Page last updated at 23:16 GMT, Tuesday, 2 June 2009 00:16 UK

Long war against Pakistan Taliban

By Syed Shoaib Hasan
BBC News, Islamabad

Taleban members in north-western Pakistan
The Taliban have proved themselves to be formidable adversaries

Pakistan's security forces appear to have achieved their main objective in Swat with the capture of its administrative seat of Mingora.

That region and the rest of the Malakand division now seem to be under the control of the Pakistan army.

Some fighting is still going on in the mountainous rural areas - especially the Peochar valley, the militants' main stronghold.

Everyone on the list of most wanted militants - from Osama Bin Laden onwards - is said to be hiding in that area.

Dissent and duplicity

Swat's turn in the limelight may be entering its final phase, in fact some senior government officials believe it is already over.

The army now seems to be preparing itself for a new front as clashes erupt across the tribal region of Waziristan.

Baitullah Mehsud, supreme leader of the militant alliance Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), now awaits them.

Baitullah Mehsud

As a prelude to that operation, Pakistan's intelligence agencies have been whittling away at his influence.

Increasingly he is faced with dissent and duplicity in his South Waziristan base.

A rival clan led by powerful pro-government leader, Turkistan Bittani, has been making in-roads at his expense.

He is aided by Qari Zainuddin Mehsud, leader of the Abdullah Mehsud group in Waziristan.

Until his death, Abdullah Mehsud was, along with Baitullah, the main Taliban commander among the Mehsud tribe.

Some argue he had an even higher profile and stronger relationship with al-Qaeda than his namesake and that he posed a greater threat.

Abdullah Mehsud was killed in Baluchistan's Zhob district in July 2007 following a fire fight with security forces.

Greater authority

Later, reports surfaced that information about his whereabouts had been leaked on Baitullah's orders.

Pakistani soldiers
The army says that the Taliban are losing territory

The two men were known to have developed serious differences - especially concerning Baitullah's focus on Pakistan.

Now Abdullah's cousin, Qari Zain, has clearly said the TTP head's activities are un-Islamic and that he must be removed.

In addition, Baitullah Mehsud's ersthwhile allies, Maulvi Nazir and Hafiz Gul Bahadur, appear intent on sitting the latest fighting out on the sidelines.

They are the only two Pakistan Taliban commanders of similar if not greater authority and could have been powerful allies.

So Baitullah Mehsud now appears not only surrounded by the army but also running out of allies.

The question then is what will happen to the Taliban in Pakistan if he is no longer in charge?

Many people believe the TTP may fracture and the organisation could end up being destroyed.

But there are other militant leaders such as Zulfiqar Mehsud - also known as Hakimullah Mehsud - waiting in the wings.

Zulfiqar Mehsud last week told the BBC that two separate attacks in Lahore which killed 10 people were carried out by the Taliban in response to the army's operation in the Swat valley. He is also thought to be behind recent attacks on supply convoys bound for Nato forces in Afghanistan.

Recurring pattern

As far as the Pakistani Taliban's future is concerned in the event of Baitullah Mehsud's demise, past events provide an interesting barometer reading of what may lie ahead.

Displaced people in north-west Pakistan
More displacement could drive some people into the Taliban's arms

One has only to look at what has happened recently in the tribal areas when a senior militant leader was killed or when the militants were said to have been defeated.

The most famous example is of Nek Mohammad.

He was the man who launched the Taliban movement as a Pakistani phenomenon.

Starting out with a group of about 20 like-minded men in Waziristan in 2003, Nek Mohammad soon became the main front man for al-Qaeda's militants.

During this time he fought several battles with the Pakistan army before eventually signing a peace deal with them.

But that was not to last and soon the army and militants were at war once again.

His death in a drone attack in July 2004 was hailed as a "great victory" by the army who claimed to have "broken the back of the militants".

At that time he was estimated to have had about 5,000 followers.

Today, there are more than a dozen militant leaders who command at least that number of men and a few who have several times more.

The militants control territory throughout North West Frontier Province and every operation by the army has ultimately ended with them losing territory.

In fact, there is a recurring pattern to the army's offensives.

Troops nearly always tend to be deployed following international claims that the area in question is newly under al-Qaeda's control and poses a threat to the country's nuclear arsenal.

The fighting often ends up leaving a largely aggravated population at the mercy of those from whom they were being rescued.

This in turn can create resentment against the government - if only a handful out of the 2.5 million people forced to leave Swat in the most recent fighting end up joining the Taliban, the militants would still receive hundreds of new recruits into their ranks.

For many people in the war-hit north-west there is increasingly only one choice, join the Taliban or leave their ancestral lands.


That is maybe one reason why almost every family in Taliban-dominated areas has a member in the militant forces.

 A house destroyed by fighting in Mingora
Fighting between the army and the Taliban has caused destruction in Swat

The young glamourise the militants and that - combined with the tribal concept of badal, or an eye for an eye - becomes binding on each family who loses a member in the war.

Every time the army drops a bomb or fires a bullet in the north-west it is in danger of stirring up resentment among some civilians which will create new enemies in future years.

The militants in Swat may well lose the battle over the coming days and the future of Baitullah Mehsud appears increasingly uncertain.

But unless the Pakistani government - and indirectly the international community - changes its tactics, the Taliban can still win the war.


Print Sponsor

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific