Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education

Front Page



UK Politics







Talking Point

In Depth

On Air

Low Graphics

Tuesday, March 16, 1999 Published at 19:27 GMT

40,000 for widow of smoker 'denied bypass'

Doctors say quitting smoking can be vital for some operations

The widow of a man whose heart surgery was cancelled because he was a smoker has been awarded 40,000 in compensation.

Andrea Gibson says her husband John's triple heart bypass operation was cancelled by Southampton General Hospital in 1993 after he admitted he was a smoker.

Mrs Gibson, from Alton, Hampshire, claims her husband fell into a depression after being told he could not have the operation and died 10 months later from a heart attack.

"John never recovered from being told he could not have the operation," she said.

"He was literally minutes from having surgery when he was refused the treatment. "He had been shaved and the surgeon asked him whether he still smoked. John said yes and the surgeon said 'I cannot operate on you'."

"When I went to pick him up I saw him sitting on a wall. He looked as though he had been kicked by a horse. He was so dejected."

Mr Gibson, aged 59, smoked 20 cigarettes a day, but had cut down to five a day by the time the operation was scheduled to take place.

His wife says the surgeon told him smokers had less chance of surviving the bypass operation.

But she claimed that, if he had been warned in advance, he would have tried to give up smoking.

"None of us could believe it. If the hospital had got in touch with us before the operation then at least John could have given up smoking or cancelled the operation, but he was never given any chance," she said.

"He should have been given the benefit of the doubt," she said.

"We were all ready to support him in his bid to kick smoking."


She says the 40,000, awarded in an out of court settlement, will help pay off her debts.

She lost her home after her husband died because she was unable to keep up with mortgage repayments.

"I can never forget what happened and money is no compensation. But after five horrible years, I hope we can put it behind us and make sure that no-one else suffers in the same way," she said.

Southampton and South West Hampshire Health Authority, representing the hospital, said the compensation payment did not mean it admitted liability.

It rejects allegations that Mr Gibson was refused treatment - which would go against a General Medical Council ruling that patients' lifestyle should not be a factor in deciding whether they should receive treatment.

"His operation was deferred until he gave up smoking because the risks of operating while he continued to smoke were considered too high by the doctors," it said in a statement.

The decision was backed by the British Medical Association which stated: "For some conditions, giving up smoking can be the best immediate treatment.

"If patient are suffering from heart disease, for instance, quitting smoking is often essential if they are to be successfully treated."

But Juliet Wallbridge, spokeswoman for FOREST, which campaigns for smokers' rights, said: "Smokers are entitled to the same care and compassion as non-smokers."

Advanced options | Search tips

Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage |

Internet Links

British Medical Association

Southampton and South West Hampshire Health Authority

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

In this section

Smoker drops discrimination claim

Young smokers risk greater genetic damage

Anti-depressants beat the craving

10m lung cancer blitz

Tobacco firms 'hid safer cigarettes'

Cancer sufferers abandon tobacco case

Cigarettes: a complex cocktail of chemicals

High Court rules against tobacco claimants

Alert over herbal cigarettes

Smokers advised to combine therapies

Health coalition begins anti-smoking crusade

From Sci/Tech
Smoking cities

Dobson launches tobacco crusade

Mixed reaction to tobacco White Paper

Public say passive smoking is dangerous

Higher death risk for women smokers

Government targets young smokers

Controversy on passive smoking measures

Nicotine patches to be free on the NHS

From UK Politics
Controversial ban among tobacco controls

Tobacco tax hike prompts smuggling warning

'Stop tobacco firms targeting children'