Tuesday, June 2, 1998 Published at 18:40 GMT 19:40 UK
Mental health rights case goes to Lords
The House of Lords ruling could have wide implications
The case could mean tens of thousands of people with learning difficulties and mental health problems having to be reassessed.
The Lords began hearing the case of an autistic man, known as Leonard, on Tuesday. The hearing is expected to last until Thursday.
It follows an earlier Appeal Court decision that Bournewood hospital in Surrey was acting illegally by detaining him without his consent. He is now living with his carers.
If the hospital loses in the Lords, it will mean a huge increase in the use of sectioning under the Mental Health Act.
The Department of Health is supporting the hospital.
But opponents say it is a question of patients' rights. They believe mental health patients should be entitled to a regular review of their cases, which would be guaranteed under the Mental Health Act. The present informal admissions policy allows for abuse, they say.
The Department of Health says it will issue guidance after the outcome of the Lords hearing is known. This should be in around two months' time.
The NHS Confederation says it will force homes to change the grades of staff they employ for patients with dementia.
But mental health charity Mind, which is campaigning for more rights for patients, believes it will only apply to hospitals. It is supporting the Surrey case because it says it is good practice that patients should get regular reviews of their cases.