Page last updated at 08:27 GMT, Monday, 15 February 2010

Ukraine: Tymoshenko vows to contest election result


The PM's critics say her refusal to accept the outcome damages Ukraine

The defeated candidate in Ukraine's recent presidential election run-off, Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko, has vowed to challenge the result in court.

In her first comments since Viktor Yanukovych was declared the winner, Ms Tymoshenko alleged widespread fraud and said he was not legitimately elected.

Mr Yanukovych has called on his rival to abandon her protests and resign.

His margin of victory was only 3.48% in a poll that international monitors said was an impressive display of democracy.

"I want to clearly state: Yanukovych is not our president," Ms Tymoshenko said in a live televised broadcast.

"Whatever happens in future, he will never become the legitimately elected president of Ukraine."

Not going to court would mean giving up Ukraine to criminals without a fight
Yulia Tymoshenko

But she said she would not call people on to the streets to protest, as she had done after the 2004 presidential election.

"I will not call another Maidan [Independence Square demonstration] and will not allow public protests," she said.

Mr Yanukovych was pronounced the victor six years ago, only for the result to be overruled because of vote-rigging. The Orange Revolution eventually brought Ms Tymoshenko's erstwhile ally, President Viktor Yushchenko, to power.


The prime minister said more than a million votes, which she said were decisive to the outcome, were invalid.

"With all this proof, I have taken the only possible decision: to challenge the results of the election in court. I will defend our state and the choice we made on the basis of legal documents," she said.

"Not going to court would mean giving up Ukraine to criminals without a fight."

On Wednesday, Mr Yanukovych demanded his rival resign as prime minister and go into opposition.

"I want to remind Ms Tymoshenko that the basis of democracy is the will of the people. Democratic leaders always accept the results of the elections. The country does not need a new crisis," he said.

The BBC's Daria Merkusheva in Kiev says Ukraine's Central Election Commission is expected to confirm Mr Yanukovych as president-elect early next week, after which the legal challenges are likely to start.

Ukraine has been in political deadlock for several years, undermining its ability to deal with a severe economic crisis. Analysts say a challenge by Mrs Tymoshenko would prolong the instability.

With Mrs Tymoshenko still heading the government, stalemate is likely to continue. Mr Yanukovych has said he wants to form a new coalition, and may try to call snap parliamentary elections.

BBC News website readers in Ukraine have been sending us their comments on this story. Here is a selection of their views.

E-mail sent in by reader

Since the Orange revolution, corruption is higher and the poor are poorer. Yanukovych has a lot of work to do. Ukraine will probably move nearer to Russia, which is in my opinion, the right thing to do. Tymoshenko is stopping progress, she knows the election was fair. I am looking forward to some stability - the bread and water I buy has gone up in price over 50% in the last year.
Bill, Kiev

E-mail sent in by reader

I was a legal observer of part of the election process and I should say nothing was wrong at my voting point, neither the poll process, nor the counting.
Ruslan, Kiev

E-mail sent in by reader

I agree with Ms Tymoshenko. There should be a recount of ballots, especially in Donetsk, Luhansk and Crimea regions where Yanukovych's Party of Regions has absolute political dominance. Moreover, if Yanukovych is confident of his victory, he should go for a ballot recount. There should be a recount to end this story!
Oleksiy, Kiev

E-mail sent in by reader

I remember the same situation just four years ago during the Orange revolution. Now we can see the incompetence of Tymoshenko's state. Our politics and politicians now are the main source of fun for people and comedy shows.
Alexsander, Donetsk

E-mail sent in by reader

Yanukovych is the elected president, whether you like him or not. This is called democracy. Tymoshenko wants power at any cost. She doesn't care about small things like the law or democracy.
Alex, Kharkiv

E-mail sent in by reader

People of Ukraine are tired of being in limbo. Ukraine needs a strong ruler who can tell people what to do, you might call it a dictator. Favours and backhanders are the way Ukraine works. I would like like to see the Mayor of Kiev start to clean up this city instead of pocketing tax payer's money.
A EU citizen, Kiev

E-mail sent in by reader

Despite the fact the election met legal and democratic requirements, it's not enough. Unfortunately it was just a choice between two evils. Either of them is a way to nowhere!
Artem, Donetsk

E-mail sent in by reader

I believe there were elements of "unfair play" but I also believe they were on both sides, so the cumulative effect should be neutral. Ms Tymoshenko's decision to challenge election results in court will prolong the agony of Ukrainian governance in the time of economic crisis.
Dima, Nikolaev and Kiev

E-mail sent in by reader

Both Mr Yanukovych and Ms Tymoshenko represent business tycoons and oligarchs. The problem with Ukraine is its elite is divided, thus preventing a clear winner to emerge. The winner may be undecided, but there is a clear loser - the Ukrainian people.
Masroor, Donetsk

Print Sponsor

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Sign in

BBC navigation

Copyright © 2018 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific