Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education



Front Page

World

UK

UK Politics

Business

Sci/Tech

Health

Education

Sport

Entertainment

Talking Point

In Depth

On Air

Archive
Feedback
Low Graphics
Help

Monday, October 11, 1999 Published at 11:24 GMT 12:24 UK


Health

Anger as tobacco ad restrictions delayed

There is concern about the effect of tobacco advertising on teenagers

The government has been accused of appeasement after announcing it intends to soften a blanket ban on tobacco advertising due by the end of the year.


The BBC's Daniel Sandford: "The Department of Health is giving companies more time to make changes"
Ministers have granted concessions to the tobacco industry, to allow some promotions to be phased out over a longer period.

However the Tobacco Manufacturers Association (TMA) said the concessions would not affect its High Court challenge to the ban, due to start on Monday.

The TMA claims the proposed ban is illegal because it is based on a directive currently under consideration by the European Court of Justice.

Health Secretary Frank Dobson said the concessions were a "sensible compromise" between the health benefits of the ban and "legitimate concerns" of the tobacco industry.

Tobacco wars
  • The US legal battle
  • Tobacco economics
  • Smoking goes global
  • Cigarette health file
  • Timeline: the tobacco war
  • He said: "We have sought to bring in this ban in a way that both maximises the health benefits to be gained and minimises the impact on business.

    "The transitional arrangements prove that we have listened to genuine concerns."

    The blanket ban, originally announced in June, had been due to take effect from 10 December, outlawing all forms of advertising, apart from price lists and display material in shops.


    [ image: Anti-smoking campaigners Ash:
    Anti-smoking campaigners Ash: "advertisers have had long enough"
    The concessions will now delay elements of the ban by up to three years.

    The most visible advertising on posters, billboards and in the press will go in December, as originally planned.

    But the new timetable for other changes is:

    • March 2000 - final deadline for retailers to ensure their outlets comply

    • July 2000 - end of direct marketing campaigns and in-pack promotion schemes

    • July 2001 - companies which shared branding with tobacco products must ensure their branding is distinct

    • July 2002 - ban comes into force on tobacco advertising within in-flight magazines on flights operated by non-EU airlines and on EU publications sold in the UK.

    A spokesman for the TMA said: "The latest government concessions change nothing.

    "We are still proceeding with our court case against the government because we still believe that they are acting illegally and should await the European court judgement before implementing any restrictions."

    The anti-smoking group, Ash, gave a mixed response to the change.


    Ash's director, Clive Bates: "There is no need to give them any extra consessons"
    Ash's director, Clive Bates, said: "I don't know why the government is bending over backwards to appease the tobacco industry with these concessions.

    "Tobacco advertisers have been on notice since Labour published its manifesto in 1997 and have already had more than enough transitional time."

    But Mr Bates added: "We should still keep in mind and applaud the approaching end of tobacco advertising."


    [ image: Evan Harris said more young people would now become hooked on smoking]
    Evan Harris said more young people would now become hooked on smoking
    Professor Gordon McVie, director general of the Cancer Research Campaign, was angry at the delay.

    He said: "Frankly, I am extremely disappointed. I do not understand why they have done this and I cannot believe the Tobacco Manufacturers Association had any possible argument to put forward for a delay that could carry any weight.

    Dr Evan Harris, Liberal Democrat health spokesman said: "Every day's delay means more young people are seduced by tobacco advertising and become addicted to a product that will kill half of them."

    A spokeswoman for the Department of Health said the changes to the proposed timetable of the ban were "peripheral".

    "The actual ban on advertising will still come in from December 10 but these changes help corner shops and other retailers to comply," she said.



    Advanced options | Search tips




    Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©


    Health Contents

    Background Briefings
    Medical notes

    Relevant Stories

    10 Aug 99 | UK Politics
    Tory U-turn on smoking ads

    19 Jul 99 | UK Politics
    Tory attack on tobacco 'a joke'

    17 Jun 99 | Health
    UK stubs out tobacco ads





    Internet Links


    Tobacco industry information

    Action on Smoking and Health

    Department of Health

    Tobacco Manufacturers' Association


    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.




    In this section

    Disability in depth

    Spotlight: Bristol inquiry

    Antibiotics: A fading wonder

    Mental health: An overview

    Alternative medicine: A growth industry

    The meningitis files

    Long-term care: A special report

    Aids up close

    From cradle to grave

    NHS reforms: A guide

    NHS Performance 1999

    From Special Report
    NHS in crisis: Special report

    British Medical Association conference '99

    Royal College of Nursing conference '99