Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: World: Europe
Front Page 
Middle East 
South Asia 
From Our Own Correspondent 
Letter From America 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 
Monday, 7 February, 2000, 00:03 GMT
Doubt over Nato's Kosovo toll

plane High-altitude bombing increased the risk of misses

About 500 civilians were killed by Nato's air campaign against Yugoslavia during the Kosovo conflict last year an independent investigation has concluded.

The New York-based Human Rights Watch group says civilian fatalities occurred in some 90 incidents - about three times the number accepted by the military alliance itself.

Kosovo: Special Report
Its report discounts claims by the Yugoslav authorities that the civilian death toll from the air attacks in Kosovo and Serbia may have approached 5,000.

But it says Nato could have done more to minimise the number of non-combatants killed by its raids and is critical of the use of cluster bombs.

The report is likely to renew the controversy over the alliance's conduct during the war and its reliance on high-altitude bombing.

Jamie Shea Nato spokesman Jamie Shea had to apologise for bombing blunders
Nato has never given an estimate on the number of individual civilian deaths caused by its actions.

But Pentagon spokesmen have previously conceded that there may have been what they term "collateral damage" in some 20 to 30 incidents.

Many observers believe a definitive calculation of the full human cost of the air campaign is probably impossible.

Air campaign criticised

The Human Rights Watch report, compiled after visits to more than 90 towns and villages in Yugoslavia, is the first independent assessment based upon a detailed research.

It says that there were civilian deaths in some 90 separate incidents.

Civilian casualties proved a propaganda nightmare for Nato
About a third of these incidents were in Kosovo, several relating to air attacks against road convoys.

The report says that Nato pilots should have done more to identify targets properly though it also points to evidence that in at least one case, Yugoslav forces used displaced civilians as human shields.

The report makes particular criticism of Nato's use of cluster bombs near populated areas.

It asserts that after one particularly bad incident of cluster munitions going astray in Nis, the United States stopped using the bombs, but it says that British aircraft continued to do so.

Human Rights Watch also says that a small number of the targets chosen were not legitimate military locations - not least the Serb Radio and Television headquarters in Belgrade.

Nato insists - as it did throughout the campaign - that every effort was made to minimise civilian casualties.

And it says much greater loss of life among ethnic Albanian civilians was caused by Yugoslav paramilitary forces.

High-altitude failures

However, critics have long accused Nato of being reckless with the lives of Yugoslav civilians.

embassy The bombing of the Chinese Embassy caused an international outcry
Although Nato's pilots put themselves out of the range of Serb anti-aircraft fire when they flew at high altitudes the accuracy of their targeting was diminished - increasing the chances of civilian casualties.

Many commentators have claimed that the tactic was partially inspired by the fear that the loss of pilots would have undermined the unity of Nato members to use military action to end Serb ethnic cleansing in Kosovo.

But as a result there were a series of blunders when Nato hit hospitals, civilian trains and a convoy of fleeing refugees.

In the most embarassing incident the Chinese Embassy in Belgrade was largely destroyed even though the building's identity was clearly marked on street maps.

Nato has denied subsequent media claims that the strike was not a mistake and was intended to knock out a Serb communication centre that China was said to be secretly allowing to operate within its embassy.

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
Europe Contents

Country profiles

See also:
01 Jun 99 |  Europe
Why 'precision bombing' goes off course
01 Jun 99 |  Europe
Nato's bombing blunders
31 May 99 |  Europe
Civilian deaths 'necessary price'
01 Jun 99 |  Europe
Nato 'bombs apartment block'
31 May 99 |  Europe
Picture gallery: Nato destruction
01 Jun 99 |  UK
Times journalist 'amazed to be alive'
31 May 99 |  Europe
Nato 'hit old people's home'
28 Apr 99 |  Europe
Nato admits civilian strike

Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites
Links to other Europe stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Europe stories