[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Thursday, 30 November 2006, 17:41 GMT
Legal Pluralism
British muslims praying
BBC Radio 4's Law In Action
Tuesday 28 November 1600 BST
On Radio 4 and online

What Law in Action really said about Islamic law in Britain.

There seems to be some confusion about what Tuesday's edition of Law in Action did and did not reveal about the existence of sharia (Islamic law) courts in Britain.

We would like to clarify a few points for those who have not had a chance to listen to the programme in its entirety.

We have not discovered the existence of sharia courts dispensing criminal justice in Britain. The only alternative criminal court which we know of uses Somali customary law.

Those who use the court are Muslim but the court does not apply sharia law.

The court seeks to reconcile victims and perpetrators by asking those found guilty to pay a sum of money to the complainant.

The court does not apply punishments such stoning, amputation and beheading.

What the sharia councils do in Britain

The main activities of the sharia councils we have spoken to are the giving of religious advice and the dissolution of Muslim marriages in cases where the husband does not agree to the divorce.

One sharia council we spoke to, the Mahkamah Council of Jurists, also settles civil law disputes on matters such as contract and negligence.

Its decisions are recognised as enforceable in English law as long as they are reasonable.

In this respect it is operating in a way similar to that of the Jewish courts in Britain (Beth Din) and to other courts of arbitration.

Although, as far as we know, none of the sharia councils deals with matters of criminal law, Faizul Aqtab Siddiqi of the Mahkamah Council of Jurists told us that he believes 'there is a case to be made under which the elders sit together and reprimand people of the community to get them to change.'

Further details can be obtained by reading the article 'The End of One Law for All' if you go to the See Also section on top right hand side of this page.

Law in Action - Tuesday 28 November

It is one law for all isn't it? Well perhaps not if you are a member of one of Britain's religious or ethnic minorities who are turning to their own parallel legal systems to sort out disputes.

'Legal pluralism', is the law's own brand of multiculturalism.

It means a legal system which allows other culturally specific legal systems to operate within it.

However, as Law in Action has discovered, it is more than just a theory.

Religious and ethnic minority courts are already a reality in the UK.

On today's programme:

  • Presenter Clive Coleman visits a Jewish court, the London Beth Din. He hears from the court's registrar David Frei about how the court works and the wide range of civil disputes it deals with;
  • Our reporter Innes Bowen speaks to Aydarus Yusuf who facilitates an unofficial criminal court in South East London using traditional Somalian law; and
  • BBC reporter Nasreen Suleaman speaks to a British Muslim woman who used both a mainstream court and a sharia council to obtain separate secular and Islamic divorces.

To discuss the issues raised, Clive is joined in the studio by:

Dr Prakash Shah
Dr Prakash Shah is one of the guests in Law in Action

  • Dr Prakash Shah, Senior Lecturer in law at Queen Mary University of London and author of Legal Pluralism in Conflict (pub Routledge Cavendish 2005)
  • Jonathan Greenwood, a solicitor specialising in Jewish law
  • Faizul Aqtab Siddiqi, a commercial barrister, Principal of Hijaz College Islamic University and a member of the Mahkamah Council of Jurists
  • Cassandra Balchin, spokesperson for Women Living Under Muslim Laws and co-author of Recognizing the Un-Recognized: Inter-Country Cases and Muslim Marriages & Divorces in Britain (pub. Women Living Under Muslim Laws, January 2006)
  • Do you know of any other alternative courts in Britain? If so, please let us know.

    E-mail address: lawinaction@bbc.co.uk

Law in Action


Download or subscribe to this programme's podcast

Podcast Help

The end of one law for all?
28 Nov 06 |  Magazine
Religious freedom in Malaysia
09 Nov 06 |  Crossing Continents
Justice in Bolivia
16 Nov 06 |  Crossing Continents

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific