Page last updated at 23:59 GMT, Thursday, 1 April 2010 00:59 UK

Hospital checklists for common conditions 'cut deaths'

Hospital ward
The checklists apply to common conditions

Checklists that spell out exactly how to care for patients with common conditions have dramatically reduced hospital deaths, say doctors.

The British Medical Journal reported a 15% fall in the number of people who had died at one north London hospital trust using so-called care bundles.

These are checklists covering dozens of conditions including strokes, heart failure and MRSA infections.

The researchers said death rates could be "halved" using the system.

The lists were introduced at North West London Hospitals NHS Trust by its former director of nursing, Liz Robb, who travelled to the US to learn the methods.

We think an average hospital could halve their death rate
Professor Brian Jarman, Imperial College London

She focused on approximately 56 conditions which accounted for about four in five of all deaths at the trust's three hospitals.

Under the system, when a patient is first diagnosed with one of these conditions, a coloured checklist is placed into their medical notes and a sticker on the front tells doctors and nurses to follow it.

Recommended treatments and care are based on the best available medical evidence and even include simple but vital elements such as hand-washing.

For example, any patient with diarrhoea and vomiting would be put in a side room with a closed door and have their antibiotic or laxative prescription reviewed.

Staff would also have to confirm with a signature that they had worn gloves and aprons, used soap and water to clean their hands before and after contact and notify the Infection Control Team.

'Cheap and easy'

At the London trust, which already had better-than-average death rates, there were 174 fewer deaths from the 56 conditions in 2007/08 compared with the previous year - the sharp drop in the overall death rate made it the best-performing trust in the country for that year.

The fact that the sharpest improvement centred on those conditions, and the hospital with the highest use of the checklists, suggested that they played a significant role, said the researchers.

Dr Clare Higgens, the trust's director of medical education, said: "It's so simple to use for doctors, nurses and other clinicians.

"In short, it has worked, and it continues to work."

Professor Brian Jarman, from Imperial College London, one of those involved in the scheme, said the impact could be massive if the system was adopted across the NHS, saving many thousands of lives each year.

Earlier this month he called for 25 trusts to be investigated over apparently high death rates.

He said: "It costs a few hundreds pounds per trust, but we believe it could make a substantial difference - any hospital could take this and say, 'Let's give it a go.'

"We think an average hospital could halve their death rate."

Inquiries are already coming in from other trusts and the Care Quality Commission, which monitors healthcare standards in England, is also impressed by the idea.

Its national clinical adviser, Professor David Haslam, said: "There is increasing evidence that checklists can make a real difference.

"There is good evidence that they ensure that clinicians don't miss the fundamental elements of delivering patient care and also that teams communicate better with each other."

Print Sponsor

Warning on hospital death rates
25 Mar 10 |  Health
Dispute over NHS hospital ratings
29 Nov 09 |  Health
Making operations smoother and safer
01 Nov 09 |  Health

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Press Association Care checklists cut patient deaths by 15% - 7 hrs ago
Telegraph Treatment checklists in hospitals 'can significantly cut death rates' - 33 hrs ago Care checklists cut deaths by 15% - 39 hrs ago

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific