[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Tuesday, 28 March 2006, 05:08 GMT 06:08 UK
Hospital parking: who's making a mint?
Breakfast reporter Julia Botfield
Julia Botfield with the Freedom of Information list
Over the past couple of weeks here on Breakfast, you've been telling us about your experiences as an NHS patient.

One of the biggest causes of complaint has been the high charges some hospitals make for car-parking.

Now, using the Freedom of Information Act, the BBC has found out exactly how much hospitals in England are making from the charges.

The figures - obtained from the Department of Health - reveal that some hospitals generate more than 1m from parking fees, while others make only a few thousand pounds.

This morning on Breakfast:

  • Our reporter Julia Botfield went to the Queen Elizabeth Medical Centre in Birmingham. With its sister hospital in Selly Oak, it generated 1.5m from car park charges last year.

  • You can see the full list of hospital income from car-parks via the link below. You will need to have a PDF reader installed on your computer

    We took the decision to remove a handful of hospitals from the list, because they appeared to have given inaccurate figures (two appeared to suggest they had made 6 in a year).

    And, although the information was gathered by the Department of Health, not every hospital in England responded to its request for information.

    HOSPITAL CAR PARK INCOME
    Most computers will open PDF documents automatically, but you may need to download Adobe Acrobat Reader.

    The data collected is for 2004 to 2005, but the Department of Health told Breakfast "This is a non-mandatory collection and therefore may not be complete."

    The figures represent the total gross income generated by parking fees - before costs such as staff and maintenance.

    Crunching the numbers

    The University Hospital Birmingham said it received 1.5m in car parking charges last year - and paid its contractor Q-Park 1m to operate the car parks.
    Hospital Communications Director Fiona Alexander
    The hospital says half a million pounds went back to patient care

    That leaves half a million pounds, which has been ploughed back into patient care in its hospitals.

    The hospital's communications director Fiona Alexander told us that the car park has half a million users a year, paying on average a 3 charge for three hours.

    She added that 800,000 has been spent on improving the car park, providing CCTV, shuttle buses and free parking for kidney and cancer patients.

    The Birmingham trust is one of twelve hospital trusts in England which generated more than a million pounds in gross income from car-parking last year.

    Gerard and Amanda Murphy
    Gerard and Amanda spent 560 on parking when he had leukaemia

    The other million-pound money spinners are: Basildon and Thurrock University Foundation Trust; Cambridgeshire University Hospital Trust; North West London Hospitals; Portsmouth Hospitals; Southampton University Hospitals; Barking, Havering and Redbridge Hospitals; Barnet and Chase Farm Hospitals; East Kent Hospitals; Epsom and St Helier; Pennine Acute Hospitals; United Lincolnshire Hospitals.

    There's a wide difference between the amount of money generated by car park charges: for instance, Tower Hamlets Primary Care Trust received 5,110.

    The Department of Health stressed that it was up to the individual hospital to decide whether to provide a car park and whether to charge. It added:

    "What level any charge should be set, taking into account local circumstances including patients, visitors and staff needs and the cost of providing the service".

  • We'd like to hear your experiences of parking charges at your local hospital. You can use this form to send your views straight to the Breakfast inbox:

    Name
    Your E-mail address
    Where you live
    Comments

    The BBC may edit your comments and not all emails will be published. Your comments may be published on any BBC media worldwide.




  • VIDEO AND AUDIO NEWS
    Hospital car parking
    Where does the money go? Fiona Alexander defended the Queen Elizabeth's charges



    SEE ALSO
    Hospitals: the hidden costs
    03 Mar 06 |  Breakfast
    Paying to park at your hospital
    02 Mar 06 |  Breakfast
    The hidden costs of hospital
    08 Mar 06 |  Breakfast

    RELATED BBC LINKS

    RELATED INTERNET LINKS
    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


    FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
    Has China's housing bubble burst?
    How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
    Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

    PRODUCTS & SERVICES

    Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific