BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: Health
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Background Briefings 
Medical notes 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Thursday, 26 April, 2001, 16:29 GMT 17:29 UK
Gays 'have right to parenthood'
Campaigners want IVF for same sex couples
Gay rights campaigners have hailed a vote by the British Fertility Society in favour of equal parenting rights for lesbian and gay couples.

Peter Tatchell, of Outrage!, said the vote at the society's annual conference in Belfast represented a signficant breakthrough in the fight to make IVF techniques available to same sex couples.

This vote signals that key members of the fertility profession believe that discrimination against lesbian and gay couples is wrong

Peter Tatchell
He said: "This vote doesn't change the law but it does signal that key members of the fertility profession believe that discrimination against lesbian and gay couples is wrong."

BFS chairman Dr John Mills welcomed the outcome of the vote, but warned that gay men may not receive public support for their campaign.

About two thirds of delegates backed the motion tabled by Mr Tatchell and Manchester-based consultant gynaecologist Dr Anthony Nysenbaum supporting the right to same sex parenting.


Mr Tatchell, spokesman for gay human rights group OutRage!, told more than 100 top medics and scientists his argument was based on equality for all sections of society and a responsibility to safeguard children's welfare.

Peter Tatchell
Peter Tatchell spoke in favour of the motion
He claimed the publicly-funded NHS was discriminating against lesbians and gays in their fight to secure services such as IVF treatment and sperm donation.

He said: "The NHS is funded by taxation. Lesbians and gay men are taxpayers too and we have a rightful claim to the services we contribute towards providing.

"To require us to pay for services that we are denied is ethically indefensible."

He also argued the scale of planning involved in providing a child for gay couples through donor insemination and surrogacy methods often makes them better parents than their heterosexual counterparts.

And he quoted from a City University in London study to back claims that children of lesbian mothers suffer no disadvantage.

The research carried out by two professors over a 14-year period found only two of the 39 children studied grew up to be gay, he said.

Before Mr Tatchell put his case a preliminary vote on the motion found delegates split 50-50.

Insisting the swing proved the validity of his arguments Mr Tatchell added: "The vote clearly represents the views of doctors and scientists working in the field of human fertilisation.

"This is the popular vote by professionals in favour of same sex parenting."

Not representative

I do not feel that there is a mood in this country to support this at this time

Dr John Mills, British Fertility Society
Dr Mills, a consultant gynaecologist from Dundee, said the vote did not necessarily represent the views of the society as a whole.

He said: "This was a debate to stimulate discussion and early thinking in a process.

"Nothing has changed but in general terms we should be cautious of ruling out treatment for any groups on the basis of sexuality as well as race, religion and other social factors."

Dr Mills said a gay male couple would require much greater IVF surrogacy technology.

"I do not feel that there is a mood in this country to support this at this time.

"It's likely that more lesbian couples might seek to have a child and I think the vote carried out today perhaps represents support for these same sex couples rather than two men."

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
See also:

01 Jun 00 | Health
Gay men 'take more sexual risks'
31 May 00 | Health
'Screen gay men for cancer'
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Health stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Health stories