Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education

Front Page



UK Politics







Talking Point

In Depth

On Air

Low Graphics

Friday, October 29, 1999 Published at 16:58 GMT 17:58 UK

French flair meets All Black might

Reaching new heights: France hope to create a major upset

Even the most ardent optimist would find it hard to back France when they take on World Cup favourites New Zealand in their semi-final at Twickenham on Sunday.

The All Blacks have looked unstoppable in most phases of play and at every stage of the tournament, while the French have looked disorganised and out-of-sorts against the weakest of opponents.

The two teams' journey to the semi-finals could hardly have been more different.

Short work

The All Blacks are the reigning Tri-Nations champions - a record 28-7 loss to Australia notwithstanding - and progressed through the group stages of the World Cup undefeated, recording hard-fought victories over England and Tonga before handing a 101-3 pasting to Italy.

[ image: Philippe Bernat-Salles: Mission impossible]
Philippe Bernat-Salles: Mission impossible
They also made short work of a typically pugnacious Scotland in the quarter-finals last weekend, cruising past the Five Nations champions despite the overwhelming atmosphere of Murrayfield and the best attentions of the elements.

By contrast, France took the Five Nations wooden spoon before slumping to a summer friendly defeat to tiny Tonga.

Fortunately for the French, they enjoyed probably the easiest route to the semi-finals in World Cup history, but they made even that look difficult.

In the group stage they scraped past Canada and Fiji and were hardly convincing against the minnows of Namibia. Their last-eight match confrontation with surprise quarter-finalists Argentina was an end-to-end thriller that owed much to the Gallic disregard for defence in favour of all-out attack.

The Lomu problem

Defence is one element they cannot neglect when they take on the frighteningly potent attacking force of the All Black back line. The skills of Jeff Wilson, Christian Cullen, Tana Umaga and, of course, Jonah Lomu can prize apart even the staunchest lines - and nobody would accuse the French of being staunch.

[ image: Jonah Lomu can prize apart any defence]
Jonah Lomu can prize apart any defence
Marking Lomu is the comparatively diminutive Philippe Bernat-Salles, who explained his philosophy for taking on the big man: "I'll just have to jump on him and call my mates to the rescue because one man is not usually enough to bring him down."

And it is not as if they can take solace in the possible absence of star New Zealand fly-half Andrew Mehrtens. Even if he fails to recover from a bruised knee in time for the match, his understudy Tony Brown would make it into most international line-ups as an automatic first choice.

Ominously, the All Blacks have made an unforced change, dropping scrum-half Justin Marshall for attacking reserve Byron Kelleher, suggesting they intend to run at the French.

Coach John Hart confirmed that Kelleher's selection was a tactical choice.

"He was the best option for this particular game," he said.

The last time the two sides met, New Zealand piled 54 points on France, although both sides will know that there is a massive difference between a friendly and a World Cup semi-final.

Size and technique

France manager Jo Maso said: "We have started a new adventure with this World Cup and what happened before does not count.

[ image: Strike force: Tana Umaga in training]
Strike force: Tana Umaga in training
"If we did not have a belief that we can beat them, there would be no point in even going out there to play the match."

Similarly, Hart said: "I expect the French to be hugely fired up for this game. I think they will come out and throw everything at us.

"They have got the size and the technique. It's going to be an interesting day at the office."

France are the only northern hemisphere side still in the World Cup. They are also the only team from north of the equator to have won a series against New Zealand and if they fire on the day, they could cause the All Blacks all sorts of problems.


New Zealand:15 Jeff Wilson; 14 Tana Umaga, 13 Christian Cullen, 12 Alama Ieremia, 11 Jonah Lomu; 10 Andrew Mehrtens or Tony Brown, 9 Byron Kelleher; 8 Taine Randell (captain), 7 Josh Kronfeld, 6 Reuben Thorne, 5 Robin Brooke, 4 Norm Maxwell, 3 Craig Dowd, 2 Anton Oliver, 1 Carl Hoeft.
Replacements: 16 Daryl Gibson, 17 Tony Brown or Bruce Reihana, 18 Justin Marshall, 19 Andrew Blowers, 20 Royce Willis, 21 Kees Meeuws, 22 Mark Hammett.

France: 15 Xavier Garbajosa; 14 Philippe Bernat-Salles, 13 Richard Dourthe, 12 Emile Ntamack, 11 Christophe Dominici; 10 Christophe Lamaison, 9 Fabien Galthie; 8 Christophe Juillet, 7 Olivier Magne, 6 Marc Lievremont, 5 Fabien Pelous, 4 Abdel Benazzi, 3 Franck Tournaire, 2 Raphael Ibanez (captain), 1 Cedric Soulette.
Replacements: 16 Ugo Mola, 17 Stephane Glas, 18 Stephane Castaignede, 19 Arnaud Costes, 20 Olivier Brozet, 21 Pieter de Villiers, 22 Marc de Maso.

Referee: Jim Fleming (Scotland).

Advanced options | Search tips

Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©

Rugby World Cup 1999
 -  Schedule & Results
 -  League Tables
 -  Grounds

Relevant Stories

29 Oct 99 | Rugby World Cup
Rugby World Cup web links

28 Oct 99 | New Zealand
Marshall axed by All Blacks

28 Oct 99 | France
Ntamack fit for All Black clash

24 Oct 99 | France
Pumas destroyed by late French surge

27 Oct 99 | France
Marconnet joins French squad

27 Oct 99 | New Zealand
Lomu battle hots up

24 Oct 99 | Scotland
All Blacks end it for gutsy Scots