Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education



Front Page

World

UK

UK Politics

Business

Sci/Tech

Health

Education

Sport

Entertainment

Talking Point
On Air
Feedback
Low Graphics
Help

Thursday, August 27, 1998 Published at 07:54 GMT 08:54 UK


Sci/Tech

Computer judges Wife of Bath to be chaste

Chaucer's Canterbury Tales may not be as racy as scholars thought

Students of Chaucer may have to rethink their theories about one of the most notorious woman in early English literature, the Wife of Bath.

Using evolutionary biology, scientists have been able to debunk the long-held theory that the sexually voracious Wife of Bath was actually so outrageous.

Biologists at Cambridge University have used a system developed for tracing the origin of the species through their DNA to work out which of the 58 surviving versions of The Canterbury Tales are closest to the original, which no longer exists.


[ image: DNA tests show the Wife of Bath to be more demure]
DNA tests show the Wife of Bath to be more demure
Some depict the wife as coarse and with an indiscriminate sexual appetite, but researchers say they can now restore her to the personality they believe Chaucer intended.

The most authentic manuscripts still paint her as outrageous, but with hankerings after respectability.

The infamous passage about her appetite for all men "were he short or long or black or white", no matter "how poore" or of "what degree", was probably excised by Chaucer and replaced by scholars later, the scientists have discovered.

The results of the research - published in the scientific journal Nature - found evidence for believing that Chaucer's own copy was not a completed single text but a working draft.

The researchers, led by Dr Christopher Howe, wrote: "In time, this may lead editors to produce a radically different text of The Canterbury Tales."


Dr Christopher Howe and DR Peter Robinson explain how they made the breakthrough
Speaking on Radio 4's Today programme, one of the literary experts who worked on the project, Dr Peter Robinson, said the research made the Wife of Bath a different person.

"It stresses her desire for social and economic dominance rather than her sexual aggression," he said.

Dr Howe's team worked with manuscript experts from De Montfort University in Leicester who are investigating the origins of Chaucer's works.

They used the latest computerised techniques normally used by biologists to reconstruct the evolutionary trees of different species from their DNA.

Early hand-copied manuscripts often contain duplicated mistakes and variations.

By comparing the similarities and differences of a number of texts, scientists are able to reach conclusions about what an original copy was like, even if it has been lost.

Family trees

Until now, the technique, known as 'stemmatics', has been a laborious manual process only feasible for a few short manuscripts.

But Dr Howe realised it had much in common with the techniques used by evolutionary biologists to track different species' family trees.

He and his team concentrated on The Wife of Bath's Prologue to produce a computer-generated family tree showing the relationships between the 58 different 15th century versions of the story.

A number of manuscripts formed groups which could be traced back to distinct common ancestors.

One particular group appeared to go back further than the others to a point probably close to the missing original.

Yet these manuscripts had mostly been ignored by scholars.

Dr Robinson added that the work had given the team a "radically more efficient" way of discovering the early history of the Tales.

"It has already suggested vital new approaches to long-unsolved problems, which will bring us much closer to understanding what Chaucer left behind him at his death."





Advanced options | Search tips




Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©


Sci/Tech Contents

Relevant Stories

01 Sep 98 | Sci/Tech
Puffbox -





In this section

World's smallest transistor

Scientists join forces to study Arctic ozone

Mathematicians crack big puzzle

From Business
The growing threat of internet fraud

Who watches the pilots?

From Health
Cold 'cure' comes one step closer