BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in:  World: Middle East
Front Page 
Middle East 
South Asia 
From Our Own Correspondent 
Letter From America 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Thursday, 7 February, 2002, 13:50 GMT
Europe's growing Mid East role
Palestinian stone thrower
Intifada: EU fears its effect on moderate Arab states
By Middle East analyst Fiona Symon

Arab countries have long been pressing for greater European involvement in the Middle East peace process to counteract the perceived US bias towards Israel.

Crown Prince Abdullah of Saudi Arabia has said that Europe has a "moral and political responsibility" towards the region because of its former colonial role and its close ties to the Arab world.

Europe's ability to exert any influence on the Middle East peace process has been hampered by divisions

Europe should play a "more prominent role than the one that is currently hardly noticeable", he said.

But until recently Israel resisted direct European participation in its peace talks with the Palestinians because it too perceived Europe to be more pro-Arab than the United States.

As a result, Europeans have been either sidelined or completely absent from all the major peace negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians during the past 30 years.

European vision

It is true that the European Union has taken a consistently more sympathetic line towards Palestinian rights than a succession of US administrations over the years.

The Venice Declaration in 1980 was the first official European statement setting out a clear position on the Middle East.

Israeli Foreign Minister Shimon Peres and Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat
Peres and Arafat held talks in Europe last year
It recognised the Palestinians' right to self-determination, called for an end to the Israeli occupation of Arab territories, condemned the Jewish settlements in the occupied territories and the Israeli legislation changing the status of Jerusalem as illegal.

It also recognised the need to involve the Palestine Liberation Organisation in the peace negotiations - something which the US at the time did not.

The EU explicitly recognised the Palestinians' right to a state at the Berlin summit conference in 1999 - whereas the US has only lately adopted this view.

Consensus required

Europe's ability to exert any influence on the Middle East peace process has been hampered in the past by divisions among the different EU countries. France has tended to have a more pro-Arab bias, while Germany and the Netherlands were closer to Israel.

This is illustrated by the EU's failure to act over Israel's claiming of duty-free status for goods made in Israeli settlements inside the West Bank and Gaza.

Bank of Palestine
Effort to build stable Palestinian institutions undermined by violence
The EU does not regard such settlements as legal or part of Israel and has been poised to announce an end to the practice, which goes back some 25 years.

EU resolve has been strengthened by anger in Brussels over Israel's policy of "targeted assassinations" of Palestinians, and by the prolonged closures of the West Bank and Gaza that are blamed for worsening the prospects for peace.

However, for the duty-free status to be taken away, a consensus is required among the EU foreign ministers - something that has so far failed to emerge.

Equal partner

The 1992 Maastricht treaty, giving Europe a common foreign and security policy, was followed by the appointment in 1996 of a special representative for the Middle East to put Europe's proposals and guarantees to the various parties.

But while this led to a series of diplomatic tours, it had little effect on the strength of Europe's voice in the peace process.

Europe has taken the lead in financial aid to the Palestinians

In the absence of an effective role in the negotiations, Europe has focused its main efforts on support for economic development in the region as a way of encouraging peaceful coexistence between Israel and its neighbours.

In 1986, the EU granted a preferential regime for Palestinian products and in 1987, under European pressure, Israel agreed to the direct export of Palestinian products to Europe.

In the mid-1990s, the EU set about creating a Euro-Mediterranean partnership, with the aim of creating a free-trade zone between Europe and its neighbours in the Middle East.

Association agreements were signed with Israel in 1995 and with the Palestinian Authority two years later.

The Euro-Mediterranean Partnership remains the only multilateral forum outside the United Nations where all parties to the conflict can meet and where the Palestinian Authority is recognised as an equal partner.

Intifada effect

Europe has taken the lead in financial aid to the Palestinians - something that has provoked criticism from Israel.

German Foreign Minister Joschka Fischer
Germany's Joschka Fischer: Trusted by both sides

The EU is the largest donor of non-military aid to the peace process, giving 179m euros ($157m) a year on average over the past six years in direct support of the Palestinian Authority, refugees and regional peace process projects.

It was the first donor of financial and technical assistance to the Palestinian Authority providing over 50% of the international community's finance for the West Bank and Gaza Strip between 1994 and 1998.

But much of the effort to build stable Palestinian institutions and improve the economic situation of Palestinians has been undone by the intifada and the accompanying Israeli closures.

Europeans have recently been more assertive in attempting to mediate between Israel and the Palestinians, partly because of the vacuum created by the absence of the US as a mediator during the first few months of the new Bush administration.

Mediator role

EU and notably German leaders have been adopting a more high-profile engagement in the Middle East and this has been accompanied by a more conciliatory line towards Israel.

Under German Foreign Minister Joschka Fischer, who enjoys the confidence of both the Israelis and the Palestinians, Germany has virtually adopted the role of unofficial mediator in the Middle East.

"It is pointless if one party receives me and the other refuses. In that sense, the change in European behaviour is significant," Mr Fischer has said.

Israel, too, appears to have realised it can no longer afford to ignore the views of its leading trade partner.

In 2000, trade with the EU represented 27% of Israeli exports and 43% of its imports.

Last November, Foreign Minister Shimon Peres and Palestinian Authority Chairman Yasser Arafat held talks in the Baleares Islands that were joined by Spanish Prime Minister Jose Maria Aznar.

This marks a break from the past, when Palestinians and Israelis tended to allow only Americans to mediate between them in these kind of three-way meetings.

Both the US and Europe regard the Palestinian intifada as creating risks for moderate Arab states and as an impediment to maintaining the international coalition against Osama Bin Laden.

There is therefore a move for greater co-ordination between the European and US positions and may ensure a continuing role for the EU as a mediator in future negotiations.

See also:

07 Feb 02 | Middle East
Violence clouds Sharon's US visit
30 Nov 01 | issues
The running of Palestine
02 Jan 02 | Review of 2001
Middle East peace retreats in 2001
30 Nov 01 | issues
Half century of US diplomacy
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Middle East stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Middle East stories