BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: Health
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Background Briefings 
Medical notes 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Thursday, 8 February, 2001, 00:04 GMT
Bypass ops 'lead to mental decline'
heart bypass operation
Thousands of bypass operations take place in the UK each year
Heart bypass operations may lead to long term mental decline, suggests a study.

Thousands of men and women undergo the operations each year, to replace sections of coronary artery which have become hardened and clogged, leading to heart disease.

A period of short-term mental decline has been noticed in some patients, but this often appears to disappear again within a few months.

However, researchers at Duke University Medical Center in the US may have confirmed the suspicion that many patients suffer some sort of mental decline even years after the operation.

They looked at 261 heart surgery patients before and after the operation had taken place, measuring short-term memory, attention, concentration, language comprehension, and spatial orientation.

Duke University
The research was carried out at Duke University Medical Center
Indeed, more than half of the group were discharged from hospital after the surgery with some form of cognitive deficit.

This, as expected, improved, with only a quarter of the group having persistent problem six months later.

However, when the same group was re-checked some five years later, 42% had suffered a measurable decline in cognitive ability compared to their pre-operation state.

While it might be expected that some people lose some mental ability as they age, this group suffered a decline more than two times that found in a control group of nearly 6,000 patients of similar ages.

Cause unknown

Dr Mark Newman, who led the research, said: "Little is more devastating to patient and family than for the patient to have a successful operation that prolongs life, but diminishes the quality of that prolonged life.

"Our results confirm long-term persistence of cognitive dysfunction and the importance of preventing these deficits."

It is not known precisely what causes these problems, although suspicion falls on the heart-lung machine, which circulates oxygenated blood around the body once the heart has been stopped so the delicate operation can take place.

It is thought that tiny blood clots may form, travel to the brain and lodge in blood vessels, depriving very small areas of the brain of a blood supply.

In the future, minimally-invasive heart surgery, which does not require heart bypass, may become more common.

A spokesman for the British Heart Foundation said that while cognitive decline following heart bypass surgery was not unknown, most people recovered in the months following the operation.

She said that she hoped the study would not scare patients into refusing heart surgery, as the benefits outweighed the risks.

She said: "The introduction of beating-heart surgery should eliminate this problem."

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
See also:

02 Feb 00 | Health
Heart surgeons use robot hands
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Health stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Health stories