Page last updated at 18:13 GMT, Thursday, 17 September 2009 19:13 UK

Cold War roots of Yemen conflict

Yemeni army vehicle in Saada province (file image)

By Ginny Hill
Yemen analyst

The roots of Yemen's current civil conflict, in which the government is trying to put down a localised but potent rebellion, lie in the Cold War regional politics of the 1960s.

Then, Egyptian-backed army officers brought an end to Yemen's 1,000-year Shia Imamate and established the modern Yemeni republic.

Republican troops seized control of Yemen's capital, Sanaa, in 1962, while the imam fled to the northern mountains, where he mounted a spirited counter-offensive from the same territory where the fighting is happening today.

Then, as now, a well-equipped army in Sanaa deployed air power and superior military hardware against the rebels in the Saada region but for five years republican forces failed to defeat the mountain guerrillas.

Perceptions of external interference in Yemen serve to distract attention from multiple internal factors driving this brutal stop-start war

Thursday's reported aerial bombardments of civilians, reports that the Saada rebels are holding Yemeni soldiers as prisoners of war and preparations by aid agencies to deliver humanitarian relief across the border from Saudi Arabia echo familiar patterns of conflict from the 1960s.

Then, as now, regional dynamics inflamed local tensions inside Yemen, with Saudi Arabia and Jordan backing Yemen's imam against thousands of Egyptian troops barracked in Sanaa.

War 'over'

The 21st Century geopolitical context has undeniably changed, but regional tensions continue to stoke the conflict in Yemen.

Yemeni President  Ali Abdullah Saleh in Sanaa (file image)
President Saleh declared the war "over" in 2008

Sunni-dominated Saudi Arabia is nervous about a Shia uprising on its southern borders.

Shia Iran stands accused of supporting the Saada rebels, despite the fact that Yemen's Zaydi Shias - who take their name from the fifth imam, Zayd Ibn Ali - are doctrinally distinct from Iran's Twelver Shias.

At times, the insurgents in Saada have also been accused of accepting support from Libya, Hezbollah and al-Qaeda, as well as Yemen's local Jewish minority.

Such inconsistent allegations are certainly exploited for shifting and expedient political reasons.

Perceptions of external interference in Yemen serve to distract attention from multiple internal factors driving this brutal stop-start war, which began in 2004 when the rebels condemned Yemen's government for allying with the West on counter-terrorism and called for freedom to worship according to their own traditions.

Yemen's government has since brokered several failed ceasefire agreements with the rebels, and in July 2008 President Ali Abdullah Saleh abruptly declared the Saada war "over" during celebrations for his 30th anniversary in power.

Religious balance

However, the underlying grievances have not been resolved and resentments keep escalating during each cycle of conflict, drawing local tribes into the fight.

Displaced Yemeni woman in a camp in Hajja region (15 September 2009)
The UN says Yemen's "humanitarian emergency" has been overlooked

Yemen is a Sunni majority country, but President Saleh has Zaydi Shia heritage. Crucially, he is not a sayyid - a descendant of the Muslim Prophet Muhammad through his grandsons, Hussein and Hassan.

Yemen's ruling imams historically derived their legitimacy partly from their sayyid status and the charismatic Houthi family who now lead the Saada rebellion are also sayyid - although, the Houthis deny allegations that they intend to reinstate the imam's rule.

While there is a sectarian element to this war, it lies in the delicate local religious balance between Zaydi Shia and Sunni Salafi teaching institutes in the Saada region.

The rebels accuse President Saleh of playing divide-and-rule politics by promoting Sunni Salafi institutes while restricting the activities of a Zaydi Shia revivalist movement, known as the Believing Youth.

However, many contributing factors to the Saada war are much more profane.

A recent report from the International Crisis Group (ICG) noted that the "conflict has become self-perpetuating, giving rise to a war economy".

Looting, drug smuggling, gunrunning, people trafficking, tribal feuds and an unresolved hostage crisis, involving a kidnapped Briton, have also contributed to the lawless reputation of the Saada region.

Resources strained

The United Nations' Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (Ocha) claims Yemen's "humanitarian emergency" has been "largely neglected" by the international community and a $23m (£14m) flash appeal to help 150,000 internally displaced people fleeing the fighting in Saada has not yet received any funds.

Saada map

At a national level, Yemen is oil dependent but oil production is declining and the weak central government has less and less money at its disposal.

In addition to the war in Saada, the government confronts a southern separatist movement and resurgent terrorist networks.

Increasing numbers of Somali refugees and a rapidly growing domestic population place escalating strain on Yemen's fragile resources.

The fear that Yemen could eventually fragment now preoccupies Yemen's neighbours and its Western allies.

The scenario of state collapse in Yemen would create even greater potential for external interference in this strategic Arabian Peninsula state.

Ginny Hill is the author of Yemen: Fear of Failure, a Chatham House briefing paper

Print Sponsor

'Many killed' in Yemen air raid
17 Sep 09 |  Middle East
Yemen claims success over rebels
10 Sep 09 |  Middle East
Foreigners 'kidnapped' in north Yemen
14 Jun 09 |  Middle East
Civil war fears as Yemen celebrates unity
21 May 09 |  Country profiles
A new pattern of Yemeni violence
17 Jun 09 |  Middle East
Yemen country profile
07 Jun 11 |  Country profiles

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Sign in

BBC navigation

Copyright © 2015 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific