes to mind. Worst, we're not even concerned about cleaning the gutter.
Faris Kasim, Pakistan/USA

If it took every penny I made in my life to go into space, I wouldn't even hesitate. This isn't some great moralistic crusade that some in the forum would make it out to be. This is about going 5000 mph, and seeing the Earth and the heavens like few others ever get the chance to. Bon voyage Dennis Tito.
Chris McCoy, USA


That an American had to go to Russia with his millions to fulfil a capitalists' dream is a remarkable twist! Bravo!

Phil Harrison, Canada
Of course it will catch on. In 10 or 20 years it will be commonplace. What is really significant is that a former communist government has made a truly capitalist decision and created the first independent commercial human transaction in space. That an American had to go to Russia with his millions to fulfil a capitalists' dream is a remarkable twist! Bravo!
Phil Harrison, Canada

I like many others here think that space tourism is inevitable. But we are long way off even the $100,000 ticket type of package. There is still much to be done to make even low Earth orbit (LEO) tourism feasible. We need massive investment in LEO infrastructure with permanently manned space stations on a far grander scale than the present ISS.

It is however the right way to go. It would enable the development of spacecraft designed to be launched from such stations instead of being ground launched. They would be a more practicable solution for large man-rated payloads destined for deeper space. The Moon initially (this time to stay) and then to Mars and so on. All this will eventually include tourism but that is not the most important aspect of it.
Philip S Hall, UK

If I had the money I would love to go into space. I would think it a privilege to see the Earth from above. See other planets would be my idea of heaven. The techology of space travel is here and I belive we should (if we want) have access to the heavens.
Janet Roberts, England

It will only be a matter of time before this trend catches on. There is no denying that once Tito has set a precedent, others will want to follow suit. I would say given 50 years, space tourism will be as commonplace as another other forms of travelling. In fact, on reflecting, I would say this is just part and parcel of the advancement of the human civilisation. As such, I feel this event is worth commemorating.
Grace Ho How Lian, Bedok, Singapore

What's the alternative to letting people go into space? Do we really want some "anti-space police force" forcing people to stay on Earth. If we stay on Earth, we will run out of resources. If space tourism can advance the day when we can pull down resources from the moon and asteroids, let's welcome it. Earth is a cradle, not a prison!
Kevin Elliott, UK

It's all fun and games until somebody gets "space rage" and assaults the cabin crew. Where will you put down? Asteroid 2099B?
Simon Keiler, UK

I think that space should be reserved for the elite astronaut corp. You can't have tourists bumbling around on the ISS, wrecking good space science.
Paul Tisdale, UK

Currently, I don't think space tourism is a good idea. All Tito did was take advantage of the cash-strapped Russian Space Agency. But if they want to send him up there, and if they can do it, so be it. We can't stop him unless we point out to the Russians that in fact WE paid for THEIR part of the International Space Station, but we understandably don't want to cause a rift. Someday it will probably be somewhat affordable to travel to space, but for me, I haven't yet visited all the countries I would lke to.
Ryan Corcoran, Austin, TX, USA


May there be more extremely rich people putting money into space travel

Antony Shepherd, UK
If I had the money, I'd be there like a shot. Even if I spent the whole time feeling sick, it would still be the experience of a lifetime. Good luck and bon voyage to Dennis Tito, I say. May there be more extremely rich people putting money into space travel.
Antony Shepherd, UK

While I have to admit that going into space would be absolutely thrilling, I also feel that it is disgusting that people will spend any amount of money for a thrill, yet ignore the needs of their brothers. If the rich would only realize how thrilling it would be to take $20m dollars and do something about the children in an impoverished country who dig in piles of stinking garbage every day for something to eat. The smiles on the faces of the children would be worth far more than a few days in space. There would be no such horrible suffering on our beautiful planet if we would all just readjust what we consider valuable.
Jim V, USA

To be given the opportunity to go into space, albeit by having to fund it oneself, would be the ultimate 21st century thrill, giving one the same sense of feeling as the early pioneers must have felt in previous days whether it be in space or on land/sea.

Just imagine the feeling of exhileration of take-off, weightlessness, actually being there in space and the thrill of re-entry. One would certainly have been to the very extent of mankind's achievements and to the forefront of his potential destiny. Yes, I would definately go!!
Ian Davison, England

I would love to go into space, but I can't see how the pollution could be justified. If it's a regular thing - a true tourist destination, then the amount of fuel burned and pollutants released would just serve to increase the rate at which this beautiful blue jewel is destroyed.

If it served to educate the rich and powerful and moved them to stop polluting it, perhaps a limited environmental price would be acceptable in the short term.
Alistair M-S, UK

Ever more expensive and rare thrills to destroy the planet. Such tourists should pay in addition the same money again to the UN or some other competent international body for the alleviation of the misery caused by world pollution and global warming - on the basis the polluter should pay. Better still stay at home and learn to appreciate the miracle of our beautiful but fragile planet.
Will Lever, UK

Well, Mr Tito has bought his way into the history books, that's for sure! I can't see paying $100k just for "the view", though... as staggering as I'm sure it must be, I think I'd want a little bit more for my money.
Mark M Newdick, USA/UK

What about pollution? It may be nice to see the earth from space but it is extremely polluting. I have nothing against it as long as it is along with another space mission, but tourism just for tourism would be a scandal.
Gergey Pasztor, Germany


I don't think we will see major steps into space for all of the populace on earth for another good 30 years or so

Stuart Bell, Scotland
I think the issue of humans in space is a greater issue rather than space tourism. I personally don't agree with Tito going into space at this point as the current level of exploration into space by man is not yet up to a frequent tourism trade. As well as that, it seems that space tourism will just be for the rich and powerful for the moment. I don't think we will see major steps into space for all of the populace on earth for another good 30 years or so.
Stuart Bell, Scotland, UK

This is just the beginning of course. Surely we will see more and more people paying large sums to get this unforgettable space experience in few years time. Certainly I would like to take off to space if the price for it comes down to six figures.
Yoga, UK

Let's face it: it's the ultimate tourist trip to the ultimate destination. How can it not catch on? But in a world as chaotically disordered as ours, isn't it just so much ostentatious escapism? Let's get our house in order and then fulfil our fantasies.
Simon Cameron, UK


If space tourism becomes an affordable reality in my lifetime I know that I will sign up for it!

Tim Jones, UK
Surely it is the dream of most people to discover and experience something beyond this planet be that through religion or by travelling into space. I would jump at the chance to travel into orbit or perhaps even further, if it happens it will be popular as it will help people to see that this really is our 'Island Earth' part of a infinite universe. This however could be demoralising as we may realise we are a very small part of a great big universe. If space tourism becomes an affordable reality in my lifetime I know that I will sign up for it!
Tim Jones, UK

I would love to go into space, but I don't think I would be prepared to pay anywhere near 100,000 for it. And I defintely would not if that was only for a cramped space with 499 other people. Some big business should get it together and build a resort either a space station or a base on the moon. Now I might pay 100,000 for a week or two on the moon.

PS: When exactly is someone going to bother going back to the moon, it's the logical place to practice all our deep space exploration ideas and Mars landing schemes.
SD, England

No, who wants to spend 20 million bucks to sit on a big firework when you can spend fifty quid and go to Blackpool and ride the big dipper? Hmmm it may at that.
Phil Davies, UK

Yes, yes, and yes again. It would be the ultimate trip of our lifetime. But what would you do for kicks when you got back?
Nathan Hughes, England

People are worried about flying over 55,000m in the earth's atmosphere. How would they react to flying in outer space!
Maria Brown, England

If it does catch on, I hope it becomes affordable for at least some sizable percentage of the population by the time we begin to colonize, if that happens.

What better way to finally separate the rich from the poor (once again) than to allow wealthy industrialists to leave the Earth they've so gleefully polluted while the working classes have to stay on the "home planet" and deal with stinking air and poisoned water?

Looking more short term... It may be a good thing. Perhaps this sort of thing will help to fund space research, allowing governments to shift the funds to hungry poor folk everywhere.
A Hsiao, USA

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
BBC RADIO NEWS
BBC ONE TV NEWS
WORLD NEWS SUMMARY
PROGRAMMES GUIDE
See also:

28 Apr 01 | Sci/Tech
Space tourist blasts off
27 Apr 01 | Sci/Tech
Profile: Tito the spaceman
Internet links:


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


Links to more Talking Point stories