BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: World: Europe
Front Page 
Middle East 
South Asia 
From Our Own Correspondent 
Letter From America 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

The BBC's Joanne Gilhooly
"Those who remain will tell you that Badolato is dying"
 real 28k

Wednesday, 19 April, 2000, 21:09 GMT 22:09 UK
Italy: Immigration or extinction
The faces of Badolato: Most of the young have left the village
Badolato faces: Most of the young have left the village
Joanne Gilhooly in Badolato, southern Italy

The question of immigration in Europe is always controversial.

However, what if immigration were to be seen not as a problem to be solved, but as the solution to one of Europe's biggest dilemmas - how to replenish a shrinking population?

In Italy, birth rates are among the lowest on the continent.

The community of Badolato, in particular, has been more than happy to welcome asylum seekers as saviours.

It is a picture-perfect hill top town in southern Italy.

It is beautiful and quiet - in fact, it is rather too quiet and that is because most of its inhabitants have left.

A dying village

Badolato: A picture-perfect Italian village
Badolato: A picture-perfect Italian village

Those who remain will tell you that Badolato is dying.

Seven thousand people used to live in the town. Now that figure is closer to 400.

Most of the young have fled unemployment - a feature of the south - but Badolato is also a symbol of a real problem across Europe.

Birth rates are down, longevity is up. Italy has always been seen as the bastion of the big family but in fact its population is in steep decline.

Badolato citizens are living longer than before
Badolato citizens are living longer than before

Now it is feared that there will not be enough workers in the future to support the elderly who are living longer than ever before.

For 10,000 years, the fortress town had repelled foreigners. Two years ago, they were welcomed with relief - at last some young blood was back in town.

Warm welcome

1998: Italy-bound  Kurds rescued off a ship
1998: Italy-bound Kurds rescued off a ship

At the beginning of 1998, hundreds of Kurds, desperate enough to leave Turkey aboard an old rust bucket, were rescued off the southern coastline.

Around 400 mostly young men were brought to this village. The warm reception they found turned Badolato into a cause celebre.

Television crews arrived and the talk was of a town being brought to life again by asylum seekers.

Kurdish immigrants receive warm reception
Kurdish immigrants receive warm reception

Could this be the answer for Italy's other dying cities?

Daniela Trapasso of the Italian Council for Refugees says she was surprised and impressed by the welcome the asylum seekers received.

"I thought the people from the village will be scared of them but it was not like this," she recalls

"I was very emotional when I saw Italian people give food, bread and oil to the Kurdish neighbours."

Two years later, that warmth has not diminished.

Badalato's womenfolk think 'It's lovely to have them around'
Badalato's womenfolk: 'It's lovely to have them around'

Sitting around the piazza in weak spring sunshine, the old people are happy to talk about their visitors.

"It's lovely to have them around," they tell me.

"They never give us any problem and if there is something we can give them, we give it to them.

"We don't understand them and they don't understand us but they are good, and the more people we have around the better it is for everyone."

The few who do not want them here are given short shrift.

The Italian people are very friendly. Everything so far has been quite good, but what will happen to us in the future I just don't know

Nedim Palabiyik, Kurdish immigrant

The Kurds were housed in the town's long-abandoned school.

However, most of the original group have found work in Germany or elsewhere.

Nedim Palabiyik is one of the 50 or so who remain and they are frustrated.

"The Italian people are very friendly," he says.

"Everything so far has been quite good, but what will happen to us in the future I just don't know."

The promised funds from the government for housing and start-up businesses to encourage them to stay have never arrived.

The Badolato experiment, says Daniela Trapasso, is in bureaucratic limbo.

"A lot of people came here," she says.

Frustration: Kurd waiting for government assistance
Frustration: Kurd waiting for government assistance

"A lot of promises have been made but we have been waiting for this money for two years.

"This is a big problem. If you talk with our government they will tell you - 'Ah yes! Badolato! - a very good experience. We must learn from Badolato. There, there is civilisation.'

"But then - nothing."

Fewer babies

Yet the statistics are stark: too few people across Italy are having families.

A recent UN report gave worse projections for Italy than Italian experts themselves, sounding an SOS in Rome - in the next 50 years the population is expected to shrink from 57 million to 41 million.

Without "replacement migration" as it is called, the retirement age would have to be raised to 77 to maintain the ratio of four workers to every pensioner.

The president of the Rome-based Eurispes Research agency, Gian Maria Fara, has watched the birth rate halve since the 1960s.

Fara: "Italy needs at least 200,000 immigrants"

It is not good enough, he says, for the government just to turn a blind eye to illegal immigration.

"This will cause political problems but even the highest authorities of the Italian economy say that Italy needs at least 200,000 immigrants just to keep the status quo."

There are analysts who believe that the crisis is exaggerated.

They say that there have been periods of low reproduction before which have not caused great social or economic disruption.

Back in Badolato, there is good news according to Mayor Gerardo Mannello: the money to restore 20 houses for the Kurds has finally arrived.

Rare sight: there are only about 20 children left in the village
Rare sight: Only about 20 children remain in the village

He believes that the government now understands the importance of immigrants in Italy and he is confident that soon they will be seen as essential to the economy - especially in the South.

For now, there are about 20 children - Italian and Kurdish - left in Badolato.

Cycling around the lanes and kicking a football around in the evening, they bring the piazza some much-needed life.

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
Europe Contents

Country profiles
See also:

01 Aug 99 | Europe
Gypsy boat intercepted by Italy
01 Apr 00 | Europe
Following the route to refuge
21 Mar 00 | Europe
Italy looks to migrants
02 Nov 99 | Europe
Stowaways die in ferry fire
26 Aug 99 | UK Politics
Straw: Asylum is 'European problem'
19 Apr 00 | Europe
Italian PM determined to go
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to other Europe stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Europe stories