This transcript is produced from the teletext subtitles that are generated live for Newsnight. It has been checked against the programme as broadcast, however Newsnight can accept no responsibility for any factual inaccuracies. We will be happy to correct serious errors.
Battle that could make a sideshow out of Afghanistan 29/10/01
ROBERT DENSELOW:
This rough, rocky track, twisting
alongside a spectacular gorge,
leads to one of the most volatile
front lines in the world. This is
Kashmir - the setting for a bitter,
bloody dispute that has continued
for over 50 years and flared up
again this month. While attention
is focused on Afghanistan, less
than a day's drive away, the
struggle between Pakistan
and India for control of Kashmir
threatens the US-led coalition
against terrorism. At Chakothi,
the Pakistani army is dug-in with
a maze of trenches stretching
along the "line of control"
between the two sides that
have clashed so often in the past.
This exquisite, divided land could
lead to nuclear war. The issue of
Kashmir has led to two major
confrontations between India and
Pakistan. They are now both nuclear
powers. Despite the cease-fire, the
past month has not been good. There
have been artillery barrages across
the dividing line. Over in Indian
Kashmir, Islamic militants have
launched guerrilla and car bomb
attacks. For the Pakistanis, these
are freedom fighters, but in India
they're regarded as terrorists, in
league with Bin Laden and linked
with Afghanistan.
BRIGADIER MOHAN MOHAMMED YAQUB:
54 years since partition, these
pledges remain to be honoured, and
Kashmir continues to bleed and burn.
DENSELOW:
You need Pakistani army clearance
to come here. Visitors are treated
to a slick presentation on the
Pakistani view of the conflict - on
how unfair it was that the local
Hindu ruler ceded this Muslim state
to India back in 1947, and how the
fighting led to the split between
what the Pakistanis call Azad
Kashmir - Free Kashmir - and the
larger area controlled by India.
There's a lecture on the array of
Islamic militant groups that have
fought the Indian army in Kashmir
for the past 12 years, in which
35,000 people have died. India
has long portrayed Pakistan as
a terrorist, state promoting
Kashmiri militants, and in league
with the Taliban. It's harder for
India to be heard on this now
Pakistan is helping the US.
Standing on the front line
as we peered across at the Indian
troops over the valley, the
brigadier explained why he
thought India had launched an
artillery barrage this month.
YAQUB:
India was trying to take advantage
of the situation and trying to create
a situation where the tension
increases on the line of control - the
situation between Pakistan and
India comes to the stage where the
world worries about it and starts
talking to the Indian leadership.
They want to gain that importance.
DENSELOW:
Now there is a new relationship
between Pakistan and the US,
much to the fury of the Indians,
it's argued, will the US now help
Pakistan over Kashmir? General
Rashid Qureishi is the President's
official spokesman.
GENERAL BRIGADIER RASHID QUREISHI:
Not only the US, we hope the world
will help us in convincing India
that Kashmir needs to be resolved.
That's the only issue between India
and Pakistan.
DENSELOW:
Have the US given any commitments
to you on this?
QUREISHI:
I am not aware of commitments,
but when Secretary of State
Colin Powell was here, who
said in a statement, "Yes,
this is the issue between India
and Pakistan." He made it known
that the US would be ready to
assist if anybody asked for
assistance.
DENSELOW:
The Indians see it differently.
They'd argue that the mountains
of Kashmir hide training camps, and
point out the US has branded
at least one militant group as
terrorists with links to Bin Laden.
The Pakistanis say they give
political but not military support
to the militias, who only operate
and train inside Indian-controlled
Kashmir, though they do come
here to rest. All this has created
a diplomatic minefield for
the US and its allies. India and
Pakistan are members of the
coalition against terrorism, and
yet the US and the UK, and of
course India, have accused some of
the Islamic militias operating in
Kashmir and supported by Pakistan
of being terrorist. To make matters
worse, Pakistan today accused India
of suspected state terrorism.
QUREISHI:
They stage-managed an incident outside
the Srinagar Assembly, where a vehicle
was blown up and 40 people got killed
and injured.
DENSELOW:
And as Pakistan vows to track down those
responsible for yesterday's horrific and
unprecedented attack at a Christian church,
in the Pakistani town of Bahawalpur, in
which 17 Christians and a Muslim
policeman were killed, the president's
spokesman made another remarkable
allegation. He said he considered India
as a suspect.
QUREISHI:
These trained terrorists, we are not sure
whether they work from extreme religious
parties or are motivated by people from
across the border.
DENSELOW:
The Indians?
QUREISHI:
Yes. We are not sure as to who motivated
these people.
DENSELOW:
So you are blaming that attack on the
Indians?
QUREISHI:
I just give you facts. In Pakistan there
has never been friction between the
Muslims and the Christians. Never has
such an action taken place. It has taken
place in India, but not in Pakistan.
DENSELOW:
There was no firing over the line
of control this weekend. Instead, a
flurry of furious allegations
hurled from one nuclear power at
another. For the outside world,
Kashmir has become a forgotten
conflict, much as the war in nearby
Afghanistan was ignored until
September 11th. But if there is to
be peace and security in this
volatile region, it's vital that
the tragedy of Kashmir is finally
resolved.