Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education

Front Page



UK Politics







Talking Point

In Depth

On Air

Low Graphics

Tuesday, May 18, 1999 Published at 07:08 GMT 08:08 UK


Doctors' call for ban on GM crops rejected

Oil seed rape has been genetically modified

The government has rejected a call by doctors for an open-ended ban on the commercial planting of genetically-modified crops.

Dr Jack Cunningham interviewed about the BMA report
A report from the British Medical Association claims that sufficient evidence that GM organisms are safe has not yet been gathered, and that they should not be released into the environment until the level of 'scientific certainty' makes it acceptable.

The BBC's Fergus Walsh: "The British Medical Association is urging an indefinate ban on GM foods"
The ban should continue, it says, until there is scientific consensus about the likelihood of long-term effects.

But the Cabinet Office Minister Dr Jack Cunningham told the BBC's Breakfast News that there was no evidence to justify a ban.

He said not even environmentalists supported an indefinite moratorium and claimed the BMA had "expressed satisfaction" with a government report on how GM food use is monitored.

Dr Cunningham said the review, written by the government's chief medical officer and chief scientific advisor and to be published shortly, showed no evidence for withdrawing any GM food currently on the market.

He added that the government was not giving in to commercial organisations and put health and safety at the top of its agenda.

But he said it had to ensure that biosciences were "properly managed in the interests of Britain and the economy as a whole".

Rowett Institute

The BMA call comes 24 hours before the publication of two high-level reports into the controversial scientist whose work sparked the original GM debate.

Dr Arpad Pusztai, from the Rowett Institute in Aberdeen claimed rats fed GM potatoes had suffered damaged internal organs and immune systems.

The institute accused him of publicising unproven theories, and confusing his results with those from other experiments.

On May 18, the influential Royal Society will release a review of Dr Pusztai's work, and the House of Commons Science and Technology Select Committee will publish its report into the handling of the affair.

The BMA report calls for the government's proposed regulatory body, the Food Standards Agency, to be established quickly, given control over GM food production, and even consider a complete ban on products which mix GM and non-GM ingredients.

Sir William Asscher, Chairman of the BMA's Board of Science and Education said: "Once the GM genie is out of the bottle, the impact on the environment is likely to be irreversible. That is why the precautionary principle is so particularly important on this issue."

The BMA also claims that the use of antibiotic-resistant 'marker genes' in GM crops could make human diseases more difficult to treat as so-called superbugs develop their own resistance.

The government would also have to step up its own disease monitoring procedures, says the report, to look out for new diseases possibly caused by GM foods.

Allergic reactions

[ image: Dr Vivienne Nathanson fears GM food will spread antibiotic resistance]
Dr Vivienne Nathanson fears GM food will spread antibiotic resistance
Dr Vivienne Nathanson, BMA Head of Health Policy and Research, told the BBC: "This is the first time that a group of doctors have said: `We think there is reason to be far more cautious, to take time in making sure we actually do understand the science.'.

"Because once we have discharged them into the environment, you cannot turn the clock back." The government currently allows limited planting of GM foods for research purposes, and will have to decide next spring whether to allow more widescale commercial planting.

A spokesman for GM producer Monsanto said: "How much more regulation do the BMA want? GM crops and GM foods are the most highly regulated novel products available."

Interviewed by the BBC, the government's Chief Scientific Officer Sir Robert May said that if a particular threat to health could be identified, regulatory bodies would take action.

He said: "That is a bit different from the vaguely non-specific thing of saying anything new might have something unexpected - and you could invoke that against any novel food."

David Curry MP, a Conservative member of the House of Commons Select Committee on Food Standards, told the BBC that there was no evidence 'that anyone could point to' of a medical risk.

But he added there was a lot of confusion around about GM food.

In an edition of the BBC's Panorama, broadcast on May 17, Prof Mike Roberts, from the Natural Environment Research Council, said that the GM crop trials he runs for the government could fail because of public pressure over the issue.

Advanced options | Search tips

Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©

Health Contents

Background Briefings
Medical notes

Relevant Stories

23 Feb 99 | Sci/Tech
GM food scare is 'bad science'

07 May 99 | Sci/Tech
GM pests bite back

26 Apr 99 | Health
Meningitis fear over GM food

02 Mar 99 | Sci/Tech
GM pollen warning

16 Feb 99 | Sci/Tech
Some GM foods may evade detection says report

17 Feb 99 | Sci/Tech
GM firms fined for safety breach

12 Feb 99 | Sci/Tech
GM foods: Environmental concerns

13 Feb 99 | Sci/Tech
Gene-altered food 'safe to eat'

12 Feb 99 | Sci/Tech
Genetic food safety row

Internet Links

British Medical Association

GM food links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

In this section

Disability in depth

Spotlight: Bristol inquiry

Antibiotics: A fading wonder

Mental health: An overview

Alternative medicine: A growth industry

The meningitis files

Long-term care: A special report

Aids up close

From cradle to grave

NHS reforms: A guide

NHS Performance 1999

From Special Report
NHS in crisis: Special report

British Medical Association conference '99

Royal College of Nursing conference '99