[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Saturday, 1 November, 2003, 05:12 GMT
Hip op survival 'depends on area'
Hip replacement
Hip operations are common, but many patients die soon after
The speed with which hospitals operate on patients with broken hips can have an "enormous" bearing on their chances of survival, suggests new figures.

In some English hospitals patients can be four times more likely to die than in others, said the report, published in The Times.

An analysis of Department of Health data found many hospitals failed to operate within the target of 48 hours.

Patients were 60% more likely to die if they waited more than 24 hours.


One tenth of the 30,000 people who broke a hip every year died within a month, and one quarter within six months.

The cause of death was usually pneumonia or infection, according to the report.

But the Department of Health rejected the claim that waiting times had the impact on death rates the analysis claimed.

It argued patients with broken hips were often made to wait because they were too frail to undergo immediate operations.

It claimed the research - in which health company Dr Foster looked at hospital performance in England between April 1999 to March 2002 - did not take into account more recent improvements.

According to the Times, the safest place to break a hip was Weston-super-Mare in Somerset and the most risky were Southampton, and St Helens in Merseyside.

Rapid diagnosis

Surgery should ideally take place within 24 hours, according to the guidelines, but only a few hospitals manage it within two days.

Help the Aged told the newspaper the report provided yet more proof of a "postcode lottery" in the NHS.

Dr Tricia Woodhead, medical director at Weston General Hospital - which operates on 86 of its hip patients within 48 hours - said they had a system of fast-tracking people through the emergency department and up to the wards.

She said: "We tried to streamline how patients come in through A&E.

"There is a pretty rapid diagnosis - has this patient a broken hip or not?"

More than a third of hip break patients in Southampton waited longer than two days for an operation.

The Southampton trust said it was working hard to improve, by appointing more specialist medical and nursing staff, introducing a system to prioritise highest-risk patients and expanding operating theatre capacity and opened extra beds.

The Department of Health told the Times it had set up a programme to look at hip fractures, and was already seeing improvements.

The BBC's Sophie Hutchinson
"Every year 30,000... people are admitted to hospital with painful broken hips"

'Goo measure' could help hip ops
22 Oct 03  |  Health
Pensioner demands surgery abroad
03 Oct 03  |  Health
'Home in a day' hip replacements
02 Oct 03  |  Health
Broken hip survival lottery
22 Nov 01  |  Health

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific