[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC TwoThis World


Last Updated: Monday, 9 October 2006, 10:38 GMT 11:38 UK
Will Israel bomb Iran?
By Chris Boulding
Director, Will Israel bomb Iran?

This World investigates the debate going on in Israel about how to deal with Iran's nuclear project, which divides the diplomatic world.

Iran insists that its programme is exclusively peaceful, citing the international treaty which gives it the right to use atomic energy to produce power.

Explosion in Beirut after bomb attack
An Israeli airstrike hits the suburbs of Beirut, Lebanon in August
Yet there remains deep diplomatic suspicion of Iran in the West, and growing alarm that it is exploiting its civil nuclear programme as a cover to produce atomic weapons.

Israel is the crux. Seen in the Arab world as America's outpost in the Middle East, Israel's very existence is regarded as a "stain" by Iran's Islamic regime which came to power in 1979.

Within two months of his election, Iran's current President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad approvingly quoted Ayatollah Khomeini's call for Israel to be "removed from the pages of history".

The statement drew fierce condemnation inside Israel and crystallised attitudes towards Iran among Israelis.

Intelligence reports

Israel's former Prime Minister Shimon Peres called for the international community to shun Iran.

He said: "Iran is the only member of the United Nations that threatens publicly to destroy another member of the United Nations. It is a call for genocide."

The Israeli leadership had already become increasingly concerned by intelligence reports on Iran's nuclear project.

Israel is not going to wait until the first nuclear bomb is going to be dropped on Israel
Avi Dichter, Israeli Minister for Public Security

But now Israeli feelings about Iran have reached a critical point. In order to understand Israeli attitudes, it is necessary to get inside the Israeli mindset, to uncover why Iran is being seen as an 'existential' threat - that is, a danger to the nation's very existence.

Why is Israel's fear of attack so intense? And what kind of response could such feelings trigger?

To some in Israel's political world, the country's life is on the line and if some action is not taken, the country could disappear from history in the way that President Ahmadinejad spoke of.

Despite Iran's frequent diplomatic reminders that its nuclear objectives are entirely peaceful, there is a sense of foreboding inside Israel.

The former Prime Minister Ehud Barak sums up his own feelings by drawing on a personal experience after the Yom Kippur war in 1973, when he returned from Israel to live in America.

He said he realised - while watching a football game - that if Israel had lost the war, it would have become a part of history and not a single game of football would be cancelled.

"And I carried this memory with me to the chair of the prime minister. Ultimately we are standing alone."

Nuclear deterrent

According to the respected Carnegie Institute, Israel has its own deterrent, in the shape of an arsenal of as many as 200 atomic warheads.

AFP-Getty image of Iran nuclear plant
Iran's heavy water plant at Arak has provoked international criticism
But Israel has never openly acknowledged its atomic programme, and has always maintained that it will not be the first to introduce nuclear weapons in to the Middle East.

The possibility that Iran could build nuclear weapons is regarded by some of Israel's military and political class as an unacceptable danger, putting the world's most dangerous weapons in the hands of their enemies.

The former head of Israel's security service Shin Beit, Avi Dichter, believes Israel must now adopt a "preventative" approach.

"I was an Air Marshal and I was trained to open fire towards a terrorist once I identified two things: one that he has a means of warfare, a pistol, a hand grenade, etc, and the second that he has an intention to use it in order to kill innocent people," says Mr Dichter, who is now Israel's minister for Public Security.

"Israel is not going to wait until the first nuclear bomb is going to be dropped on Israel."

Western intelligence services claim they have good evidence that Iran is developing atomic weapons and President Bush has declared that he will not permit a nuclear armed Iran.

But with its ongoing commitments in Iraq, some of Israel's strategic thinkers believe America has too much at stake to intervene militarily.

Iraq precedent?

Meanwhile, Israel's foreign minister has said publicly that time is running out. This scenario begs the question: could Israel act against Iran on its own?

Twenty five years ago, it did precisely that. The Iraqi nuclear reactor at Osirak was potentially capable of producing material for atomic weapons.

America was then backing Saddam Hussein's regime, and seemed unlikely to take hostile action against a nation at war with Iran.

In 1981, when the reactor was nearly complete, Prime Minister Begin of Israel felt that the threat required immediate action. He decided to go it alone and launch a raid to destroy the nuclear plant. Eight Israeli F-16 fighters bombed the Iraqi facility, in what was seen in Israel as a model of pre-emptive action.

As a last resort, the West should be ready to launch military strikes to deal with Iranian nuclear capabilities.
Moshe Yaalon, former chief of staff, Israeli armed forces
Could this happen again? According to Israeli intelligence sources, Iran's scientists are now within a year of reaching the technical point when they could enrich uranium to the level required for atomic arms.

This is regarded in Israel as the point of no return, after which Iran would allegedly be able to produce the uranium needed at secret sites.

Some Israelis think this is the moment when action should be taken. For them, a nuclear armed Iran is a doomsday scenario.

Israel's war with Hezbollah this summer reminded Israelis of Iran's reach beyond its own borders. Iran is widely believed to provide support and weaponry to Hezbollah.

The end of the conflict left Israel's government and its military under investigation for what was seen as a failure to defeat the Islamic militant movement convincingly.

Some inside Israel believe that Israel must turn its attention directly to Iran.

The former chief of staff of Israel's armed forces, Moshe Yaalon concludes: "As a last resort, the West should be ready to launch military strikes to deal with Iranian nuclear capabilities ...but Israel should be ready to deal with this kind of threat, if anyone else doesn't do it."

Will Israel bomb Iran? was broadcast on Tuesday, 10 October, 2006 at 21.50 BST on BBC Two

Will Israel Bomb Iran?
05 Oct 06 |  This World
Read your comments
29 Sep 06 |  This World
Factfile: How Osirak was bombed
05 Jun 06 |  Middle East
'The F-16s passed me at Osirak'
16 Jun 06 |  South Asia
Osirak: Over the reactor
05 Jun 06 |  Middle East
Osirak: Threats real and imagined
05 Jun 06 |  Middle East

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

banner watch listen bbc sport Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific