[an error occurred while processing this directive]
BBC News
watch One-Minute World News
Last Updated: Wednesday, 17 September, 2003, 12:43 GMT 13:43 UK
Hospital beds 'blocked by elderly'
Some patients can wait over a month to be discharged
Up to 3,500 elderly people are needlessly stuck in hospitals across England every day, according to MPs.

A report by the Commons public accounts committee suggests one in three patients can wait more than a month before they are allowed to leave.

While these patients are well enough to be discharged, they are not well enough to go home.

However, the report shows councils are still struggling to find suitable accommodation for these patients.

MPs said the delays cost the NHS around 170m each year and mean that elderly people are taking up valuable beds that could be used by other patients.

The report acknowledges the government has significantly cut the number of delayed discharges since it came to office in 1997.

Problems persist

However, it warns problems persist because many hospitals are still failing to follow guidelines to help them tackle the issue.

MPs said trusts should start planning for the discharge of elderly patients much earlier than at present.

On any given day there are 3,500 older people waiting in hospital even though they are fit to be discharged
Edward Leigh MP
Public accounts committee

They also called for more cooperation between hospitals, local authorities and primary care trusts, which provide local health services.

They said more could be done to help elderly patients live at home, relieving pressure on local authorities to find them nursing home places.

They also urged ministers to address the shortage of physiotherapists and occupational therapists, who play a key role in deciding when elderly patients are able to be discharged or return home.

"Shortages of these professionals are a cause of discharge delays in many areas," the report said.

Johanna Power
Johanna Power broke her shoulder on August 22. On the 27th, she was declared fit to be discharged.
But she is still in the Homerton Hospital, in east London, three week's later, because of an argument over who should pay for her care.
She told the BBC: "I just feel like I'm taking the place up of someone who's critically ill when I could be in a home or somewhere."
MPs said the NHS and local authorities would have to work with private nursing home owners to solve the problem.

"The independent sector provides most of the care homes and home care services and without their full participation, the NHS is unlikely to reduce delayed discharges significantly," it says.

Conservative MP Edward Leigh, chairman of the committee, said urgent action was needed.

"It is intolerable that on any given day there are 3,500 older people waiting in hospital even though they are fit to be discharged.

"There is an urgent need for the Department of Health, health authorities, trusts and independent providers to work together better to plan care provision."

Health Minister Stephen Ladyman told BBC Radio 4's Today Programme the government was acting to combat the bed blocking problem.

Mr Ladyman said: "Over the last two years we have halved the number of people who are bed blocking, a recoup of 900,000 bed days every year.

"But we as a government have acknowledged that that is not good enough. That is why we have passed the Delayed Discharges Act, which forces local councils to take the issue seriously."

From next year, councils failing to find alternative accommodation for patients well enough to be discharged could face fines.

Extra money

But Paul Burstow, Liberal Democrat spokesman on older people, said: "Taxpayers' money is wasted on keeping people in hospital or readmitting the elderly to NHS beds, when what they need is good care at home, or a good care home."

The Independent Healthcare Association, representing private nursing homes, said extra money could solve the problem.

We have introduced new legislation to provide incentives for councils to promptly assess and arrange community care services for patients
Department of Health spokeswoman
"Patients are suffering and money is being wasted on expensive hospital care because homes are being starved of funds," said spokesman Andrew Fairburn.

"Two homes close every week, and about 12,000 beds have been lost in the last year, simply through under-funding."

Charities called on the government to address the problem.

Gordon Lishman, director general of Age Concern England said: "An urgent solution must be found to stop delayed discharges and older people get the care they need."

Jonathan Ellis of Help the Aged added: "Despite the overall fall in the number of delayed discharge, it is still the most frail and vulnerable older people who wait the longest for appropriate services."

Shadow Health Secretary Dr Liam Fox said: "Promises that this crisis will be resolved are simply not enough.

"Up and down the country elderly patients are suffering. The government should be ashamed."

  • Meanwhile, a report by the National Audit Office shows some trusts are doing better than others on introducing checks to ensure patients receive high-quality care.

    It found that so-called clinical governance measures varied across the country.

    The checks are designed to reduce risks and improve the quality of care given to patients.

    The BBC's Janet Barrie
    "The knock on effects can be alarming"

    MPs attack bed-blocking policies
    24 Jul 02  |  Health
    Bed-blocking: a fine approach?
    18 Apr 02  |  Health
    Bed-blocking a massive problem
    17 Apr 02  |  Health
    Q&A: Bed-blocking
    17 Sep 03  |  Health

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


    News Front Page | Africa | Americas | Asia-Pacific | Europe | Middle East | South Asia
    UK | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health
    Have Your Say | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
    Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific