Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education



Front Page

World

UK

UK Politics

Business

Sci/Tech

Health

Education

Sport

Entertainment

Talking Point

In Depth

On Air

Archive
Feedback
Low Graphics
Help

Tuesday, May 18, 1999 Published at 15:04 GMT 16:04 UK


Sci/Tech

GM food study was 'flawed'

Dr Arpad Pusztai: Stands by his work


Fergus Walsh reports: " The rat experiments were dismissed as flawed"
The research by Dr Arpad Pusztai which triggered the row in the UK over the safety of genetically-modified (GM) food was flawed, a panel of leading scientists said on Tuesday.

Dr Pusztai claimed rats in his Scottish laboratory suffered damage to their vital organs and immune systems as a result of being fed GM potatoes.

Food under the microscope
But the panel of six toxicologists, appointed by the influential Royal Society, has dismissed the research as irrelevant and inconclusive. It said the work undertaken by the Hungarian-born scientist was flawed in many "aspects of design, execution and analysis".

The panel said: "It would be unjustifiable to draw from it general conclusions about whether genetically-modified foods are harmful to human beings or not."

Scientific protocol


The Royal Society's Professor Patrick Bateson explains what was wrong with the research
Dr Pusztai lost his job at the Rowett Research Institute in Aberdeen as result of his claims, which he made on television last summer.

The institute said he had ignored scientific protocol by going public with his claims before the research had been peer reviewed and published in a recognised scientific journal.


[ image: The potatoes contained a gene from the snowdrop]
The potatoes contained a gene from the snowdrop
Nonetheless, the claims were the catalyst for the big debate on GM crops and food now underway in the UK. The row came to a head in February when a group of 20 scientists held a press conference to declare their support for Dr Pusztai.

Summoned before the House of Commons Science and Technology select committee, Dr Pusztai stood by his claims and said he had no regrets. The committee, which also published a report on Tuesday on the handling of the whole affair, said the UK risked losing the benefits of GM technology unless the government led a rational debate on the issue.

Snowdrop gene


BBC's Gerry Northam: The row over GM food is changing the relationship between government and scientists
Dr Pusztai's £1.6m research project, was funded by the Scottish Office. He modified potatoes to contain a gene from the snowdrop. This produced a natural insecticide, lectin, in the potatoes.

When these were fed to the rats over a period of 10 days, Dr Pusztai claimed some of their organs shrank or did not develop properly, including the kidney, the spleen and the brain. He said the rats' immune systems also suffered.


[ image: The Rowett removed Dr Pusztai from his post]
The Rowett removed Dr Pusztai from his post
However, the Royal Society Working Group said: "We found no convincing evidence of adverse affects from GM potatoes.

"Where the data seemed to show slight differences between rats fed predominantly on GM and on non-GM potatoes, the difference were uninterpretable because of the technical limitations of the experiment and the incorrect use of statistical tests."

The panel said the whole episode underlined the importance of scientists exposing their work to critical appraisal from their colleagues before releasing information to the public.

Further research


Jack Cunningham has welcomed the panel's findings
The working group stressed its report related solely to Dr Pusztai's research and said other studies on the health effects of GM food would be needed to resolve the arguments over the safety of the technology.

"There are going to be new foods which must be analysed properly and they must be done to the highest scientific standards and peer reviewed, and then published in the public domain," Professor Patrick Bateson, vice president of the society, said.


[ image: The working group said there was incorrect use of statistical tests]
The working group said there was incorrect use of statistical tests
Dr Jack Cunningham, who has taken responsibility for GM foods in the Cabinet, welcomed the findings of the Royal Society Working Group. A report by the UK Government's Chief Medical Officer to be published in the next few days would echo the findings of the panel, he said.

The pressure group Friends of the Earth, which has campaigned against GM foods, said the report from the Royal Society did not change its view of the dangers - both to human health and to the environment - of GM foods.


Oxford University's Professor Chris Leaver debates GM food with Tony Juniper
"There's no concrete proof that they are safe," said its spokesman Tony Juniper.

"The public are concerned about the use of biotechnology in agriculture and I think they are behind the British Medical Association (BMA) which is calling for a pause so that we can properly assess the upsides and downsides of the application of biotechnology in food."

The BMA said on Monday that the UK Government should adopt a more cautious approach to GM foods. It said more research was needed into the environmental, agricultural and health impacts of the technology.



Advanced options | Search tips




Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©


Sci/Tech Contents


Relevant Stories

19 May 99 | Sci/Tech
Pusztai attacks his critics

19 May 99 | Sci/Tech
GM potatoes and all that

18 May 99 | UK Politics
MPs call for 'rational' GM debate

17 Mar 99 | Food under the microscope
GM food: Head to head

06 Mar 99 | Sci/Tech
GM-row scientist 'misrepresented'

17 May 99 | Health
Doctors: Ban GM crops

06 Apr 99 | Food under the microscope
Genetically-modified Q&A





Internet Links


British Medical Association

Rowett Research Institute

Royal Society


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.




In this section

World's smallest transistor

Scientists join forces to study Arctic ozone

Mathematicians crack big puzzle

From Business
The growing threat of internet fraud

Who watches the pilots?

From Health
Cold 'cure' comes one step closer