[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Wednesday, 4 October 2006, 12:12 GMT 13:12 UK
Poor air degrades church artwork
By Kate Ravilious

Swinging incense (AFP)

Lighting a candle in church may bring you inner peace, but it does not do the paintings much good.

New research shows churchgoers can also damage valuable church artworks by burning incense, polishing the brass and even just breathing.

Frescos, icons, textiles, books and silver are being seriously degraded by poor environmental conditions inside churches according to the study.

It was done by a team from Democritus University of Thrace in Xanthi, Greece.

Rea Loupa and her colleagues monitored air quality in two churches in Cyprus.

Over one summer and one winter season, they recorded variables such as temperature, humidity, light and particulate levels, along with carbon dioxide, ozone and nitrogen dioxide levels.

In addition, they kept a detailed diary at each church, recording all the comings and goings.

Candles and cars

Weather conditions had a strong impact on indoor pollution, but surprisingly church visitors also played a significant role.

In the UK, bat urine is one of our biggest problems
Sally Woodcock, art conservator
"In St John's cathedral in Nicosia, one of the major sources of pollution was burning candles," explains Loupa.

The other church, St Paraskevi near Yeroskipou, didn't allow candles, but still had poor air quality at certain times. "Sometimes this was locally generated by traffic around the church," says Loupa.

On the worst occasions ozone levels inside St John's cathedral reached 40ppb (parts per billion) and nitrogen dioxide 200ppb. "These are the levels you would expect in the centre of Athens, next to a busy road," says Loupa.

Artwork (Rea Loupa)
Over time, the pollutants will start to eat into artwork
International recommendations (from the National Materials Advisory Board) suggest that artworks should not be exposed to more than 1ppb of ozone and 2.5ppb of nitrogen dioxide.

Both nitrogen oxides and ozone are bad news for artwork because they cause colours to fade and decrease the strength of materials.

They also react with other pollutants and often create secondary products that can be even more harmful.

Hold your breath

Volatile organic compounds such as isoprene were also a problem inside the churches.

"People emit organic compounds in their breath, so if the church is busy this is a problem," says Loupa. But even in quiet churches, organic compounds can be high, with cleaning products such as furniture polish and bleach contributing to the chemical cocktail.

Loupa and her colleagues think that these church pollution problems are likely to be global.

Church (Rea Loupa)
The research was conducted in two Cypriot churches
"All over the world there are lots of cars now, creating high levels of nitrogen oxides, ozone and particulate matter," says Loupa. And most churches are cleaned with solvent cleaners, rather than the traditional lemon and vinegar.

But not everyone is convinced that candles, cars and cleaning products are the worst culprits.

"In the UK, bat urine is one of our biggest problems," says Sally Woodcock, an art conservator who specialises in church paintings. Splashes of bat urine etch through the varnish and bleach the underlying paint.

And the UK's damp climate and dwindling church population is also taking its toll. "When churches are not open much then there is not much air flow. It is the ideal environment for mould," explains Woodcock.

Whether it is bat urine or candle smoke, Loupa and her colleagues think that there are ways of improving church interiors and preserving artwork.

"We suggest that no candles are allowed and that very precious artwork is put under glass," says Loupa. And if possible the scientists also recommend regulating the temperature and humidity with air conditioning and heating.

The research is being published in the journal Atmospheric Environment.

Mona Lisa pregnancy theory mooted
27 Sep 06 |  Entertainment
Public risk to priceless pieces
06 Feb 06 |  England

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific