BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: Health
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Background Briefings 
Medical notes 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Thursday, 23 November, 2000, 15:02 GMT
No justice for shaken baby
baby brain
Emily Messer died from Shaken Baby Syndrome
A coroner has recorded an unlawful killing verdict on a 15-month-old baby even though no-one has been charged with her death.

Baby Emily Messer was shaken to death while only her parents and two other children were at home in Rochester, Kent, in December last year, an inquest heard.

The child had suffered "shaken baby syndrome", which happens when a baby's head is twisted and decelerated so violently that damage is caused to blood vessels in its brain.

Her death had originally been the subject of a murder inquiry and coroner Roger Sykes warned the child's parents Lisa, 30, and Stuart, 33, they should say nothing to the inquest which might criminally implicate them in their daughter's death.

'Entirely truthful'

The couple, who are now separated, both agreed statements they originally gave to the police were "entirely truthful".

We are not looking for any strangers in connection with it and if any further evidence is forthcoming the investigation will be continued

Detective Inspector Dave Withers

Neither would say what had happened between 7.30pm on 18 December when the children were put to bed and the discovery of their dead daughter at 8.30am the following morning.

Passing verdict at Mid-Kent and Medway Coroners' Court, Mr Sykes said: "It was obvious to the perpetrator that harm would be caused and that such action was therefore both unlawful and dangerous, even though the fact that she thereby lost her life was a matter of inadvertency as opposed to intent.

"I appreciate that this issue needs to be dealt with in a different arena and I would otherwise have wished to say a few words."

'Not an accident'

Home Office pathologist Peter Jerreat said the baby died from brain damage.

He told the inquest he believed the baby's death was not an accident.

"This could not have been the result of over vigorous handling.

"There would have been immediate noticeable effects, possibly drowsiness or unconsciousness and limpness.

"It would have been something that I do not think you could disregard."

After the hearing, Detective Inspector Dave Withers said: "This is a tragic death of a 15-month-old baby.

"If any further evidence is forthcoming the investigation will be continued."

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
See also:

05 Feb 99 | Medical notes
Shaken baby syndrome
27 Jul 99 | Health
Shaken baby to be taken into care
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Health stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Health stories