Page last updated at 14:24 GMT, Saturday, 31 May 2008 15:24 UK

Cigarette machines may be banned


The new anti-smoking campaign advert

Cigarette vending machines and packets of 10 could be outlawed under government plans aimed at preventing children and young people smoking.

The plans, which include banning branding and logos, apply to England, Wales and Northern Ireland. Similar plans have been unveiled in Scotland.

Smokers' lobby group Forest said there was "no evidence" to show the plans would to cut smoking in young people.

Meanwhile, a new TV advert campaign is targeting parents who smoke.

The adverts warn that children of smokers are three times more likely to take up the habit than those of non-smokers.

Most computers will open this document automatically, but you may need Adobe Reader

Under current pricing, a packet of 10 cigarettes cost about 3, compared to nearly 6 for 20.

Last week the Scottish Government announced a range of proposals to restrict tobacco sales in Scotland - including a ban in shops from displaying cigarettes in "pride of place" on their shelves.

On the latest consultation document, Public Health Minister Dawn Primarolo said it was vital to take away temptation from children.

"Protecting children from smoking is a government priority and taking away temptation is one way to do this," she said.

"If banning brightly coloured packets, removing cigarettes from display and removing the cheap option of a pack of 10 helps save lives, then that is what we should do, but we want to hear everyone's views first."

'Tobacco trap'

Martin Dockrell, from the anti-smoking group Action on Smoking and Health (Ash), said: "These sorts of measures are not going to have an overnight effect, but we think they will over time."

A YouGov poll commissioned by Ash of 3,330 people found that 65% supported a complete ban on cigarette vending machines, while 43% favoured the introduction of plain packaging.

As far as vending machines go, the simple solution is to make them credit card operated - then children can't use them
Neil Rafferty

Dr Vivienne Nathanson, from the British Medical Association, which represents doctors, said: "It is essential that cigarettes are made more inaccessible to children.

"We need to break the tobacco trap. Young smokers will become tomorrow's parents who smoke and they will continue the cycle of smoking-related ill-health and premature death."

The Department of Health says point-of-sale advertising can encourage young people to start smoking, so it is suggesting putting cigarettes below the counter in future.

It also suggests the introduction of plain packaging for cigarettes, carrying only the product name in standard lettering.

Other ideas being mooted in the plans, which will go out for a three-month consultation, include a ban on advertising for "smoking paraphernalia" such as cigarette papers.

Pack sizes could also be restricted to a minimum of 20.

The consultation paper will be published in England, Wales and Northern Ireland.

I will not support a government that suggests that packaging is the reason why people smoke
David Craven, Oxford

It applies in its entirety to England, and certain sections - including that on smoking and young people - apply to Wales and Northern Ireland.

The plans come as the World Health Organisation (WHO) called on governments to ban all tobacco advertising to help prevent young people taking up the habit.

The Tobacco Manufacturers' Association said it "completely agrees with the government that children should not smoke and should be actively discouraged from doing so".

But its director, Chris Ogden, added: "While we welcome any sensible proposals that will assist in preventing the sale of tobacco to children under the age of 18, any proposals should be supported by credible evidence that they would address the government's stated objectives."

Smokers' lobby group Forest warned that banning point-of-sale display could make smoking even more attractive to teenagers, and could increase the appeal of counterfeit and smuggled cigarettes.

Newsagent's dismay

Spokesman Neil Rafferty said: "In one Canadian province, youth smoking actually went up in the first 18 months after a display ban was introduced.

"As far as vending machines go, the simple solution is to make them credit card operated - then children can't use them."

He criticised plans to ban packs of 10, arguing that children could still afford packs of 20.

One newsagent told the BBC he was dismayed by the proposals.

Phillip Youle, from Bridgewater, said: "Just how are my customers supposed to know what I have in stock and the price, if I am forced to take them off display and put them under the counter?

Smoking ban

He went on: "Is the government going to pay for the costs involved to adapt my counter? Will they compensate me for the inevitable loss in trade?

"Its hard enough to make a living in this game as it is; these proposals will see many newsagents/corner shops close."

The proposals follow a series of restrictions on smoking in the UK which have come into force over the last couple of years.

The legal age for smoking was raised from 16 to 18 in October.

A ban on smoking in public places and workplaces in England came into force last July.

Bans were introduced in Scotland in 2006, and in Wales and Northern Ireland in 2007.

Call to ban all tobacco adverts
31 May 08 |  Special Reports
Tobacco display ban plan unveiled
21 May 08 |  Scotland
Shop tobacco ban 'makes no sense'
21 May 08 |  Glasgow, Lanarkshire and West
Smokers 'make their children ill'
08 Mar 08 |  Merseyside

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific