BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in: Health
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Background Briefings 
Medical notes 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Sunday, 10 February, 2002, 00:47 GMT
Back pain heat therapy hope
Back pain can be debilitating for sufferers
Back pain can be debilitating for sufferers
People crippled by back pain could be helped by a new procedure which works by "cooking" discs.

The technique, called intra-disc electrotherapy (IDET), heats nerve endings, making them less sensitive and blocking pain signals from the discs.

Doctors who carry out IDET emphasise it is not suitable for all patients with lower back pain.

But they say for those it can help, it offers a less painful and much cheaper solution than spinal fusion - the standard treatment procedure in which two or more vertebrae in the spine are fused together using either bone grafts or metal rods.

I've seen the most grateful patients I've ever seen in my life

Brian Freeman, Queen's Medical Centre
Patients also have to have gone through physiotherapy, exercise regimes and pain relief treatments before they will be considered for IDET.

The procedure was developed in the US, and is only carried out at around six centres in the UK.

Doctors are still carrying out independent studies to support IDET's marketers' claims.

But Mr Brian Freeman, a spinal surgeon at Nottingham's Queen's Medical Centre, who performs IDET, said that he had seen many patients who had improved after the procedure.

Mr Freeman, who learnt the technique while studying in Australia at the Royal Adelaide Hospital said: "I thought IDET had enormous potential - and I've seen some dramatic improvements."

Scan needed

He said it was suitable for people whose movement was impaired, who may only be able to sit for 10 to 15 minutes before it became too painful.

Mr Freeman added: "The standard patient that would come to see me would be 45, with disabling lower back pain, who had tried all the conventional therapies."

Patients have to undergo a scan and an exploratory investigation to see how badly their discs are affected.

IDET is only suitable for people with one or two discs affected.

A hollow needle is guided into the affected disc, and an electrothermal catheter, a heating wire, passed through it into the disc.

Most of us are waiting for a trial. It's very difficult to evaluate its effectiveness

Philip Sel
British Association of Spinal Surgeons
This is heated up to 90C and tissue temperature goes up to 65 - 70C.

That is enough to destroy the nerve endings which are sending the pain messages to the brain.

Only the part of the needle which is in the disc is not insulated, so the patient's skin does not get burnt.

The procedure, carried out under local anaesthetic, takes less than an hour and does not need an overnight hospital stay.

The patient then has to wear a corset for the next six weeks and do nothing before starting an intensive course of physiotherapy.


Some doctors have suggested it is the physiotherapy rather than the procedure itself which makes the difference.

Philip Sel, secretary of the British Association of Spinal Surgeons, told BBC News Online: "Most of us are waiting for a trial. It's very difficult to evaluate its effectiveness."

But one patient said IDET had given her a "kick-start" to enable her to do the much-needed physio which she had been in too much pain to do before.

The alternative for patients is two-stage spinal surgery where each stage takes two hours.

Patients are then in hospital for a week, and it can take up to 18 months to recover.

The surgery can cost up to 3,000, whereas the needles used in IDET cost around 800 each.

Mr Freeman said: "If we are able to really define who will benefit from IDET, it could completely revolutionise the treatment of back-pain."

He estimated it could help 30% of patients he sees.

"I've seen the most grateful patients I've ever seen in my life."

See also:

03 Dec 01 | Health
Why back pain is hard to beat
04 Sep 01 | Health
Drivers 'risking spine problems'
27 Oct 01 | Health
Search for back pain cause
20 May 01 | Health
Back to nature for pain relief
13 Apr 00 | Health
Ceramic implants ease back pain
10 Feb 02 | Health
'My whole life has changed'
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Health stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Health stories