BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: Health
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Background Briefings 
Medical notes 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Sunday, 17 December, 2000, 03:02 GMT
Beatle's mental health law warning
Olivia and George Harrison
Olivia and George Harrison survived a ferocious attack
Plans for radical reforms to mental health laws fail to address the real issues, the former Beatle George Harrison and his wife have warned.

They spoke out ahead of Health Secretary Alan Milburn's unveiling of significant changes to the legislation this week.

One of the key proposals contained in a government White Paper would allow victims to be told when their attackers are released from mental institutions.

George and Olivia Harrison, who underwent a knife ordeal at the hands of an insane man in their home a year ago, welcomed the reforms.

Major mistakes are being made regularly with devastating results, as in our case

George and Olivia Harrison
But in a letter to The Independent on Sunday newspaper, they suggested that Mr Milburn was in danger of "addressing the wrong end of the problem".

They wrote: "Since the attack, we have had a number of letters - both from people revealing horrendous attacks on them or their children by mentally ill people who have been released too early from mental hospitals, as well as parents of paranoid schizophrenics who have been treated with shameful inadequacy.

"There clearly need to be much stricter criteria applied and although it is impossible to generalise, clearly major mistakes are being made regularly with devastating results, as in our case."

Independent inquiry

Michael Abram was sent indefinitely to a secure psychiatric hospital last month for attacking the Harrisons at their home in Henley-on-Thames.

An independent inquiry is being held to examine Abram's medical history.

There has been criticism of doctors at a Liverpool hospital who allegedly mistook Abram's mental illness for drug addiction.

Michael Abram
Michael Abram: Misdiagnosis inquiry
Abram, 34, was cleared of attempted murder of Harrison and his wife.

He stabbed the musician 10 times in a frenzied attack on 30 December 1999.

The Harrisons' letter to the newspaper raises failures in the way Britain deals with those who are dangerously mentally ill and their victims.

They say that case law and human rights legislation lay down a positive duty on the state to protect those whose lives may be at risk by the criminal acts of others.

The White Paper is also expected to include the introduction of community treatment orders which force patients to comply wth their treatment after they have been released into care in the community.

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Health stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Health stories