Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: In Depth: 99: World Club Championship
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Alan Green
"I'd say you couldn't make it up, except of course this involved Manchester United"
 real 28k

Thursday, 6 January, 2000, 22:46 GMT
Beckham off in Man Utd epic

Beckham's foot was high and a long way from the ball

Man Utd 1-1 Necaxa

Manchester United showed all their famous diehard spirit as they fought back from losing David Beckham in a controversial dismissal to snatch a draw with Mexican side Necaxa in their World Club Championship opener.

World Club Championship
The England midfielder received the red card in the 43rd minute for a high challenge on Jose Milian, reviving doubts over his unpredictable temperament.

United were already trailing 1-0, after a Cristian Montecinos free kick had put the Mexicans ahead in the 15th minute.

The sending off, not one but two saved penalties, and a late equaliser from United were all packed into an astonishing 90 minutes.

Referee Horacio Marcelo Elizondo had no hesitation
The British side battled their way back into the game despite being a man down to keep their tournament hopes alive.

Ecuador international Alex Aguinaga and Dwight Yorke both had penalties saved before the United striker grabbed a deserved equaliser ten minutes from time.

It is difficult to imagine a more controversial or action-filled match.

Manager Sir Alex Ferguson spent the build up to this tournament fielding questions about the organisation and value of the World Club Championships.

Goalscorer Yorke with Octavio Beccaril
And though Ferguson will not have enjoyed his side's controversial debut in the tournament, the match sparked what had until now been a lacklustre event, into life.

The game started slowly - instead of showing the tiny Rio crowd their treble-winning class, Ferguson's men appeared nervous and disjointed.

While United appeared to be waiting for the sun to sink out of sight and cool the 90 degree heat before hitting their full stride, Necaxa came haring out of the blocks.

Match facts
15 mins: Montecinos curls in a free-kick to give Necaxa an early lead
42 mins: Beckham is dismissed for violent conduct
56 mins: Bosnich saves Aguinaga's spot-kick
78 mins: Pineda saves Yorke's spot-kick
82 mins: A Solskjaer mis-kick allows Yorke to grab the equaliser
Jaap Stam, normally such a rock in defence was a particularly slow starter and it was a mistake by him in the 15th minute which allowed Necaxa to take a shock early lead.

Midfield playmaker Alex Aguinaga won a free-kick on the edge of the box and from the resulting set-play, Cristian Montecinos stepped out of a gang of three to curl a left-footed shot past the rooted Mark Bosnich.

The goal rocked the English side and, as the shadows finally engulfed the pitch at the Maracana Stadium, they finally injected the missing urgency into their game.

The 8,000 crowd did not know it then but that was to be merely the first surprise turn in a rollercoaster ride of a match.

Montecinos (left) celebrates Necaxa's goal
With the clock showing three minutes before the interval, the game sparked into life in the most ugly fashion.

Beckham, who along with most of the United players had been booed by the largely Brazilian crowd, raised his studs in a waist high challenge on Jose Milian.

The Necaxa players were incensed by the tackle - and the apparent bad-tempered follow-through - and Argentinian referee Horacio Elizondo waited only to consult briefly with his assistant before showing Beckham the red card.

The dismissal revived the doubts raised over Beckham's temper when he was sent off when playing for England in the 1998 World Cup - and once again left his team-mates a man short.

United had struggled to create more than a fleeting chance - squandered by Dwight Yorke - in the first-half and were now facing a huge uphill task in the final 45 minutes.

From the restart, Nexaca surged forward.

Beckham had been trying to raise his team-mates
In the space of three minutes they created havoc in the European champions' box.

And just when skipper Roy Keane appeared to have steadied his side, French defender Silvestre gave Necaxa the chance to inflict the killer blow.

His slip allowed Montecinos a clear run on goal and though he recovered his ground to make a challenge, referee Elizondo once again penalised Man United and awarded a 56th minute penalty.

Aguinaga could have put the game beyond the European champions reach but Bosnich produced a flying save to keep his side's hopes alive.

Further controversy was to follow as Ferguson was apparently ordered from the touchline by the Kuwaiti fourth official.

Keane was one of three United players to be booked
With 20 minutes to go, a defiant Ferguson who had remained in the dugout, made the decisive changes.

He threw three men up front - replacing Andy Cole and Denis Irwin with European Cup heroes Ole Gunnar Solskjaer and Teddy Sheringham - and swapped the hardworking Nicky Butt for Phil Neville.

Sheringham curled a close-range shot just high on 77 minutes and Yorke missed a glorious chance when his nondescript penalty, awarded for a clear handball, was saved by 38-year-old Pineda.

But just as he did in Barcelona. Solskjaer proved his side's saviour - his 82nd minute mis-hit shot providing Yorke with a perfectly weighted cross which he side-footed home from inside six yards.

But the heat and the numerical disadvantage had taken their toll and a last-minute winner for once proved beyond Ferguson's men.


Man Utd: Bosnich, G. Neville, Irwin, Silvestre, Stam, Butt, Keane, Beckham, Giggs, Cole, Yorke.
Subs: Rachubka, Van Der Gouw, Higginbottom, Sheringham, P. Neville, Cruyff, Greening, Wilson, Solskjaer, Wallwork, Berg, Fortune.

Necaxa: Pineda, Cabrera, Almaguer, Aguinaga, Perez, Delgado, Lopez, Vigna, Milian, Montecinos, Higareda.
Subs: Alvarez, Guadarrama, Ambriz, Scotti, Acosta, Terres, Ochoa, Velazquez, Becerril, Hernandez, Oliva, Vazquez.
Referee: Horacio Marcelo Elizondo (Argentina)

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
World Club Championship Contents

See also:
06 Jan 00 |  World Club Championship
Ferguson defends Beckham
07 Jan 00 |  Football
Man Utd's flawed genius?
07 Jan 00 |  Sport
Picture gallery: Man Utd misery turns to relief
07 Jan 00 |  World Club Championship
Vasco take control of group
24 Dec 99 |  World Club Championship
Brazil 2000: Football's new century begins
06 Jan 00 |  Football
Man Utd look to turn up the heat
06 Jan 00 |  Manchester United
Ferguson losing patience with UK press
05 Jan 00 |  World Club Championship
Anelka finally opens account
06 Jan 00 |  World Club Championship
Corinthians benefit from controversy
20 Dec 99 |  World Club Championship
Man Utd: Bidding for unification
20 Dec 99 |  World Club Championship
Necaxa: Kings of a small hill
Links to other World Club Championship stories are at the foot of the page.

Links to more World Club Championship stories