Page last updated at 04:48 GMT, Monday, 13 October 2008 05:48 UK

Predators could be superweed fix

By Rebecca Morelle
Science reporter, BBC News


This timelapse footage shows Japanese knotweed growing more than 1m-tall (3ft) in just four weeks

A superweed spreading throughout the UK could be brought under control by introducing plant-eating predators from Japan, scientists believe.

Japanese knotweed was first introduced as an ornamental plant, but has since plagued the environment; removal is costly and time consuming.

Now a team has identified natural predators from its native home that could also control it in the UK.

The plans have been submitted to the government for approval.

If the proposal gets the go-ahead, it will be the first time that biocontrol - the use of a natural enemy to control another pest - will be used in Europe to fight a weed.

All this week, BBC News will be taking a closer look at some of the alien invaders that are in the UK.

Appetite for knotweed

This year has been particularly bad for knotweed spread in the UK.

Aphalara itadori (Dick Shaw)
The nymphs are literally sucking the life out of the plant.
Dr Shaw, Cabi

James MacFarlane, vegetation adviser for Cornwall County Council, said: "The weather patterns have ended up with us seeing a lot of knotweed spread in a number of areas."

In Japan, the original home of knotweed, the plant is common but it does not rage out of control like in the UK.

Dick Shaw, the lead researcher on the project, from Cabi, a not-for-profit agricultural research organisation, said: "In 2000, we went out to Japan to see whether the plant had any natural enemies that it had lost when it came here.

"We found that it had a lot: there were 186 species of plant-eating insects and about 40 species of fungi."

The team then began to test the predators to find those that only had an appetite for Japanese knotweed - and not any other plants.

The researchers tempted them with plant species that were very closely related to knotweed, less closely related species that belonged to the same tribe or family, and important UK plants such as apples and wheat.

Leaf spot fungus on knotweed
A leaf sport fungus only has an appetite for knotweed

Those that attacked any plants other than Japanese knotweed were ruled out, explained Dr Shaw.

Eventually, the list was whittled down to two: a sap-sucking psyllid insect (Aphalara itadori) and a leaf spot fungus from the genus Mycosphaerella.

Dr Shaw told the BBC: "We have done some efficacy trials here in the lab and they are showing a significant impact."


Dick Shaw shows the effects of the sap-sucking psyllid on Japanese knotweed.

Successful biocontrols do not eradicate the target weed - this would mean wiping out their only food source and effectively making themselves extinct - but they do bring them under control.

Dr Shaw said: "The psyllids are having an effect on the plants' height and the treated knotweeds produce tiny curled leaves rather than big light absorbing leaves, which means that less resources will get to their root system.

"The nymphs are literally sucking the life out of the plant," he added.

Phenomenal growth

Japanese knotweed, like many other non-native, invasive plants, was first introduced to the UK for horticulture.


Its 3-4m-tall (10-13ft) stems, ornamental leaves and clusters of white flowers made it an attractive option for gardens.

Simon Ford, a nature conservation adviser from the National Trust, said: "Japanese knotweed first came into the UK in 1840 through Wales - but it was only about 10 to 15 years later that people started to see it as a threat."

The plants grow incredibly quickly - some have been shown to grow four metres in just four months, they can spread at a tremendous rate, and they can quickly obliterate any other vegetation growing nearby.

Mr Ford said: "By the time they realised this it was already far too late."

Today, Japanese knotweed is prevalent throughout the UK.

It has not only caused great damage to plant biodiversity but it is also causing problems for hard structures, including buildings, paving stones and flood defence structures.

Garden schematic

It has been estimated that to remove all knotweed from the UK would cost several billion pounds.

Cabi scientists believe that natural control could offer a much simpler solution.

The project has cost about £600,000 over five years.

Dr Shaw said: "In comparison to the current control methods, if it works, this will be significantly less costly."

The team has submitted its proposals to the government.

The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) along with independent peer reviewers will assess the work before it is submitted for a public consultation.

What is more alarming is the idea of introducing an insect into the wild to eat the J.K. Weed
James Paul, United Kingdom

Dr Shaw said: "We do not know if this is going to be the silver bullet for knotweed, but if we were able to just stop the thing spreading at the rate it currently is, or make it easier to kill, I will be very happy."

The research project has been paid for by a consortium of UK sponsors including Defra, the Environment Agency, the Welsh Assembly Government, Network Rail, South West Regional Development Agency and British Waterways, coordinated by Cornwall County Council.

Print Sponsor

Volunteers gather to fight weeds
26 Jul 08 |  Bristol
Knotweed 'choking' island rivers
14 Mar 08 |  Isle of Man
Warning issued over harmful weeds
11 Jun 07 |  Tayside and Central
River fights off 'alien invaders'
05 Nov 07 |  South of Scotland

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Sign in

BBC navigation

Copyright © 2019 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific