Page last updated at 07:40 GMT, Monday, 24 May 2010 08:40 UK

Israel fears stronger Hezbollah 10 years after pull-out

Old border post near Metulla
The old border post at Metulla, once used by Lebanese workers crossing into Israel, is now in disrepair

By Heather Sharp
BBC News, Metulla, north Israel

Barely 100m from a picnic spot in Israel's northern-most village, the yellow flag of the Lebanese militant group Hezbollah flutters in the breeze.

It was through Metulla that the last Israeli soldiers drove as they withdrew unilaterally from Lebanon in 2000, ending their 18-year presence in the country.

The troops had held a buffer zone in southern Lebanon, aiming to protect Israel's northern border from militant attacks.

Now 10 years later, the scene is tranquil, although a major war was fought across this border in 2006, and the regional media is full of talk of Iranian-backed Hezbollah's growing arsenal.

Lebanese, Palestinian and Hezbollah flags in Lebanon, seen from Israeli side of border
A Hezbollah flag can be seen flying just metres from the border

"In Metulla, it's always business as usual," says local resident Jonathan Javor, 28. "You still have to pick fruit, you still have to open your hotel, no matter what's going on."

Metulla forms a finger of land jutting into Lebanon.

Its green orchards back right onto the border, overlooked by Lebanese villages on the hills beyond.

Israel invaded Lebanon in 1982, pushing as far as Beirut in an attempt to target Palestinian militants, but then drew back to hold a zone varying from about 5-20km (3-12 miles) into Lebanon, to protect border communities such as Metulla.

While many Lebanese civilians from the buffer zone crossed into Israel daily to work, Hezbollah and other militant groups fought a war of attrition against the Israelis and their Lebanese Christian allies, the South Lebanon Army.

On average, about two or three Israeli soldiers died each month.

Bruria Sharon (l), Amalia Dayan (c), Smadar Ben-Porat (r), former members of Four Women
The Four Mothers activists say soldiers were dying "for nothing' in south Lebanon

Sitting on a sunny veranda in Kibbutz Ashdot Yaacov, an hour's drive south, three friends reminisce together about the campaign they waged, as part of a group called Four Mothers, for the withdrawal.

"Many people called us saying 'Please take my child out of Lebanon, I want him alive," says Amalia Dayan.

From a local guerrilla organisation, we've created a monster
Alon Ben-David
Defence analyst

The women are at pains to point out their commitment to sending their sons and daughters to defend Israel.

But Mrs Dayan says they felt losses in Lebanon were a sacrifice "for nothing," in a long-standing occupation "with no goal".

Ten years on, the women have no regrets. Smadar Ben-Porat believes it is just a matter of time until the next war with Hezbollah, but she thinks the movement would have grown stronger whether or not Israel had pulled out.

"I believe it's better for us to defend our country from legitimate borders," she says.

Israeli soldiers leaving Lebanon (24 May 2000)
Israeli soldiers celebrated as they left Lebanon

Israeli President Shimon Peres recently accused Syria of transferring Scud missiles to Hezbollah. The US says the group now has more missiles than most governments.

There is a UN presence in south Lebanon, which was expanded as part of the 2006 ceasefire agreement, but few Israelis believe it has stopped Hezbollah rearming.

Metulla Mayor, Herzl Boker

If Lebanon creates an escalation, the state of Israel will react… if we will not live in peace, neither will they

Herzel Boker
Mayor, Metulla

Alon Ben-David, military analyst for Israel's Channel 10 television, believes Hezbollah has 40,000 rockets and long-range precision missiles with which it could strike targets such as military bases and power stations, which "makes the equation completely different".

"From a local guerrilla organisation, we've created a monster," he says.

In 2000, the troops were pulled out ahead of schedule, in what was perceived on both sides as a hasty scramble. Hezbollah claimed it as a major victory.

"We boosted the radical axis - Iran, Syria and Hezbollah - we gave them a lot of encouragement in the withdrawal and I think we're still paying the price for it," says Mr Ben-David.

At present, he believes neither side has the incentive for another war, "because they realise what devastation it would cause on both sides".

But, he says, if Israel were to launch a pre-emptive strike against Iran's nuclear programme, Hezbollah would be likely to hit back.


In Metulla, town mayor Herzel Boker dismisses talk of imminent war as "manufactured by journalists".

A commander in Israel's south at the time of the withdrawal, he believes the pull-out was "a necessity", but says it left the security situation "effectively without control".

Few Israelis argue that the troops should have stayed, but many wish they had left differently - as part of a peace deal with Syria and Lebanon, or at least without creating the impression of weakness.

Mr Boker is also angered that Israel did not make better provisions for the SLA fighters and their families. Some were able to rush across the border to begin new lives in Israel, but others were left behind and captured by Hezbollah.

The 2006 war began when Hezbollah seized two Israeli soldiers from the border region. Israel struck back, mainly at south Lebanon and Hezbollah areas in Beirut.

Some 1,200 Lebanese, mostly civilians, and some 160 Israelis, most of whom were soldiers, were killed.

Now, there are two Hezbollah ministers in Lebanon's unity government and Israel has said it will hold Lebanon as a whole responsible for the activities of Hezbollah.

"If Lebanon creates an escalation, the state of Israel will react, and as we saw in 2006 it could react aggressively… if we will not live in peace, neither will they," Mr Boker says.

Print Sponsor

New US warning to Syria on Scuds
30 Apr 10 |  Middle East
Hezbollah 'has improved missiles'
28 Apr 10 |  Middle East
US warns Syria over Scud claims
22 Apr 10 |  Middle East
Lebanese PM denies missile claim
21 Apr 10 |  Middle East
US summons Syrian envoy over arms
20 Apr 10 |  Middle East
Syria denies scud missile charge
15 Apr 10 |  Middle East
US worries about Syrian intentions
15 Apr 10 |  Middle East
Hezbollah chief meets Ahmadinejad
26 Feb 10 |  Middle East
Syria inches in from the cold
08 Dec 08 |  Middle East

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific