[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Thursday, 21 December 2006, 03:03 GMT
Anger over egg donation licence
By Jane Dreaper and Rachael Buchanan
BBC News

A human egg
Women can donate eggs for research
The UK's fertility regulator has amended a licence to allow stem cell researchers to recruit egg donors not already having medical treatment.

A world expert criticised the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority for making the decision during a public consultation on the issue.

The HFEA has defended the decision, and stressed that it will not affect the outcome of the consultation.

The process of human egg donation involves potential health risks.

I am flabbergasted that the licence was given before the consultation process was completed
Dr Stephen Minger

Earlier this year, the team in Newcastle was awarded a temporary licence to offer discounted IVF treatment if patients donate eggs for research.

It has emerged that the team was granted the UK's first licence to begin recruiting female donors who are not already having medical treatment in November - even though the HFEA's public consultation on the issue didn't finish until early December.

'Improper decision'

Leading stem cell scientist, Dr Stephen Minger, from King's College London, criticised the awarding of the licence.

He said: "Although I support this research, I am flabbergasted that the licence was given before the consultation process was completed. It seems very improper.

"It begs the question - what is the point in having a consultation?

"Why should women undergo this procedure to donate material for something where we have no idea yet how efficient therapeutic cloning with human eggs is?"

Professor Alison Murdoch, from the Centre for Life, Newcastle, which has been granted the licence to use altruistic donations said: "I think it's probably very unlikely that we will get many women coming forward, because of the procedures that are involved and the potential risks that might be involved there.

"But I believe very firmly in women's choice, and if we give these women full info about what the research is about, and about the risks that they incur in participating in this research, I think we should take their decision as it stands."

The authority said the licence could be reviewed if the consultation resulted in a new policy which did not favour this type of egg donation, known as altruistic donation.

The HFEA said in a statement: "The intention is to be ready to produce a policy by late February.

"The recent decision to allow one centre to carry out altruistic egg donation for research will not affect the outcome of the consultation.

"The centre agreed to provide the HFEA with regular information on their work in the meantime to inform our decision making.

"The HFEA has a statutory obligation to consider research applications as they come in and therefore must deal with them."

Dr Evan Harris, a Liberal Democrat member of the Commons Science and Technology Select Committee, said: "The medical risks of egg donation are low enough for women to be allowed to volunteer to donate for research, just as they can for the treatment of others, especially given the shortage of eggs and embryos."


SEE ALSO
Cloning research egg donor plan
14 Feb 06 |  Health

RELATED INTERNET LINKS
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites



FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

PRODUCTS & SERVICES

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific