Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education

Front Page



UK Politics







Talking Point

In Depth

On Air

Low Graphics

Wednesday, May 12, 1999 Published at 19:11 GMT 20:11 UK


Night light 'damages children's eyes'

Children should sleep in the dark

Children who sleep with a light on during the night could be ruining their eyesight, scientists have warned.

US scientists have found that children who sleep with a light on are significantly more likely than children who sleep in the dark to grow up short-sighted and having to wear glasses.

BBC Health Correspondent James Westhead: "Children's eyesight is getting worse"
In the trials, children under the age of two who slept with a light on were five times more likely to be short-sighted than those who slept in the dark.

Toddlers who slept with a "night-light" were three times more likely to be short-sighted.

Short-sightedness, or myopia, is the inability to focus on distant objects. It is thought to be a risk factor for blindness in later life.

It is caused by excessive growth of the eyeball, which grows particularly quickly before the age of two. Scientists believe light at night may stimulate the eyeball to grow.

The US team questioned the parents of 479 children about whether their sons and daughters, before the age of two, slept with room lighting, a night-light or in darkness.

The children were aged between two and 16 at the time of the study, with an average age of eight.

The researchers found that 10% of children who slept in the dark were short-sighted, but for those who slept with a night-light the number who were short-sighted was 34%, and, for those who slept with a room light on, the figure was 55%.

Risk factor

Professor Richard Stone, from the Scheie Eye Institute at Pennsylvania University in Philadelphia, is part of the research team.

Professor Richard Stone explains the team's work
He said: "Our findings suggest that the absence of a nightly period of full darkness in early childhood may be an important risk factor in the future development of near-sightedness.

"It would seem advisable for infants and young children to sleep at night without artificial lighting in the bedroom until further research can evaluate all the implications of our results."

The researchers, who reported their results in the journal Nature, said their findings might explain why short-sightedness has become more common over the last 200 years.

Ten per cent of children now need to wear glasses.

Early findings

But Professor Stone told BBC Radio 4's Today programme it would be premature to say that light actually made children short-sighted.

BBC Radio 5's Science Specialist Matt McGrath offers his view of the study
"The study shows an association and is the first effort to tackle the problem. But the association is very strong, even if it does not establish a cause and effect."

Many researchers believe that an increase in close-up work, such as reading and writing, may be to blame.

But the authors of the new study speculate that greater ambient night-time levels associated with urban living might contribute to the growing rate of short-sightedness in developing countries.

Previous research on chicks has shown that the relative proportions of light and dark during the 24-hour day greatly affects eye growth and focusing development.

Parents 'should not worry'

Gill Adams, consultant ophthalmic surgeon at Moorfields Eye Hospital in London, urged parents not to worry about night-lights.

[ image: Gill Adams says light could be a factor in eye development]
Gill Adams says light could be a factor in eye development
She said: "The most important factor in a child later becoming short-sighted is whether or not the parents are short-sighted.

"Environmental factors may play an additional role."

Laura Galbraith, head of child clinical psychology at Fife Primary Care Trust, Scotland, based at Stratheden Hospital, said: "Ideally children should learn to cope with the dark, because, after all, darkness is part of life, and it will help them sleep better.

"We advise parents not to turn the light on when comforting their child because then light becomes associated with security and comfort, and is seen as a positive thing, while dark is seen as a negative thing.

"But we wouldn't force children to put up with the dark if it worries them. It's best to turn the light off gradually, maybe using a dimmer switch."

Other factors

Optician Ellot Most says factors other than sleeping in light might be to blame for poor eyesight.

[ image: Elliot Most says children watch too much TV]
Elliot Most says children watch too much TV
He said: "The necessity for children to spend a lot of time reading and writing, they are spending more time in front of the television and they are sitting in front of their computer games more, and that is influencing their eyesight."

BBC Radio 5 Science Specialist Matt McGrath said the research did not offer the final word on the subject.

"What the researchers are saying is that, in some respects, it's OK to leave the landing light on and the door open - they're not too concerned about ambient light exposure," he said.

"What they are concerned about is direct light exposure, and it's going to take a lot more research before they find out exactly what the link is."

Advanced options | Search tips

Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©

Health Contents

Background Briefings
Medical notes

Relevant Stories

29 Apr 99 | Health
Bionic eyelid passes double take test

22 Mar 99 | Health
Eclipse cooks eyeballs

17 Mar 99 | Health
Eyesight cure for the ageing

18 Feb 99 | Health
Bid to save world's eyesight

Internet Links

The eye in health and disease

Eye diseases


Moorfields Eye Hospital

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

In this section

Disability in depth

Spotlight: Bristol inquiry

Antibiotics: A fading wonder

Mental health: An overview

Alternative medicine: A growth industry

The meningitis files

Long-term care: A special report

Aids up close

From cradle to grave

NHS reforms: A guide

NHS Performance 1999

From Special Report
NHS in crisis: Special report

British Medical Association conference '99

Royal College of Nursing conference '99